The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Sant’s Brass neck

Malta Independent Sunday, 17 February 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 15 years ago

Tomorrow my youngest son, who has just started driving, is taking me out. He has invited me to a debate at the university. The leaders of all the political parties contesting the election will face a large audience of students, hoping for their votes. I trust that a reporter will be there to ask this very important question of Alfred Sant: “Five years ago you did your damnedest to deny these young people an EU passport and all the rights, privileges and benefits that EU membership gives them. You even dismissed and disparaged their parents’ Yes vote in a referendum, and said that what their parents thought didn’t count, because what you thought counted more. How do you now have the brass neck to face them and ask them to vote for you, after you tried so hard to destroy their chances?”

I can tell you already what his wet answer will be: “I don’t want to speak about the past. The past is history. We are speaking about a New Beginning.” Then he will climb into his kowc tal-bidla and go home. That is now his stock answer every time he is embarrassed by a reference to his failures and to his objectionable stances. But, excuse me, for whom would it be a Bidu Gdid – for him and his horrible bunch of henchmen, or for Malta? I think we know the answer to that one, without having to ask him.

It is only children who think of five years ago as “the past” and as remote history I don’t think of Alfred Sant’s behaviour five years ago as the past; I think of it as the present and the future, lying in wait to cause disruption once more.

Alfred Sant doesn’t deserve the vote of a single young person, just as he doesn’t deserve the vote of a single one of my contemporaries, who were so badly short-changed when Labour was in government and Sant was party president and chairman of the university students’ selection board, which was set up to keep people out of university. What he deserves from us all, if the electoral system were to allow it, is blackballing. I hope those students tomorrow have the good manners not to boo and hiss him off the stage like a pantomime baddy.

* * *

I received this email from a contemporary, and I’m going to quote it in full, though anonymously. “When I read your articles, I get this sick feeling inside because what you write reminds me so much of the Labour government and what we went through. When we try to explain our past to our children, they cannot believe that it actually happened. They cannot understand that it isn’t like when their grandparents talk about the war, that our fear is about something still real and present – that the very people who made our life a misery in the 1980s are still in parliament today, ready to become ministers again, and one of them is trying to become prime minister. The way we lived made me think of myself as inferior, with all those social hardships forced on us by a government that institutionalised hatred and division. I remember sitting on the bus on my way to sixth form college, and seeing that many buildings had been plastered over with posters during the night, posters that read ‘Mintoff…professor tad-demokrazija.’ I remember wondering about the madness of it all, and why we had to live that way. I had started sixth form college in Valletta. We were moved to Pieta during the first semester. They didn’t shift premises during the summer months – no, they had to wait until the school year had started. Moving took about two months, and they made us students pack all the things that had to be transferred. We were in a mess for another three months after that. Lectures were cancelled. Science labs were in confusion. And what did they do next? They held examinations all the same. You should have seen the chaos.

“I don’t have to remind you that every day we waited for the eight o’clock news to see what our professors of democracy had dreamt up the previous night: banning imports, fighting with European countries, declaring war on church schools. Air Malta could sell you a ticket to Italy, but the banks weren’t allowed to sell you Italian currency, and you weren’t allowed to take more than a tiny sum of foreign currency with you anyway. I remember going to Rome via London, and hiding cash in my shoes to pay for my hotel and meals. I was terrified that I would be frisked on the way out and arrested. I got on the plane and shuddered until it took off. And now people have the luxury of complaining about the departure tax. University? I don’t have to explain to you why we couldn’t get in even though we had A-levels. And in any case, somebody had decided to scrap the Bachelor of Arts courses and start something called B.Educ instead, because he said we should become teachers instead of wasting our time studying useless rubbish.

“So one of my first jobs was as a receptionist at a St Julian’s hotel, on the minimum wage. A German couple staying there asked me to arrange a visit to Farsons, because he was a brewer. The next day they came up to me and said, ‘We’d like to thank you for arranging the visit. We read in a book about Malta that the best way for foreigners to show appreciation towards a Maltese is to bring him chocolates from their country.’ I tried to show gratitude, but I couldn’t stop a tear rolling down my cheek. I felt so degraded. I did eventually get to university. I am 43 years old and a third-year student. Now I look at the electoral pictures and see the same faces of the people who made my life hell then, expecting me to forgive and forget everything and bring them to power again. When anyone tells me today ‘Ilhom wisq fil-gvern tal-PN’, I am enraged. Maybe they’d prefer to bring back those who destroyed our chances and made us second-class citizens in a third-world country.”

* * *

In their attempts at persuading us that a coalition is “very possible”, AD politicians forget or ignore the crucial principle that majority rule underpins democracy. They speak as though they have the whole of the country behind them, when the reality is that they are speaking only for themselves and their supporters. What they appear to be advocating is a kind of minority rule, and a minuscule minority at that, in which a party with one seat in parliament tells those with the other 64 seats what to do.

