The events of the past week showed us once again clearly the almost impossibility of anything in this country avoiding becoming the ball to be kicked around by our national Punch and Judy show – politics.
We had an issue, brought up by a non-partisan paper, regarding a minister who, it would have seemed, showed more loyalty to his aides than to court instructions (and who, according to yesterday’s Orizzont, hinged his appeal for a stay in the execution of the court orders on a precedent involving a young man found guilty of defrauding Lm4 whereas the two men now asking for a presidential pardon were involved in far more money than that).
Added to which there was confusion galore between the minister and the CEO and the chairman, with all evidence of people who first speak to the media and then try to salvage misunderstandings and unravel things, rather than the way round.
Anyway, there was this issue.
Then the Opposition got involved. It had not been involved in the creation of the case. It added no new information on the case. It only added to the confusion. And it enabled the government to get away with it.
For then, once the issue had been made a political issue, once the Opposition tried to question the minister, and, having been involved in a prolonged procedural wrangling with the government, thus enabling the minister to get by with five minutes’ questions, it then claimed a Breach of Privilege, which got thrown out (and rightly so, for the minister may have been muddled in the way he expressed himself but breached no privilege by muddling, though yes he was very close to do so by claiming ‘collective decision-making when it turned out to be collectively he and his lawyer) only then to go one step further and mount a No Confidence vote.
Which in turn did get the government to come and defend its minister, as anyone could see it doing (perhaps that was precisely the Opposition’s aim) but which added nothing to the debate or to the truth of the matter. The minister argued how he had acted against corruption (wrong tactics) and the Prime Minister shrilled in defence. But even the minister’s counterpart went astray and started complaining about the St Paul’s Bay ByPass, which had nothing to do with the matter at hand.
And, exasperated, members voted and left on their summer holiday.
Who gained anything from this? No one. Not the country. Not the government, seeing it had been brought, feet forward, to defend the indefensible. Not the Opposition, either for it is its foregone conclusion this government is collectively and individually bankrupt and the sooner replaced (by the Opposition, no less!) the better. Nor did those (government) members who may have disagreed with the way Mr Mugliett handled matters (just as the president of the PN Council, Jean-Pierre Farrugia admitted, but he sits not in the House today) or who, like John Dalli would have wanted to know why was he forced out and Mr Mugliett not (but Mr Dalli voted and kept silent).
So who gained? We have come to accept this as normal (and indeed so did the Nationalist Opposition all through the Seventies, the Eighties and no doubt will do again if it finds itself in Opposition) that the Opposition latches on to every issue and turns and twists it to its own supposed benefit.
But all that this does is to turn politics into a Punch and Judy show, where no one resigns, no one is wrong, where the indefensible is defended and where the government is forced to defend even its weakest links. This is sumo-politics where two heavyweights dance and jabber their way around each other, sometimes one falling, and sometimes the other but there is no reason why one falls and why not the other, except something called alternation.
Having been put on his guard by the Opposition, the Prime Minister could do nothing except defend Mr Mugliett, much though he may privately decry the way and the means used by his minister. If it’s any consolation for him, things were far worse for his predecessor just a year before 2003, with Zeppi l-Hafi on all front pages.
At most, the Mugliett affaire confirmed what the Labour diehards were saying, exasperated the pale-blue Nationalists no end, but it will not change matters by as much as one vote.