The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

Get Rid of him, for God’s sake

Malta Independent Sunday, 15 July 2007, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

The Prime Minister is labouring under the delusion that his primary duty is towards his ministers. It isn’t. His primary duty is the country. This lot fall far short of what is required of a government, but the other lot are much worse – so we’re better off with this government until the Labour Party gets itself a new leader, instead of getting new eyelids and a fresh hairpiece for its old one. The way things are going, it’s not going to happen, and when we wake up some time next year to find that the country is being run by the same man who made such a damned mess of it the last time he tried, the funeral won’t just be Lawrence Gonzi’s. He’ll have let down the country, and all because he won’t get rid of the men that are making us detest the government.

Tonio Borg is a bombastic piece of work who is making many of us twitch with the urgent desire to vote the Nationalists out of power, just so that we can get rid of him and his pompous, patronising and paternalistic presence. There’s another minister who really must be swept up and out of the way, where he can’t do any more damage to this government’s electoral chances: the Minister for Roads and Transport. This isn’t just because Jesmond Mugliett isn’t doing what he is there to do: giving us better roads and public transport. Resentment against him for his uselessness has been gathering up a storm for some time now. All we needed was to hear that one of the driving examiners who took bribes to give pass-marks to those sitting their test is Mr Mugliett’s canvasser.

In the hue and cry about whether or not he intervened to keep the man in his post, everyone – and I mean everyone – has ignored an equally salient point. How did a constituency canvasser for the Transport Minister get a job as a driving examiner with the Transport Authority, in the first place? Was he selected from among hundreds of applicants, in which case the fact that he is or was the minister’s canvasser is a mere coincidence? Or did he get the job precisely because he is or was the minister’s canvasser? We’re so busy discussing how he lost his job that we have forgotten to ask how he got that job to start with.

The examiner in question, together with another one, had been prosecuted, found guilty, and banned for life from holding public office. Both men decided to ask for a presidential pardon, taking it for granted that this would allow them to stay on in their jobs. That’s another issue – have we degraded the function of a presidential pardon so deeply that it is now being used in respect of corrupt public officials who take bribes from 18-year-olds in search of a driving licence? The chief executive officer of the Transport Authority wished to sack them immediately, but was prevented from doing so by orders from on high. He resigned, but said that his resignation had nothing to do with the matter – though of course, we are left in no doubt that it did.

Precisely because one of the men was his canvasser, Jesmond Mugliett should have cut him loose immediately instead of trying to help him. If he got that job only because he was a canvasser for Mr Mugliett – and here I stand to be corrected – then the need to cut him loose at once was imperative. The man in question has betrayed the trust and confidence of the Transport Minister, compromised him shockingly, and created a scandal for the government. So why was he being supported?

When the story broke, Mr Mugliett said that he didn’t give the order to keep the corrupt examiners in their jobs. He said it was a “collective decision”. The chairman and board of directors of the Transport Authority reacted at once by saying that they were not involved in the decision and that they disagreed with it. The CEO reiterated that he wanted to fire them, not keep them on. A furore broke out in Parliament and in the newspapers. The Leader of the Opposition accused Jesmond Mugliett of lying to Parliament. He missed the point that Mr Mugliett didn’t tell us by whom that collective decision was taken. The assumption was made, and run away with, that he meant the chairman, chief executive officer and board of directors of the Transport Authority. I have a sneaking suspicion that what Jesmond Mugliett really meant was the Cabinet, but he is now too scared to spell it out because he’s buried up to his neck in s**t.

* * *

We are speaking here of two men who were convicted of an extremely serious offence. It is obvious to all right-thinking people that somebody who has done this should be sacked immediately, not just as a punishment but because his position is untenable. How can an examiner who has been convicted of taking bribes to pervert the outcome of exams be allowed to continue examining students? I shouldn’t have to explain the several grounds on which it is obscenely wrong, but apparently the Transport Minister, the Prime Minister and the cabinet are not right-thinking people, because they don’t think so. They have come up with Jesuitical arguments to bolster Jesmond Mugliett’s position, and the Prime Minister has continued to sink his ship by calling his minister’s behaviour “debatable” instead of just plain wrong. In what way is it debatable, and in what way can it possibly be excused or justified? The point is not so much whether he intervened to help them, but that he seems to think there is nothing wrong in allowing them to keep their jobs if they are pardoned presidentially.