Many people have been convinced somehow, and this is an argument for stronger civic education in our schools, that it is desirable to have an AD politician in parliament to act as a “control” on the other 64 MPs or to keep them in check. This can only work if that AD politician, with his one seat, threatens to hold the governing party hostage or to ransom – in other words, working against the elected representatives of the majority. The deciding vote on matters of policy or legislation should not be in the hands of a political party with a single seat. A renegade MP in a governing party with a one-seat majority is bad enough. The last time that happened in Malta, in 1998, we found ourselves with a new government. This was a serendipitous surprise that allowed us to pursue membership of the European Union when we thought that all had been lost, but it is not a way to run the country on a daily basis, and the results are more likely to be negative than positive.

I find it fascinating that all the arguments about seats for third parties in parliament assume that this party is AD and mention no others. The fallacy of many of these arguments can be tested by applying them to other third parties, like Azzjoni Nazzjonali or Imperium Europa. It is irrelevant whether they are realistic contenders for now or not; we should still test the arguments by inserting their name instead of AD’s. Suddenly, the situation is not so desirable, and the arguments are no longer quite as convincing.

* * *

I find distasteful in the extreme the constant harping by Harry Vassallo, who lost his rag on Xarabank last Friday, on the importance of having him or one of his men in parliament to keep everyone else in check. His self-portrayal as some kind of folk hero or national saviour is beginning to grate. He forgets that all those other MPs he thinks are in dire need of his control are the legitimate representatives of around 300,000 electors, and that they haven’t been imposed on us by some celestial high command.

This outrageous arrogance is much in the same vein as his reference to the democratically elected government as a “regime” and to AD activists as “dissidents”. A few days ago he wrote that the Nationalist Party’s stance “does not express the sentiment of (its) party’s supporters across the country, who would have no objection to a Blue-Green coalition and would certainly prefer it to a Red-Green coalition, and very much more to a Red single-party government.” It would be interesting to know on what grounds he feels able to speak for Nationalist Party supporters “across the country,” but it is even more interesting to see how it has occurred to him that they wouldn’t like a “red” government at all.

Yet a red government is exactly what they will get if they follow his suggestion to vote AD instead of PN, or even to give AD a second preference vote (which means that if their first-preference PN candidate is not elected, the vote is transferred to AD instead of to another PN candidate, and is lost to the Nationalist Party).

In another newspaper, an AD politician wrote: “it is very probable that if AD gets elected, it will have to decide with which party to form a coalition government.” In his enthusiasm, he has forgotten that it is the people, and not a putative member of parliament for AD, who decide which party governs – at least, under the Maltese system. In any case, AD has been left with a single road to its fictitious coalition – an alliance with Labour – because in a long overdue and very restrained statement, the prime minister has ruled out any coalition with AD. “We have a general election coming up and there is no question of an alliance,” he said. “From what I hear, it would appear that there is an alliance between AD and the Labour Party. I have heard nothing but criticism against the government from AD, and we cannot see how we can form an alliance with a party which talks in exactly the same way as Labour.”

Another kind of man might have been more pointed in his remarks that the demands for a coalition are coming from a party that consistently denigrates him and his government, runs him down, criticises everything he does and says, never has a positive word for any of the considerable achievements of the last five years and more, and describes the democratically-elected government as a regime – which poses the question: if the government allies itself to a single AD member of parliament, is it then no longer a regime? AD’s approach to forming an alliance has been rather like trying to persuade a woman to marry you by beating her up and calling her a good-for-nothing slag.

* * *

This has left AD in something of a fix. The votes it has been collecting so far have come from people who always voted Nationalist, and who have been led to believe that their vote will go towards a PN-AD coalition, not having had it explained to them that the vast majority’s preference for two major parties does not allow for such coalitions (majority rules, remember). These Sliema matrons and Swieqi singletons would be less than thrilled at the prospect of their vote going towards an AD-MLP coalition, now that this is the only “option” left. Having spent the days immediately after the 1971, 1976, 1981 and 1996 general elections locked in their homes weeping as lorries full of roughnecks drove through, shouting virulent abuse and throwing hard and soft objects, they might wish to have the potential for an MLP-AD alliance explained to them more clearly.

I think the euphoria of collecting one protest vote after another in Nationalist Party strongholds has gone to AD’s head, and its people are no longer thinking straight. I take exception to being told by the Italian MP – or is it former MP? – Arnold Cassola, in his contributions to various newspapers, that coalitions work. The reason he is free to contest this general election in Malta is the failure of the Italian coalition government. But I take the greatest exception of all to seeing my friends, neighbours and acquaintances being persuaded to vote for AD without also being told that the natural consequence of this is a return of the failed prime minister Alfred Sant, with consequent distress to the economy.

Somebody described the Labour Party/government to me as a “giant happiness-sucking machine” and I knew exactly what she meant. Labour governments, over the last 37 years, have been the agents of chaos, confusion and even misery. They were unable to introduce even the few good things that they did without causing disruption and anxiety and sowing division and hatred. And here they are, at it again, with the shadow minister for finance shouting from a mass-meeting stage last Sunday that Nationalist supporters have “something bad in their DNA”. Thank you, Charles, I’ll take a note of that.

  • don't miss