The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Joe’s Call in the wild

Malta Independent Wednesday, 23 January 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 20 years ago

Joe Sant tries to take me to task by challenging me to publish a report which, according to him, holds the key to all treasures! He tempts me to go against the opinion of the Ombudsman himself. As Joe points out, the Ombudsman noted that the publication of the Mepa Auditor’s report on the Sant’ Antnin recycling plant, planning process ‘will be prejudicial to the authority’ (TMID, 19 January). If I were to do as Joe is suggesting, the next thing he (or some Labour ally) will do, is call me arrogant for having gone against the word of the Ombudsman. Joe Sant should stop wasting his time, and that of his fellow members on the Committee Against the Sant’Antnin Recycling Plant as Proposed now, rather than later.

Joe Sant continues to fail to see the benefit that an upgraded Sant’Antnin plant will have on the quality of life of the residents in Marsascala and the operators of the plant itself. Joe Sant seems not to be bothered by the fact that the old plant, licensed to treat 83,000 tonnes of mixed waste annually, will be getting a e23 million facelift. In so doing the throughput of the plant will be reduced to 71,000 tonnes of waste annually with 36,000 tonnes of this being recyclable waste. Thus, the plant will receive only 35,000 tonnes of organic waste and that’s just 43 per cent of the organic waste the facility was licensed to receive under the old permit.

In 1998 Joe Sant was the personal secretary of the Labour Minister George Vella, who happened to be responsible for waste management in Malta. Did Joe Sant take this minister to task when he publicly announced (see Times of Malta – Aug 1998) that all of Malta’s mixed municipal waste will be taken to Sant’Antnin and left to rot, together with the abysmal environmental credentials of the then Labour administration? No he did not. On the contrary, Joe Sant kept this recommendation – by a selected few experts – hidden, when he embarked on this crusade against the upgrading of today.

Joe Sant fails to mention how the countless environmental assessments that were carried out, leading to the full development permit of this state-of-the-art upgrade, have led to reducing the impact of this development to an absolute minimum. Joe Sant should perhaps opt to challenge the former Marsascala mayor to publish his 2005 report, carried out by an independent expert, on the upgrade. This report, paid from taxpayers’ money, has never seen the light of day because the then mayor was disturbed by its constructive comments on the development. Joe Sant is competent enough to compare what this report – authored by Prof. Alfred Vella – recommended and how such recommendations are presently being taken on board by WasteServ Malta Ltd, as the upgrading is implemented.

Joe Sant should challenge himself to visit the upgrading in person, as the current Marsascala mayor has done, to learn about the project. I am convinced that Joe Sant will be impressed, should he find the time to be guided by WasteServ employees and be given an overview of the investment being made. Instead of resorting to countless challenges, Joe Sant should have the project explained to him at first hand. Joe Sant should not just bury his head in the sand, and pretend that this upgrade is as catastrophic as he conveniently thinks it is.

Joe Sant’s original, and only, point of contention (before the Auditor’s report) was the alternative siting that this upgrading should have been given. On 13 August, 2007, the opinion of Commissioner Dimas was safely in the bag when he said “that in the case in question, the project is for the extension and modernisation of an existing waste recycling site, therefore no alternative geographical site, in effect, exists”. Now Joe Sant should not continue to challenge this, that and the other, hoping to gain political mileage for his fellow colleagues. National interest has been served, and will continue to be served, as the upgrading unfolds. Undermining this national interest is irresponsible and pathetic.

Commissioner Stavros Dimas himself, hailed Malta for its long term planning in waste management. Joe Sant thinks otherwise, and feels that a ’21-page report’ (as he says) will break this government’s track record in this sector of the environment. How silly of Joe Sant to think in this way.

Rather than challenges, one would expect Joe (and his allies) to apologise for the nonsense instigated, given that the true reality of this process has long become public.

George Pullicino is Rural Affairs and Environment Minister

  • don't miss