That the convicted men themselves should see nothing wrong in staying on goes without saying. After all, they saw nothing wrong in taking money from kids sitting their driving test. They have been convicted of corruption. They are, by definition, corrupt people – and so their way of thinking is corrupt too. They are arguing that, because another official was convicted and retained in his job after receiving a presidential pardon two years ago – may we have more details, please? – then they should be given the same treatment. I am speechless. Not only did these two laboratory specimens fail to resign as soon as they were caught, nor even when they were convicted. Now they are fighting to stay on. It beggars belief, as does the fact that they appear to have had the support of the Transport Minister, and he in turn the support of his colleagues.

It is distressing that these corrupt men have been allowed to think that the entire Cabinet, and not just Jesmond Mugliett for whom one of them canvasses, is on their side. To compound the mess, Nationalist MP Jason Azzopardi was the lawyer who wrote to the Transport Authority on their behalf, demanding that they be retained until the outcome of the presidential pardon application is known, and citing precedent. Now another lawyer is fighting the case on their behalf – perhaps our Jason has had the good sense to avoid helping dig the government in any deeper. “My clients fail to see how their situation is different to that of the official who was granted a pardon two years ago. What’s sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander,” their lawyer told the newspapers.

Hang on a minute there: the reinstatement, after a presidential pardon, of a public official convicted of taking bribes was not a precedent but a serious error of judgement with wide-reaching consequences (see nursery rhyme below). The fact that a bad mistake was made then does not mean that it has to be repeated down the line for all eternity. A presidential pardon does not waive the conviction, but the penalty. Presidential pardon or not, these two corrupt persons will remain convicted criminals, and convicted criminals have no place in public authority, sitting in judgement over others. Another thing: I may inhabit a totally different planet or come from a completely different background to the corrupt officials and the ministers who are backing each other up, but it strikes me as completely wrong that a presidential pardon should be used to waive or undermine a court-mandated penalty that is a life-long ban on holding public office.

* * *

Mr Mugliett offered to resign. This is about as effective and credible as threatening suicide. Those who mean it just do it. Why ‘offer’ to resign? Why not just go ahead and resign? I’m sorry, but we can’t take him seriously, just as we can’t take the Prime Minister seriously for failing to say: “Thank you, Jesmond. I am accepting your resignation offer. Please clear your desk.”

Jesmond Mugliett has continued to flail around in the muck, even now that the presidential pardon has been refused and his canvasser and the other man have been fired. He has refused to answer questions, and is speaking with arrogance to journalists. He told The Times: “Just as you and others have the right to follow a story in the way you want to, I think I have the right to issue a statement when I want to and how I want to.” He told another journalist, when refusing an interview: “I think enough has been said about the issue. I feel there is no scope for an interview. If you want to interview me about something else, or if some new fact emerges in this case, then we can discuss it.” Way to go, Jes! Or as we say in Maltese, x’mentalita bazwija. What do his rights have to do with anything in this mess? It’s his obligations he should be concerned with now, but he seems to have the same underclass mentality as his canvasser, who wants the right to be retained in his post even though he failed to fulfil the obligation not to take bribes.

* * *

What’s wrong with the Prime Minister and his Cabinet, that they simply cannot see how their attempt at shoring up the unacceptable behaviour of Jesmond Mugliett has undone the good will generated by the fabulous new hospital? Trundling along on their cast-iron egos, they believe that the Transport Minister’s foibles are insignificant – indeed, that he has done no wrong. They really cannot see that they are hoist by Jesmond’s petard – and the fact that they cannot see it, or pretend that they cannot, only serves to worry and anger us more. I can just hear the reasoning: “We just gave them that fantastic hospital! Now are they going to complain about Jesmond and his driving examiner canvasser?” Well, yes, actually – they are.

Despite the hospital, it is quite possible to lose an election because of the attempts at keeping the Transport Minister’s corrupt canvasser in his job. For want of a horseshoe, the battle was lost – but I imagine that our government ministers, whose socio-educational background is largely homogenous, had childhoods singularly lacking in English nursery rhymes and many other aspects of British culture – which is a shame, as it is the cause of many of their troubles. So I’ll repeat the rhyme that has taught generations of children, including me, about consequences.

For want of a nail,

the shoe was lost.

For want of a shoe,

the horse was lost.

For want of a horse,

the rider was lost.

For want of a rider,

the battle was lost.

For want of a battle,

the kingdom was lost.

And all for the want of a horseshoe nail.

So there you have it. The Transport Minister’s behaviour in sticking his neck out for his corrupt canvasser is one of the nails that will lose the battle for this government – because, in turn, it made the Prime Minister stick out his neck for him, and now look what’s happened.

  • don't miss