The protracted and much politicised issue of Maltacom’s land transfers deserves a clarification after new details of the deal, and the hitch that has befallen it, came to light in this newspaper last week.
The Malta Labour Party’s accusation that the government gave in to Tecom (the investor company) on the issue of land transfer is totally off the mark. Why? You may well ask, and to shed light on the matter, one needs some background.
In the past, Maltacom was given land by the government on which to build its telephone exchanges and to which it has no legal title. On the other hand, Maltacom owns a plot of land in Qawra to which it holds full legal title. To simplify the privatisation process, the government decided to offer Maltacom (now, of course, Go, but let’s stick to Maltacom for the sake of ease and continuity) the land on which it has no title in exchange for the plot of land in Qawra.
This agreement was made between the government and Maltacom while Tecom was merely an observer and was in no way, form or manner privy to or part of the deal. However, at some point the government was informed by Maltacom that they were to renege on the deal. This, although subject to speculation, was in all probability down to fresh objections raised by the minority shareholders – members of the public who had bought shares in the company over the years.
In the meantime, the government has sought recourse to the Attorney General for advice on the matter. Only the AG’s office may give advice to the government on this issue because it involves sovereign territory of the Republic of Malta. The government wrote to the AG’s office some three months ago, but apart from an acknowledgment of the letter, nothing has yet come to light.
One understands that the AG’s office is understaffed and over-worked, but perhaps a small re-think in priorities is in order, mainly due to the MLP’s destabilising politicisation of the issue. The MLP has accused the government of incompetence and lies and cover-ups over this land, but we do not believe that this is the case.
What is the government supposed to do? Expropriate the land? The country, individuals and companies are still suffering from similar expropriations, years down the line. The government has shown tact and restraint by going to the AG’s office when it could have easily steam-rollered the agreement by not handing over the exchange land that it owns. It could easily have evicted Maltacom from those plots, yet it did not.
However, a wise word of warning here. The AG could come up with a number of solutions, one of which could very well be eviction. And then the dissenting shareholders would be up the proverbial creek without a paddle. The issue is quite simple: it seems to smack of greed and of holding the government to ransom in order to “gain” a better deal.
However this, as we have said, could backfire. So what is needed here? The dissenting shareholders need to honour a fair deal they had already agreed to. On the other hand, the MLP should not try to make political capital out of the issue. But, by far most important of all, the AG’s office needs to at least provide the government with legal advice. In that way all will become a bit more transparent and hopefully, all this useless gerrymandering will stop.