The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Raphael Don’t vote, keep Tonio

Malta Independent Sunday, 24 December 2006, 00:00 Last update: about 15 years ago

The Gift of Life petition in favour of constitutional amendment is being given outstanding publicity by liberals not openly opposed to GoL’s pro-life stance but vehemently opposed to its obscurantist thrust. While GoL would like to polarise the country on pro-life and pro-choice lines, the liberals are polarising on a liberal vs conservative divide. I have always been pro-life on the abortion issue and can claim some kudos as a liberal too. It appears to be something of a challenge for some to understand. Too bad.

In politics it is best to be in a position to sell something simple, even stupid. In this case I am not. Too bad for me. Sometimes it is simply not possible to reduce things to the one-liners that appear to be consumed with greater relish. Everybody who has ever given the issue of abortion some serious thought must realise that it is not at all a simple matter. It should give those on both sides of the divide a duty to make allowances for one another, to respect one another’s right to hold an apparently opposite opinion. It appears to be altogether beyond us to manage this.

I am, and have always been, pro-life. I am, and have always been, passionately opposed to the mixing of religion with politics. I am not pro-life because I am a Catholic. I put it down to my Catholic education that I defend freedom at every possible point in order to give value to the choices we make. If conservative Catholics find that shocking, they have a weird way of interpreting their religion. If liberals snort at it, how liberal are they?

It appears that neither side grant me the right to hold my position. Tough.

It is no small satisfaction to me that I helped defeat the original GoL proposal to graft a bit of the criminal code into the Constitution lock, stock and barrel. It made many GoL supporters suspect me of being a closet pro-choicer. Now that I have expressed my compliance with the statement made in the new constitutional amendment proposal, I have the liberals accusing me of being a turncoat. It feels just like defending the environment in the 1980s, when everybody else was keen on mutual slaughter, which was more important to them at the time. It feels like setting up the Greens in 1989 to be suspected of being blue by the reds and red by the blues. It feels like home.

I opposed the original amendment proposal because it would have made it almost impossible to amend the criminal code provisions on abortion that are currently so draconian that they are even contrary to Catholic doctrine. Not even the Catholic Church condemns abortion in the case of an ectopic pregnancy nor in the case of the administration of abortifacient cancer treatment. Our criminal code currently prescribes three years’ imprisonment for all those involved. Of course we get around it in a very Mediterranean sort of way and nothing of the kind happens in practice. Our parliament is quite happy with the arrangement.

Having built up enough steam to burst their boilers, GoL could not simply pack up and go home. They came up with a Mk II constitutional amendment adding the words “from conception” to the right to life. Reading the text as it is proposed to be amended, it occurred to me that it would be aesthetically unpleasant and a legal tautology, but a declaration of the proposers’ position and mine.

The rights in the constitution are granted to “persons”. A foetus, let alone a fertilised ovum, is not a person at law and will not become one through this amendment. To qualify for the right to life, one must already be a person. To protect from conception the life of a person already born is a task completed before it is begun. In our bi-millennial legal history, persons, the subjects of rights and duties, are only those born and viable.

This may turn a thousand knickers into a twist but it is our law and it has been so since Roman times. It is not going to change because GoL add something declaratory to our constitution. To claim that it will mean the banning of the contraceptive pill, IUDs or IVF is pseudo-legal scaremongering which I place on a par with the showing of late term abortion films to youngsters in order to traumatise them into the pro-life camp: ridiculous, unfair, disgusting.

When GoL activists informed me of the change in their proposal, my first reaction was the same as that of Dr Adrian Vassallo, who appears to have responded by saying that there were more urgent things to be dealt with. They insisted, and I went further than Dr Vassallo and told them that I thought their campaign was counterproductive and that while the amendment would have no legal or practical effect, it would certainly drive their opponents to coalesce. I am pro-life but I have more than a few reservations about the GoL campaign. They persisted and in exasperation I wrote back that I am in favour of the protection of life from conception, if that was all they wanted to hear. They asked whether they could make it public and I replied that they could tell the world. The world already knew.

