The so-called “Democratic Alternative” (AD) has made several attempts over the past 18 years to break the political stranglehold enjoyed by the MLPN tandem without success. According to its own leadership, the party has repeatedly advanced solid and innovative proposals geared at solving the nation’s problems. The reality is somewhat different. The party that originated as an ecological pressure group has blended into the local “partitocracy” with panache, proposing the usual blend of leftist-liberal pottage to overcome the population’s inherently conservative mindset under the pretext of ushering in “modern European values”. Here it finds itself in good company with the PN-MLP establishment, the other two socialist parties this country is “blessed” with.
“Modern European values” in Alternattiva jargon means any and every attempt to undermine the traditional family, reduce the influence of the Christian faith and Catholic praxis in Maltese society, foist a multi-cultural and multi-racial society on an unwilling population and elevate bird rights to a level a few degrees short of those enjoyed by human beings. For AD, the naming of State colleges after Catholic saints is unacceptable in a secular (read “laicize and secularised”) society as their spokesperson for finance Edward Fenech has made clear in vitriolic letters to the press on occasion. They want to ban spring hunting as they consider hunting a barbaric practice; in reality the agenda underpinning this stance has more to do with an ideological hatred for the traditional rural milieu than respect for orderly and disciplined behaviour in the island’s fast shrinking countryside. All this from the party that preaches tolerance of alternative lifestyles and multi-culturalism.
Yet the apostles of tolerance – of all that is ultra-liberal – have proved themselves to be remarkably intolerant of law-abiding hunters, building contractors, hoteliers, entrepreneurs, conservatives, soldiers, policemen an so on. Little, by way of discernment, has ever been attempted by Alternattiva to distinguish the good from the bad or the wheat from the chaff so to speak; instead all are bundled into one heap, namely those obstacles in the way of Malta’s march towards “modernity” within the “European” context. Just to what level of modernity and modernism AD wishes to take us may be seen by its international and cross-border ties with like-minded organisations within the European forum. Thus AD has aligned itself with former Franco-German former student rebel and delinquent Daniel Cohn-Bendit and his band of Green lunatics in the European Parliament. The same Cohn-Bendit who has faced charges of sexual abuse of minors. AD’s “allies” also include the Italian Green Party led by Alfonso Pecorario Scanio, a man who enjoys the dubious record of having been the worst Minister for the Environment Italy has had over the past 20 years. Go to Naples and see the fruits of his labour under the recent disaster-prone Prodi administration.
Yet what Alternattiva does not tell us is that its allied grouping in Europe, namely the European Greens are at the forefront of the pan-European movement clamouring for freer and easier access to abortion, contraception, euthanasia and homosexual “marriage”. In short, the culture of death and sterility as opposed to the culture of life. Clearly one begins to understand why no leading exponent from AD signed the pro-life petition promoted by the Gift of Life movement. Predictably, Alternattiva gave the petition promoted by the Malta Gay Rights Movement a warmer reception. Among other things, this petition called for State (read “taxpayer”) funding for transgender hormone treatment, and amending the Criminal Code to ensure that anyone who in good conscience and in accordance with Natural Law considers the homosexual act intrinsically disordered – and publicly says so – could end up facing criminal prosecution charges. A case of two weights and two measures. Such is Alternattiva’s consistency.
On the home front, Alternattiva has made every possible effort to defend a hopeless position: that of attempting, albeit vociferously, to justify the presence of ever greater numbers of illegal immigrants in Malta. The AD crew’s skewed concern for illegal immigrants betrayed a bitterness towards their fellow islanders that had more than a ring of what the Italians have termed “buonismo”. That is to say help and assist your neighbour at the expense of yourself, your family and your community, and to blazes with the social, economic and moral consequences of the silent invasion. If this means removing crucifixes from public buildings so as not to offend a minority of immigrant non-Christian students in Maltese schools, then so be it. If this means an increase in the rate of crime, delinquency, labour market destabilization, and tax evasion then so be it. This false charity needs to be shown for what it really is: an ideologically-based contempt for all that makes us Maltese, for our history and culture, and an even greater contempt for the country’s national identity. The AD crew conveniently brands those who raise their concerns at this veritable invasion of the Maltese islands as “racist” or “xenophobic”. Never mind the bitter experiences neighbouring European States had with illegal immigration and bogus asylum seekers.
But what they have in store for the family is even more preposterous. They bellyache over divorce as a panacea for broken and strained marriages when the real solution lies in reinforcing the traditional values of honesty, decency, communication and mutual respect among married couples. In other words the issue is how to make people behave responsibly and properly towards their partners and not send messages to society that marriage is not by its very nature indissoluble but rather temporary. Why push divorce? Because it is modern, trendy or so AD thinks. What AD forgets is that there is absolutely nothing innovative in this “remedy”, which is nothing more than rubbish from pagan times and which was so widespread in the ancient world. Alternattiva’s concept of modern amounts to everything that gives free rein to pride and egalitarianism as well as to pleasure seeking and liberalism.
In economic terms, AD’s economic “guru” Edward Fenech has, in bygone days proposed halting work on the then half-built Mater Dei Hospital in order to correct the fiscal deficit. Which makes as much financial sense as his latest brainwave to tax the banks at higher than normal rates, and thus penalize the banks’ shareholders for investing in successful locally listed equities. So much for establishing Malta as a financial services centre of international renown. He costs his proposal to increase maternity leave from 14 weeks to 26 weeks at Lm2 million. In fairness, this proposal is family friendly, but can our present day realities afford it? The issue is not that the State will fund the increased leave period rather than the employers themselves, but rather what consequences will employing replacements for just over six months will have on the replacements and the employers themselves. How feasible is it to train and employ people for a six-month period? How feasible is it to dispense with their services after six months once trained and used to the workings of the organisation?
The political, social and economic sophisms espoused by Alternattiva Demokratika deserve to be exposed for what they really are. Ponder these words, dear reader, especially if you get the unassailable urge to vote for the Greens in this election...
Mr Beattie is general secretary of Azzjoni Nazzjonali (AN)