Nationalist-leaning newspapers must have initially thought that they have enough grist for their mill till the next general election, churning out stories about the anonymous emails sent to the Malta Labour Party’s deputy leader for party affairs Dr Michael Falzon. Their jubilation however was very short-lived. Dr Frank Portelli, a former President of the General Council of the Nationalist Party, decided to pull a fast one on his former colleagues by declaring, without batting an eyelid, that the brand new Mater Dei hospital was never a squeaky clean affair and that, as a matter of fact, the whole project was rigged with corruption from day one.
Dr Portelli’s revelations gave credibility to the opposition’s aggressive criticism, carelessly dismissed as partisan spin by Nationalist pundits, that the cost of the new hospital is suspiciously way beyond the estimates. Indeed, in spite of the Prime Minister’s denial of the plain truth, a characteristic so much loved by Nationalist electoral strategists, the final bill will be very close to the much ridiculed Lm250 million that was anticipated by Dr Alfred Sant.
Dr Portelli, a leading private hospital operator with a learned financial insight in the field based on years of experience, also had the gall to make the political statement that the new hospital is not worth the millions that have been spent for its completion. You would have thought you were listening to the Labour party spokesman on health. But no, this time round it is a former Nationalist Member of Parliament - and a respected one for that matter - who is calling the shots. To add to the Prime Minister’s dilemmas, another doctor, a former Nationalist MP and also a high profile hospital operator, Dr Josie Muscat, was quick to position himself on Dr Portelli’s side on this matter in much the same way that he is positioning himself and his new party against the Nationalist Party on the Prime Minister’s electoral districts.
Through the years the Prime Minister has tried to fend off the opposition’s relentless grip on the Mater Dei scandals by ignoring criticism completely even in the face of a string of legal actions that have landed in the courts. Although these events have been widely reported on the print media curiously there has been editorial silence from some quarters and this gave the Prime Minister the opportunity to brush aside political responsibility. But Dr Portelli’s outburst and Dr Muscat’s broadsides have left him with no choice but to reluctantly rush to the Commissioner of Police. Of course this is not what Dr Gonzi would have liked to read on the headlines on the eve of the inauguration of the new hospital.
But he will be hoping that the Commissioner of Police would come to his salvation at the ribbon cutting ceremony by declaring that he could not investigate any of Dr Portelli’s allegations.
Indeed the Nationalist Party will have to be clinically careful how to manage a positive outcome as Dr Gonzi’s delight could provoke Dr Portelli’s ire who would feel that his personal credibility has been dented. On account of the latter’s determined personality and very good connections with the media, Dr Portelli could continue haunting Dr Gonzi till election day irrespective of the outcome of police investigations. And with Dr Josie Muscat ready to pounce on any opportunity coming his way there can be more woes for the PN in the southern districts.
Ultimately I think the damage has already been done. The country would have been grateful to this government had the Mater Dei project been completed within a reasonable time and at a reasonable cost. None of these targets have been met. On the contrary time has seen the project tarnished by credible allegations of corruption and kickbacks. And it has cost the taxpayer millions of liri more that could have been spent on productive sectors. The fact is that soon after the hype of the ribbon cutting ceremony is all over the Mater Dei hospital will stick out for posterity as a beautiful monument to waste.
Dr Gavin Gulia is the opposition’s main spokesman on home affairs