The budget debate over, Government and Opposition have now locked horns as the prospect of a general election begins to loom larger on the horizon. They will be engaged in combat practically until Christmas Eve, by which time they will have just about exhausted themselves and be ready for a brief holiday.
Come New Year’s Day, it will be no holiday for the hard-pressed tax-paying electors (as distinct from tax-evaders)
This is not what the Gonzi government and the PN propaganda machine would have us believe. The latter has been fully mobilised with its full paraphernalia to convey the impression that the economy has been turned around, and that the government’s finances are no longer in a parlous state.
In fact, a selection of sound bites has filled the airwaves, and a narrow range of satanic verses dominates the print media to hammer home a simple message which says: “After a year of sacrifice, the Maltese economy has found its strength. We are moving in the right direction. There will be no new taxes. The budget for next year reflects the wishes of the silent majority that wants to see a balance between economic growth and the distribution of wealth. The budget will impose no new burdens on the people.”
Fact and fiction
This is a travesty of the truth. While it is correct to say that the deficit has been reduced, it is just as true that, by year’s end, the national debt will continue to peak steadily at Lm l,400 million, in spite of the fact that the Government has been selling the family silver. Public debt-servicing costs increased by over Lm2 million to reach Lm77.8 million for this year.
It is also correct to say that total tax revenue accruing this year exceeded the estimated target to reach Lm802 million, and is estimated to escalate to Lm851 million next year – an additional tax squeeze of Lm49 million!
The government will not only have spent this windfall by the end of next year but will have overspent it to the tune of a further Lm41million, to meet all its requirements, inclusive of capital expenditure and debt-servicing.
Surely, an economy that continues to labour under excessive debt, and a public sector that continues to spend beyond its means, are not moving “in the right direction” by any stretch of the imagination.
Casuistry
The figment that the budget will not call for new taxation next year is another piece of casuistry. Suffice it to say that the government anticipates an increase in revenue for the year 2007 amounting to a further Lm27 million.
A substantial part of this will come from taxes on fringe benefits (many of which form part of collective agreements and some sanctioned by the Minister himself) and from earned salary increments.
This sustained pressure on taxpayers will escalate from a bonfire to a conflagration.
Why did the government have to blow so many trumpets and to beat so many drums, before and during the last budget debate, unless the theatrical effect was necessary to appease its foot soldiers?
The basic weakness of the Gonzi budget is bound to sink in before long because, for the second year running, the government has opted to squeeze middle-class earners and pensioners until the pips squeak. It has delivered hammer blows for a second year, notwithstanding the groundswell of public resentment.
Right Strategy
The right strategy would have been, from the beginning, to incentivise investment and growth and spur the players capable of starting the economic engine.
Instead, the government opted to concentrate on stepping up direct and indirect taxation, in order to boost revenue and keep up with increased spending and a broad range of EU-related commitments, which are going to demand increases in public expenditure at short notice, rather than at leisure.
At this point in time, it is necessary to give the utmost priority to initiatives likely to augment Malta’s income, by tapping new sources of foreign earnings, and by stepping up productivity and efficiency. Unless new wealth is created through new initiatives, there is a limit to the Government’s ability to draw more blood from Maltese stone.
I believe that a stage has been reached where the silent majority will draw a line between the embroidery of partisan politics and the pragmatism of survival.
The expanding “middle class” that was upwardly mobile in the more recent years now finds itself in the line of fire. It wants a strong hand to protect its defences instead of undermining them.
The private sector of the economy and the middle class know, as surely as night follows day, that they cannot bear the strain, and that something will have to give, unless they have the freedom and inducement to run the economic engine that generates growth and creates wealth.
John Maynard Keynes could not have put it better:
“It is enterprise which builds and improves the world’s possessions. If Enterprise is afoot, Wealth accumulates whatever may be happening to Thrift, and if Enterprise is asleep, Wealth decays, whatever Thrift may be doing” (Treatise on Money.)
[email protected]