A reader got in touch after my column last week on the large number of babies being born out of wedlock, to use the archaic term. Twenty per cent of Maltese babies are now born to parents who are not married to each other. My correspondent pointed out that the lack of divorce (some of these parents are married, only to somebody else), and older women determined to have a child even without a man around, are not the only reasons behind this alarming figure.
What about those couples who choose not to marry even when they have children, she asked? The mother pretends that the father is unknown, or that he has abandoned her, and then she can collect a social security cheque. Meanwhile, the father holds down a full-time job so that the social security is extra money for jam – and the mother doesn’t have to take on work because she’s being paid by the government to stay at home. They live together as man and wife, except that they aren’t.
Well, I know that this happens a lot, but it merits a whole discussion unto itself. The first thing that strikes me is this: are the women in this situation what I call “cunningly stupid”, or are they just plain nuts and irresponsible? They have foregone the rights and financial security of marriage – including the right to live in the home even if their partner has bought and paid for it before marriage – for a not particularly significant social security stipend that ceases once the child turns 16. Maybe the man has promised to marry her once the child leaves school and the social security entitlement expires. All I can say to that is: well, ha, ha, ha. If you know even one man who chooses to marry the woman he has lived with for two decades, when he could easily have done so before but never did, show him to me. I’d be very interested to make his acquaintance, because it’s probably easier to meet a bearded lady.
Why do I get the feeling that this “let’s not get married so we can get a government cheque” idea is invariably the father’s and not the mother’s? It’s probably because I continue to get the impression that women in general still put a higher value on marital status than do men. I have known some women to whom the greatest deterrent in leaving their husbands was not fear of financial uncertainty or starting afresh on the cusp of middle age, but because they were reluctant to swap their married status for that of a “separated woman”.
This is not because separated women are stigmatised still – far from it, because the only people still stigmatised in our society are blacks and Muslims, and a separated Maltese woman with three children by different fathers has higher status than a black woman living a respectable married life. No, it’s because women in general favour the status of marriage, though there are exceptions, as with everything. “Separated” status makes them feel exposed and vulnerable, and constantly in need of proving themselves.
I am reluctant to believe that, when she has a baby to fend for, swapping the security of marriage for a basic monthly cheque is something that a woman will suggest to the baby’s father, or that she will think it is a wonderful idea when he suggests it himself. She knows that she runs the very real risk of becoming truly dependent on that social security cheque, and that there is a guillotine waiting to fall when her child is 16.
How can anyone build a family life and a household with any sense of permanence, on these shaky and strange foundations? It seems to me impossible. Marriage isn’t permanent, as we well know; its effects are so, even with divorce. Divorce doesn’t declare a marriage null and void, like our own “desperate measures” civil system and our religious one. It merely ends a marriage while acknow-ledging that it existed from day A to day Z. Marriage brings all kinds of rights and responsibilities that are stipulated at law, and which are very important when there are children in the relationship.
They don’t matter much to two adults without children, living together on equal terms. But with children, wafting around in limbo while claiming that you “don’t need a piece of paper” – a man’s argument, and one only used by a woman when she is more keen to please her man than she is to do right by her child – is dangerous and irresponsible. The government says it plans to give more rights to cohabiting couples, but guess what? The minute you regulate cohabitation in this way, it becomes marriage.
Of course, there are those unmarried mothers who don’t want to marry their child’s father, or even acknowledge him on the birth certificate, because he is dangerous and irresponsible. They are concerned, and justly so, about being beholden to such a man until their child turns 18. His name on the birth certificate gives him rights over the child but, sadly, not responsibilities towards it – or rather, responsibilities he can easily shirk, while being able to have his rights upheld by the law courts, to the extent of preventing his child from getting a passport and being taken abroad for a holiday.
Women in this unfortunate position have to weigh up the pros and cons of 18 years of having to deal with a man like this against the pros and cons of having to deal with the fall-out of the day their child first asks who his father was, or sees his birth certificate with “unknown father” written on it. And she has no guarantee that the man won’t make her life hell in any case. She knows that this wouldn’t just be terrible for the child she loves, but would also make her child regard her as some kind of slag who slept around so much that she had no idea who could have possibly made her pregnant.
It’s a tough call. I can’t quite believe that women with babies are prepared to swap marital security for social security, when they love the father of their child and there are no obstructions to marriage. Of course, some of these women pretending that there is no father around, when there is, cannot marry, because one or both may already be married to somebody else. In the former situation, it’s a case of the government unwittingly colluding with the man.
The government’s cheque to the mother of his child allows him the space to shirk his responsibilities and to skive off from his duty to marry the woman who has his child, if he loves her and she loves him. You can argue that if he really did love her, then he would not be putting her in that position – and I would tend to agree. The argument about marriage being just a piece of paper cuts both ways: if it is just a piece of paper, then you might as well get married and raise your child that way. Women who find themselves in this position suspect, deep within their hearts, that there is truth in this, and that’s why discussion about the subject causes so much agitation and provokes such defensive arguments.