The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Establishing The truth about migrants’ claims

Malta Independent Monday, 24 December 2007, 00:00 Last update: about 20 years ago

When trying to establish the truth about migrants’ claims, you have to take into

consideration the fact that when putting

forward an application to be granted some form of protection, these people would want to try to give it their best shot, so their claims may not always be genuine. They would have made big sacrifices to try and improve the state of their lives, having escaped from

countries hit by conflict, poverty and

sometimes war, Commissioner for Refugees Mario Friggieri tells Francesca Vella

Appointed as Malta’s second Refugee Commissioner last July, Mr Friggieri took over from Charles Buttigieg – who served as commissioner ever since the office was established in 2002.

The Justice and Home Affairs Ministry has strengthened the office with a considerable increase in human resources. There are currently 13 case officers, compared to the six employed to work at the Office of the Refugee Commissioner in July this same year.

Mr Friggieri said this change is already having a positive impact on the system, as migrants’ cases are being dealt with in a faster, more efficient manner.

The Refugee Commissioner explained that migrants claiming to have reached our shores from war-torn countries like Somalia, Eritrea and Sudan (Darfur in particular), are among those most likely to have the right to refugee status or humanitarian protection.

It is for this reason that the office gives preference to asylum seekers claiming to be from either one of these countries.

While Somalia has not had an established government since 1991, when President Mohamed Siad Barre was ousted by tribal militias, Eritrea has not yet fully implemented its Constitution – adopted in 1997 – due to the prevailing conflict with Ethiopia, which began in 1998.

The situation in Sudan, on the other hand, has long been dominated by violence, but the Darfur region of western Sudan has been at the centre of international attention since 2004.

It was then that government troops and militia groups known as janjaweed moved to crush rebels who complained that the black residents of the region had been neglected by the central Muslim government.

Since then, the janjaweed, backed by government troops, have carried out widespread killings of civilians. At least 200,000 are thought to have died and more than 2.5 million more are believed to have fled their homes in the face of atrocities and the destruction of villages.

“By Christmas, we wanted to make it a point to have interviewed all irregular migrants who arrived in Malta this year and claimed to hail from either one of these countries,” said Mr Friggieri.

About 1,700 irregular migrants reached our shores this year, about 100 less than last year. Of these, more than 600 claimed to be from Somalia, more than 200 from Eritrea and about 160 from the Ivory Coast, according to statistics obtained by this newspaper.

About 130 claimed to be Nigerian, another 120 from Mali and more than 100 from Ethiopia. Another 84 claimed to be from Ghana, with another 46 arriving from Sudan.

According to statistics obtained from the Office of the Refugee Commissioner, only seven migrants were granted refugee status from 1 January till 30 November this year. However, out of a total of 860 concluded cases, 523 migrants were granted humanitarian protection.

Mr Friggieri said about 250 migrants are currently being interviewed every month. He said that this was still not a big enough number, but the 13 case officers working at the office are doing their very best to reduce the backlog of applications from summer and from last year.

Another 311 applications were rejected, while 19 applications were withdrawn. An additional 596 applications are being reviewed and 1,453 are awaiting the start of their procedure.

The applications that are still being reviewed include 210 cases involving unaccompanied minors, who would require the appointment of a legal guardian for their applications to be processed.

He said irregular migrants who are still in detention are given preference over those released from the closed centres.

“Our main mission is to ensure the protection of whoever has the right to it and do so as soon as possible.

“At the same time, however, we cannot simply grant refugee status or humanitarian protection to everyone who claims to have the right to it. Decisions are not always clear-cut, although when case officers carry out interviews, the genuine cases become easier to identify”.

Mr Friggieri explained that while irregular migrants do sometimes have documents when they reach our shores, this can facilitate or complicate matters.

“As I explained earlier, when they put forward their application, migrants try giving it their best shot; some of them might try to falsely claim they hail from one of the war-stricken countries, seeking asylum even though they may not necessarily have the right to it,” he said.

So, among the main hurdles that case officers normally come across when dealing with asylum applications, are lack of documents, language barriers, culture differences and the very fact that migrants would want to give it the best shot, sometimes even on false grounds.

As for language barriers, Mr Friggieri said it is sometimes very difficult, if not impossible, to find interpreters for certain languages and dialects.

In fact, the Office of the Refugee Commission is currently seeking cooperation from the EU to try and conduct interviews by means of video conferencing.

It might be easier to find interpreters across the whole of Europe, said Mr Friggieri, adding that the office is also seeking to provide training to case officers abroad.

He said the case officer’s job is not an easy one; in fact, only two of the 13 case officers currently employed have been in the job for more than a year.

The Refugee Commissioner expressed satisfaction, however, that resources have been strengthened. Apart from an increase in the complement of case officers, the office is now equipped with four additional rooms at the Safi centre, which can be used for interviews.

Speaking about the current detention system, Mr Friggieri pointed out that if a migrant’s application for asylum would have been rejected and s/he appeals against the Office of the Refugee Commission’s decision, s/he is still considered to be an asylum seeker and can therefore only be kept in detention for a maximum period of one year.

If, on the other hand, the migrant would have never applied for asylum, or would have applied, had his/her application rejected and had it rejected again on appeal, then s/he can be kept in detention for a maximum period of 18 months.

Mr Farrugia said the situation in Malta is quite particular, in that when a migrants’ application for asylum would have been rejected, s/he can stay on until the state issues a deportation order.

Since Malta is an island and connections to African countries are not always straightforward, it can take some time before a deportation order is issued. In the meantime however, a migrant can stay here, even though he is not eligible to protection.

Elsewhere, such migrants have to leave the country, left trying to cross borders illegally and therefore risking getting in trouble.

Mr Friggieri also pointed out that detention in other European countries is quite common and in certain places, when migrants are released from detention their freedom does not extend beyond the village, town or city where they would have been detained.

Replying to a question about the Common European Asylum System, the Refugee Commissioner said his office was already trying to follow the criteria and procedures of the new system.

He noted that Malta has received criticism over the fact that a large number of migrants are granted humanitarian protection.

“In view of such criticism, it is important to note that more than half the number of irregular migrants that reach our shores every year come from countries where violence is at its worst.

“When granting protection to people from these countries, we would be following advice provided by the various conventions we ratified as a country, including those of the United Nations and the European Union,” said Mr Friggieri.

He also spoke about the huge burden on Malta. Take the population density and GDP – Malta’s population is more or less 400,000 and about 1,600 – 1,800 irregular migrants arrive every year.

Italy, on the other hand, has a population of about 57.3 million and a maximum of 18,000 arrive there every year.

Proportionally, when you take into consideration the population density of both countries, the burden would be equal when over 100 irregular migrants would have reached our shores, said Mr Friggieri. And yet, with more than 15 times that amount, burden sharing is practically non-existent.

Same with the UK, which has a population of about 60 million and about 24,000 migrants arriving there every year, most of whom apply for asylum at seaports and airports.

Since the Office of the Refugee Commission was set up on 1 January 2002, by 30 November this year 193 migrants were granted refugee status, while 2,528 were granted humanitarian protection. A total of 2,260 applications were rejected and 145 were withdrawn.

  • don't miss