As a detached and apolitical observer of this general election, it is disheartening to witness at first hand the tribal warfare which has ensued and the reckless and largely unaffordable electoral promises being made, encouraged by sycophantic media apologists on both sides of the tribal divide. We must each of us make up our own minds on what constitutes the best solution for Malta’s future well-being, and vote accordingly. We have a duty and a responsibility to vote, which I am confident we will exercise. My concern is with the environment.
As somebody who has been vocal in his efforts to bring the environment to public notice, it was flattering to find the Prime Minister adopting as his own a phrase I had coined (with some friendly prompting) last November in a series of articles describing Malta’s environment: The environmental deficit.
“In the last three years,” I pointed out, “the government has most commendably tackled the country’s economic deficit.” But, on the other hand, “the environmental deficit has remained stubbornly out of control, and is growing. In most major respects the environment has actually become worse, despite the Prime Minister’s well-meant promises to make the environment a priority. Rarely has rhetoric exceeded reality more.”
The environment has finally come to the forefront of the political agenda. A general election in a parliamentary democracy allows us to judge a party on its record. Every five years we are able to measure performance. We are able to ask ourselves, in the environmental and cultural heritage fields, did this government deliver on its promises? Were our natural landscapes and environment safeguarded and enhanced?
We should try to examine these questions objectively and in an even-handed way. In the environmental and cultural heritage fields – which are so vital to our quality of life – individuals should weigh up the answers for themselves and then decide on the way ahead accordingly.
We recognise that on issues of such major national importance, the answer is not always clear-cut. It is a matter of assessing the balance of advantage and deciding whether on environmental grounds Malta would benefit most by voting for the Nationalist Party, the Malta Labour Party, Alternattiva Demokratika or Azzjoni Nazzjonali.
As we look back on the last few years we can, I think, congratulate the government for the launch of the first-ever Nature Park, Il-Majjistral. The waste management strategy has made great strides. The monster of Maghtab has been all but tamed. Wayside monuments and some other historic sites have been conserved. A number of embellishment projects have been completed. The Valletta and Cottonera Waterfront projects and the paving of Mdina have been most successful. The road network is being improved. Some afforestation projects have begun.
On the other hand, we cannot turn a blind eye to the crass act of institutionalised vandalism that saw the unnecessary extension of the building development zones in 2006, or the rampant over-development and land abuse which has marked the last few years. The progressive destruction of urban conservation areas and village cores. The creeping urbanisation of Gozo. The litter – despite the Prime Minister’s worthy vow soon after taking office of “zero tolerance” on this. Our chokingly poor air quality and the threat to our fresh water quality. The uglification of Malta epitomised by Tigne Point and the plans for Fort Cambridge, Pender Place and Mistra Village. The lack of a National Sustainability Plan. The sad state of Valletta.
The stewardship of Minister George Pullicino for the environment will be judged by the people of Sliema, St Julian’s, Swieqi and Qui-si-sana and it may be that Nationalists there will offer up the minister as the sacrificial lamb for past omissions. The Prime Minister now tells us that he will take Mepa personally under his wing. He will reform it and will reduce the environmental deficit as he did, successfully, with the economic deficit.
The government in power is inevitably an Aunt Sally – there for us to take potshots at. We vent our criticism on it because we expect our legislators – the people we elect to power and responsibility – to deliver efficient administration and governance. They are accountable to us. And every five years we are given the opportunity to pass judgement.
The overriding question now is: how has the government performed and would the other party – the opposition – do any better? What is the Labour Party’s track record on the environment? What does one make of the MLP’s plans for two golf courses – one in Malta and one in Gozo – and its plans for Hondoq ir-Rummien? Has there really been a Pauline conversion on the environmental road to Damascus by the Prime Minister? Is the opposition to be believed when they say that they too are putting the environment first?
Or are these simply politicians trying to manoeuvre for political advantage in the face of a resurgent green vote? Is a vote for Alternattiva a “wasted” vote, or should those who hold the environment dear be true to their convictions and take the opportunity to break the mould of Maltese politics? The bottom line is which party is more likely to deliver on its promises? The acid test is to decide which party has the competence and political will to drag Malta kicking and screaming into the 21st century on the environment.
It pleases me that the environment has finally come of age in Maltese politics. It would be impertinent of me to suggest how people should vote on 8 March. Our individual judgements about which of the political parties is best placed to deliver on its environmental promises will dictate the agenda for reducing the environmental deficit and improving our quality of life for the next five years. With the challenges of climate change and global warming, and a multitude of other environmental shortcomings to tackle, it will be a crucial decision.