The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

It’s All about the money

Malta Independent Sunday, 23 September 2007, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

The Minister of Justice and Home Affairs is being disingenuous when he colludes with the public in its mistaken belief that Malta’s search and rescue zone is a burden to the country rather than a financial blessing. Over the past few months there has been a stream of letters and angry articles published in the newspapers, written by those who believe that little Malta is being put upon by the big countries, forced to defend the European frontier with two potty Cessnas over a swathe of the Mediterranean that stretches from Tunisia to Crete, and which is roughly the size of Britain.

What they don’t know is this: that the government is determined to hang on to the disproportionate delimitation of our search and rescue zone, and that it would be mad and irresponsible not to do so. That is why, when Tonio Borg goes out clamouring for attention in European forums, he calls for more help with sea and air patrols rather than for the truncation of our search and rescue zone so that Malta’s responsibilities are no longer quite so extensive. The search and rescue zone, you see, rains down manna from heaven on Malta, and this is how it happens.

The maritime zone corresponds precisely to the country’s commercial airspace. This means that Malta doesn’t have only a disproportionately huge maritime zone from which it must pluck people who are in peril, illegal immigrants or otherwise. It also has commercial airspace that is correspondingly and disproportionately vast, and this means lots of money pouring in. Each time a plane flies through our flight information area, it has to pay Malta. The over-flight fees rake in millions for Malta every year, and this is money that comes to us pretty much for nothing. If we reduce our maritime search and rescue zone, then our commercial airspace will be reduced accordingly, meaning less unearned income for the national coffers. The government, quite sensibly, doesn’t want to do this. Nobody, still less a country as much in need of revenue as ours is, turns away free money or hands over a valuable asset.

There is payback of sorts. As the cliché goes, there is no such thing as a truly free lunch. The payback is that we are obliged to rescue illegal immigrants from the maritime equivalent of our vast commercial airspace, and deal with the consequences. This isn’t exactly doing us in, because we are imprisoning them without trial in concentration camps for up to 18 months and treating them like animals. Yet even if we were to keep them in the lap of luxury, there would still be lots of change left over from the large amounts of money that over-flight fees bring in every year. In other words, rescuing and dealing with boat people is the relatively small price that Malta has to pay for its ridiculously vast commercial airspace, from which it derives many millions.

Not many people know this, which is why they adopt the outraged view that Malta is hard done by the rest of Europe. Yet if there is any gross unfairness in this situation, it is the unfairness of a microscopic island raking in commercial over-flight fees from a quarter of the Mediterranean Sea’s airspace. We’re not hard done by at all, but rather lucky. The reason that we have such an immense search and rescue zone and corresponding airspace is because we were Fortress Malta under the British. Whitehall wanted strategic control of the Mediterranean and this was one way of getting it. Had Cyprus, also a British colony at the time, been Britain’s preferred fortress-base, then Cyprus would today be the lucky island banking the tremendous over-flight fees.

When the British relinquished control of Malta, Malta did not relinquish control of its airspace and the maritime search and rescue zone that goes with it. The growth of the island-republic coincided with the expansion of air travel, commercial airlines, and tourism in the Mediterranean. Throughout the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s, more and more money poured into Malta from over-flight fees. In return, hardly any search and rescue operations went on, except for a couple of Albanian ships in the early 1990s and problems with a few people lost at sea. Lots of money was coming in, and virtually nothing was going out the other way. Then suddenly it was payback time, as the number of boat people at risk of drowning on the way from North Africa to Italy went from a trickle to a steady stream in the last few years. We were forced to wake up to the fact that a vast commercial airspace brings with it concomitant responsibilities on the waves beneath. After years of take, take, take, we found ourselves having to give a little and boy, we don’t like that.

There is a solution to our responsibilities at sea, and this is to end our privileges in the air. By giving up our commercial airspace, we can give up our maritime search and rescue zone. Yet doing that would be insane, because it would mean giving away a valuable asset with no chance of ever getting it back. It is the equivalent of giving away a palatial estate because you can’t be bothered to deal with the maintenance, even though it pays for itself with the revenue it brings in.

Given that mercenary considerations are the primary motivator among the Maltese, the government should encourage the angry island burghers to look at this as a business rather than an onslaught. We have to handle the boat people in our maritime search and rescue zone in return for raking in money from our commercial airspace. I’m not the most mercenary of people, but I am fairly sensible and pragmatic, and that is precisely how I see it. This might be a good time to remember that having your cake and eating it too is impossible unless you’re a magician or a miracle-worker. In other words, we can’t have the benefits of a vast commercial airspace without the problems that a correspondingly vast maritime search and rescue zone brings with it. As long as the benefits of our commercial airspace continue to greatly outweigh the negative effects of our maritime search and rescue zone, then we’re smiling all the way to the bank.

* * *

I suppose the reason that the government never mentions the money coming in from the air, when it is speaking about the problems generated by the sea, is because it knows that the knowledge of that income undermines its protestation that Malta cannot cope with the rescued boat-people. Our airspace, which cannot but correspond to our maritime zone, doesn’t just bring in the money to pay for the rescue and maintenance of the boat people. It brings in a sizeable profit besides. And that is why the general reaction from “Europe” has been “What in hell’s name are you complaining about?” It’s just a shame that the people of this country haven’t had the situation explained to them. They can see only the problems being thrown up by the sea because they haven’t been told about all the money raining down from the air.

  • don't miss