Now I am accused of being a political opportunist, a turncoat and a legal weasel. What a debate. Raphael Vassallo, in last Sunday’s piece in this newspaper, mourned the fall of the mighty. I have no reason to suspect myself of being mighty and less of having fallen. I have repeated for the umpteenth time what I have always said, written and held as my personal opinion. It also happens to have been the policy of the party I have led since the year it was founded, years ahead of the PN smear campaign and aeons before GoL itself was conceived.

Of course the fuss is not about my opinion on abortion but centres around the fact that my expression of it appears to endorse the GoL campaign, quite apart from the abortion issue. GoL have behaved like the champions of benighted conservatism, provoking liberal outrage not so much by the substance of their campaign but because of the methods they have adopted. They are also rolled into one messy ball with the absurd and undemocratic methods adopted by Minister Tonio Borg to garner consensus for the GoL campaign Mk I.

I suppose the anti-GoL camp would have preferred me to remain silent. It was not an option for me. The GoL campaign has been reduced to a mere declaration, a bald, simplistic, political statement with which I happen to agree. The whole campaign is a whale-sized red herring that the anti-GoLs have swallowed whole. That in itself does not give me sufficient reason to withhold an opinion that I had already stated publicly several times before. Of course there are a million miles of matters more urgent than this constitutional amendment on the country’s agenda. So what? Asked whether I am pro-life or pro-choice, I did not feel it would be acceptable to reply that I was too busy to bother.

Once the Maltese polarise on an issue there are no half measures, no space for reservations, no quarter asked or granted. We are either friends or enemies, together against the world or in a fight to the death. Raphael Vassallo headlined his piece with Vote Harry get Tonio. It made me realise once more that I am in politics precisely to oppose this attitude that both GoL and anti-GoL seem to share in equal measure.

The abortion issue in a country where all three political parties are officially and publicly pro-life is political hot air. The conservative-liberal squabble is more interesting but almost equally unsubstantial. The false conservatism, the hypocrisy, indeed the detachment between public life and private reality, cannot be addressed by liberals without them taking political action. Writing newspaper articles or even disgorging one’s spleen anonymously in internet blogs changes very little.

Unless a third party breaks the mould of Maltese politics in the next election, stagnation and unreality will extend further into our future. We Greens are doing our utmost and welcome the help of those who share our views, share them with reservations or even have a distaste for them but see the need for an ad hoc alliance in the face of stagnation. If someone else can do better than we have done, they are welcome to the laurels and will have our support and cooperation.

It has taken 17 years for many people to realise that we are neither Red nor Blue but Green. Many thousands still find it convenient to suspect us of being either closet Blues or closet Reds. We have learnt to take it in our stride. With this latest furore I have come to realise that we have not yet managed to come across, even to those we thought were closest to us in thought, with our message of political inclusion, of a loose alliance against red blue dogmatism.

If some liberal anti-GoLs expect me to tell fibs or to waffle in order not to seem to take wind out of their sails, they should realise that they are behaving like a traditional political party safeguarding its dogma against the slightest hint of heresy, insisting on keeping up appearances.

If addressing the stifling status quo is their priority, creating a new dogma is a pretty odd way of going about it. If others feel that it is more effective to keep clear of the working end of politics, it is their choice. If some feel that they will preserve their intellectual purity by going abroad on election day, that is fine and dandy by me. In the face of our political situation, it seems to me about as effective as the GoL campaign that they have helped along enormously on its way to nowhere in particular.

If some others take this as a personal challenge to them to actually do something, I take this opportunity to let them know that there are endless vacancies for them in the Green campaign team. If the Greens are not as good as they would like them to be, this is their chance to make them as good as it gets. Either that or they keep their options firmly limited to bad, worse and nothing at all.

Dr Vassallo is Chairman of Alternattiva Demokratika – the Green Party www.alternattiva.org.mt www.adgozo.com

  • don't miss