The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Court: Spanish Student fakes armed robbery

Malta Independent Wednesday, 22 August 2007, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

A Spanish student currently in Malta to learn English after receiving a grant from the Spanish government, yesterday pleaded guilty to filing a false police report in which he claimed that he had been robbed by people who put a knife to his neck.

He later confessed to the police that he had made up the story for insurance fraud purposes.

Carlos Garcia Quatro, 23, was charged with filing a false police report at the St Julian’s police station on Monday afternoon.

Defence lawyer Jose Herrera said the accused had his mobile, wallet and a silver necklace stolen from St George’s Bay and made up an “exaggerated” story to impress the police. He said his client was under the influence of medication he was taking for health conditions including “an alcohol problem and stress”.

He said that with this crime his client had not hurt anyone and said that the police should have been more discreet with the case since it involved students and a large slice of the Maltese tourism industry.

On his part, Police Inspector Carlo Ellul said the story did not unfold exactly as the defence was portraying it. He said the accused first said that he was robbed at St George’s Bay and that he had a knife placed against his neck. He later said that he had lost his mobile and wallet and that his silver chain had fallen. He said the accused even described his aggressor.

He said he smelt a rat when he asked the students exactly where the incident had taken place and discovered that there was a policeman there at the same time the students said the alleged robbery took place. The inspector said that the students later said he had made up the story.

Inspector Ellul said that these false reports are giving people the false impression that people holidaying in Malta are robbed on a regular basis and this was harming the country’s reputation.

Handing down her judgement, magistrate Audrey Demicoli said she was conditionally discharging the student for one year and warned him that this time he was being given a chance but next time the court will hand down a harsher punishment.

Police Inspector Carlo Ellul prosecuted while Dr Jose Herrera appeared for the accused.

  • don't miss