The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

Fast Forward to the 18th century

Malta Independent Sunday, 1 April 2007, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Instead of becoming more aware of the importance of separating church and State, the government seems to be going out of its way to make a virtue of entangling the two. The politicians who lead it – and the people who follow – do not appear to understand that there is a happy medium between the attitude and behaviour of Dom Mintoff towards the Church and doing what the government does now.

The confusion is partly because of widespread ignorance among the Maltese about the history and nature of democracy. The separation of Church and State is the result of the ideas that began to take shape in Europe in the 18th century. Up until then, Europeans took it for granted that they would be ruled and punished and forced to live their lives according to the dictates of the dominant religion – Protestantism in England, for example, and Roman Catholicism in France – while those who refused to comply, or who espoused other religions, were persecuted and discriminated against. In other words, life in Europe until the end of the 18th century was like life in Iran today, and for the same reason. People in Europe believed then, as some people in the Middle East do today, that if theirs was the one true religion, then it would suffice as a system of government and the basis for punishing people, policing them, and rewarding them.

We are scandalised at the way countries like Iran and Afghanistan are governed, but on close examination it is not the fact that they are governed according to religious laws that bothers us so much as the religious laws themselves, which we think odd, sexist and even cruel. The evidence that this is what annoys us is to be found in the fact that we are not similarly bothered by countries governed according to the dictates of religions we approve of, like Roman Catholicism. We are seemingly incapable of grasping the concept that it is possible to approve of and even to espouse a religion while opposing any attempt to run the country according to its rules and policy. Indeed, it is not just possible; it is essential. But understanding this demands a certain kind of education, at school, at home and even at university, that here in Malta is conspicuous by its absence.

As though to illustrate this, a letter was published in one of the newspapers from a man, who wrote: “The Church is not the State, nor is the Church the State. Notwithstanding this, you may have a situation where the people who form the Church are the same, or almost the same, people who form the State. If these people happen to be practising Catholics, the natural consequence will be that the State legislates according to the teaching of the Catholic Church.” That shocking Statement reveals that the writer is completely unaware of the 18th century thinking and events that changed Europe permanently and made it what it is today: a place where religion is a private and personal matter that is respected in public but not directed or championed by the State.

In Malta, we choose to pretend, or perhaps we genuinely do not know, that the Age of Enlightenment ever happened. We see nothing wrong in our government running the place according to Catholic mores, because we’re Catholic, after all. No, for the thousandth time, no: that’s not the point. However Catholic we are, the government has no business in making laws and policy according to Catholic dictates – because the laws of the country, and the policy of its government, should not be wrought to fit in with the dominant religion, or with any religion at all for that matter. The separation of Church and State is not there to oppress people. It is there to protect them, and this need for such protection comes from a long history in Europe of religious persecution, oppression, and injustice committed in the name of one religion or another, by powers that were secular and religious rolled into one.

We have an example of just how this happens in modern-day Malta, where injustice and oppression are the result of the Roman Catholic-dictated refusal of one government after another to legislate for divorce. I won’t mention abortion in the same context, because the arguments against it are not simply religious, and those who argue against it purely on religious grounds are lacking in imagination. There are several humanist grounds, too.

But I have been through all that already. What prompted this article were three news stories appearing in rapid succession. The first is that the government is putting out funds for young people who want to accept the Archbishop’s invitation to join him on his trip to Australia, where he will meet the Maltese community. The government is wrong to do this – shockingly wrong. It has no business offering thousands of liri to those who want to go on religious jaunts. If it has Lm5000 to spend on young people, then it should use the money to pay for a couple of scholarships for good students, who are studying the sort of subjects that may yet drag us out of the mire of ignorance in which we have wallowed for far too long now. There’s another point: it is a truism that he who invites also pays. It is the Archbishop who has extended this invitation to young people to join him in Australia, so it is the Curia who should be putting up that Lm5000, and not the government, using the money people have paid in taxes in the hope of getting some return in the form of secular services. That sum would buy some useful equipment for our woefully under-equipped health centres.

There’s more. The Education Minister has announced that there is to be yet another school holiday – on 4 June, the day after the canonisation of Dun Gorg Preca. Laugh, if you must. I might be able to understand, at a stretch and burying my scepticism about saints and my horror of any mix-up between Church and State, a holiday on the day of the canonisation. But the day after? The reason for this crazy move is that the many teachers who are members of the M.U.S.E.U.M. (and here I repress a shudder) are going to Rome en masse to cheer on St George Preca. They’ll be on the flight back to Malta the following day. So, instead of putting out a stop-leave order for teachers on that day – because of course they have to be in Rome as the sainthood won’t proceed without them – the Education Minister has ordered all schools to close for the day – even private schools and independent schools which have nothing to do with the government or the Church, and even less to do with the M.U.S.E.U.M.

There’s even more. One of my sisters called the other day suggesting a quick holiday in Rome some time around 4 June. “We won’t have to pay the departure tax,” she said. “Might as well go up with the Dun Gorg fan club and then scarper.” Forget it, I said. I’ve just been on flights to and from Catania which were full of shrieking and babbling Sicilian teenagers, and the thought of being packed into a plane full of Dun Gorg Preca devotees is enough to finish me off. The government, not content with giving thousands of schoolchildren and their teachers the day off – which has the knock-on effect of forcing hundreds of mothers to take a day’s leave of absence from their own jobs – has also waived the Lm20 departure tax for those journeying to Rome for the canonisation of Dun Gorg.

Why it took this absurd and objectionable decision is quite beyond me. The tax is never waived even for more deserving causes – like desperate people going away for cancer treatment, or to visit stricken relatives. And presumably the members of the M.U.S.E.U.M., who are not exactly known for their high-rolling lifestyles, can afford the Lm20 and would have gone to Rome in any case. A better and more appropriate gesture by the government would have been to whip that 20 quid off them all the same and donate it to the children’s homes. Ah, but that would be discrimination against Dun Gorg fanatics – and it wouldn’t occur to the Christians off to Rome in a frenzy for their saint to make the charitable offer themselves, would it? They’d rather get the discount from the government.

* * *

For those of you who wanted to know why I wasn’t here last week: my right wrist was broken. Perhaps if I drape one of Dun Gorg Preca’s socks over it, it might get better faster and I’ll find myself singing with the M.U.S.E.U.M. people, wearing something delightful in dark flammable polyester (careful with those matches!), in the middle of St Peter’s Square. And if you want me punished for saying that, you have encapsulated the argument as to why the laws of the State should never be the laws of religion: to protect people like me from people like you.

  • don't miss