European Commissioner Franco Frattini has been reported as having informed Maltese MP in the Italian parliament Arnold Cassola that Italy and Libya will begin to patrol the latter’s borders with Chad and Niger as from next January.
This is good news, but we pose the question – will these patrols, which will be under the European Union flag – stop irregular migration? The patrols will be aimed at discouraging people from making the land trek across Africa to leave from human depots in Libya and Morocco, among other countries.
In addition, Mr Frattini said that once the issue of the Bulgarian medics and Palestinian doctor is resolved in a positive way, the EU aims to propose a special bilateral to Libya whereby irregular migrants from Chad and Niger entering Libya over the land border would be repatriated under the aegis of the United Nations High Commission for Refugees “in order to guarantee respect for the basic human rights of the individuals concerned.”
One is sure that the move will help to stem the flow of migrants through Libya, who then make their way to Malta or mainland Europe through Italy. But, again, will it stop migration? The answer is a clear and categorical “no” and there are a few pertinent points to make on the issue when looked at from a holistic perspective. One possible spin-off is that the problem will merely move to other areas of departure. If Libya’s borders are patrolled, then would-be migrants will simply look for alternative departure points in West Africa, where they would make for the Canary Islands, which are of course Spanish (and therefore EU) territory. In addition, migrants might alternatively opt to make their way to the promised land by going through Eastern Africa, onto the Middle East and finally into Europe through the former Communist bloc. What we are basically saying is that while this move will be good for Malta, Italy and Libya, it does not propose anything that will help tackle irregular migration in the long term.
Another worry is the repatriation proposal. Malta and Italy have both, in the not-so-distant past, been lambasted and been the targets of broadsides of criticism for their repatriation policy. One can surmise that if there is a repatriation agreement, Libya will be sending multitudes of people back to their own countries. This, as we have already seen and heard, can lead to imprisonment, torture, discrimination and even, some have claimed, death.
It is a welcome sign to see that our EU neighbours are taking an active interest in stemming the tides of boats that make their way over the Mediterranean, but we have to take an altogether more holistic and pragmatic view of what is going on.
Unless tyrannical governments, corruption, famine, education and basic infrastructure problems are sorted out in Africa – then it will remain the “dark continent”. Unless these problems are tackled and standards of living are raised enough to allow people the right of self-determination, the phenomenon of irregular migration will continue. What we are talking about will not take a few years, it will take decades of dedicated hard work.
It is no easy task, but unless Africa develops into a free market democratic continent, people are going to resort to ever more desperate and drastic measures to escape. And that is something that no patrols can ever hope to prevent.