From Ms M. Fenech Gasan, Ms A. Mifsud, Ms J. Borg Cardona et al

Robert Arrigo’s letter to the press two weeks ago calling for a moratorium on more construction in over-developed areas like Sliema, was a courageous suggestion, which was however totally undermined by the refusal of his wife (the Sliema council mayor) and other Nationalist Party councillors to endorse it in a local council vote proposed by AD and Labour councillors.

We feel that the mayor’s proposal to meet with the Prime Minister was an empty gesture, and likely to remain just that. Will the Prime Minister not correctly state that decisions on development are in MEPA’s hands?

And will MEPA not, in turn state that it can only follow the approved Local Plan? But, as is blatantly evident, instead of improving the situation in Sliema as has been claimed, the Local Plan actually helps speed up Sliema’s destruction. The heights set out in the Local Plan are supposed to echo the “predominant height” on each block, but in reality most inland blocks are now allowed to reach four, five and six floors even where only three out of 10 houses go higher than two floors, as can be seen in many narrow streets.

These changes in the Local Plans were carried out without adequate public consultation, as the plan shown at the time did not indicate the added height and none of the public’s submissions requested the raising of the building heights, quite the opposite in fact. This indicates that the Sliema Local Plan is in violation of the EU Directive on public consultation, as it was ratified some days after this came into force locally. And, while MEPA will no doubt claim that its one session held years ago constituted full consultation, the Ombudsman’s report on the Mellieha Local Plan, as well as that of MEPA’s Auditor, have both been critical of the lack of real consultation on the Local Plans. Furthermore, on the subject of lack of public consultation in Malta, the EU Infringements Unit has clearly stated that it is not enough to carry out the minimum possible in order to satisfy the letter of the law, while failing to respect the spirit of the law.

Although MEPA’s bible, the Structure Plan, indicates that the granting of permits should take into consideration the surrounding context, and “maintain the good visual integrity of the area in which it is located”, requests for MEPA to judge applications in the light of neighbouring over-development has been met with the curt reply that “MEPA can only judge each case on its own merit”. Thus Tigne residents are going to be choked by the exhaust fumes of approximately 3,000 more residents’ cars not to mention the traffic of thousands more cars generated by additional commercial activity in spite of the fact that Sliema already has a surfeit of shops and offices. All along, Sliema residents are having their physical and mental health undermined by 13 hours a day of dust, unbearable noise and fumes. Not to mention the constant worry of dangers that construction brings with it and the wholesale destruction of Sliema’s distinctive architecture and character.

Sliema residents cannot be fooled any longer. It is about time the Sliema council finally begins to take decisive action for the good of the people they should be representing, unless the derision poured on public suggestions at the last meeting is typical of their attitude towards Sliema residents. Until Robert Arrigo and the Nationalist local councillors decide to challenge the Local Plans by every means at their disposal, their words will remain no more than hollow pre-election manoeuvres, also because a moratorium on new construction is a rather far-fetched solution that can only be passed by an Act of Parliament. Therefore, a more workable solution, and one that is also fairer to all parties, might be an annual limit on the number and type of new units to be permitted in Sliema and similar areas.

We invite all Sliema residents who feel strongly on this matter to contact us by e-mail on [email protected] in order to express any views or suggestions they have on the above matter.

Marie Louise Fenech Gasan, Angela Mifsud, Joan Borg Cardona, Henry J. Bonett, Margaret Bozzino, Andrew Pizzuto, Joe Morana, Suzanne Bonello, Joseph Bozzino, Louise Mifsud, Carmel Aquilina, Rose Aquuilina, Gillian Foley, Jason Caruana, Franco Buttigieg, Horace Aquilina, Anna Buttigieg, Mary Rose Bonett, Joe Gerada Azzopardi, Heather Brown, Jason Kitney, Marie Benoît, Fleur Vella, Christian Mifsud, Philippa Mifsudm, Brigid Garroni, Lilian Pace, Anthony Pace, Georgette Booker, Andrea Garroni, Enrica Garroni, Albert E. Vella, Mario Grungo, Bernardette Grungo, Sidney Whitehead et al