The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Topsy-turvy Thinking

Malta Independent Thursday, 10 April 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Everyone seems to be thrilled because the Labour Party’s election commission has ruled that anyone who is a paid-up party member can contest the leadership elections. Until then, there had been rumours that only delegates would be allowed to contest, and George Abela is famously not a party delegate.

But George Abela is a lawyer, and a pretty sharp one at that. So when deciding whether to go for it or not, he didn’t wait for a ruling from the electoral commission. He read the Labour Party’s statute. “It was clear to me from the outset that I am eligible, because the party statute says so,” he told this newspaper.

Those who propose and second the nominations for the leadership (as in all such situations, you have to be proposed and seconded) need also be no more than paid-up members, and not necessarily delegates. Yes, but here’s the thing.

In all elections that I can think of (I am sure some of you will put me straight if I’m wrong on this one), those who are eligible to contest come from the ranks of those who are eligible to vote. In other words, if you can vote, then you can also contest – hence, shareholders voting to elect their representatives on the board of directors (who must also be shareholders) and at the level we are all familiar with – any Maltese citizen can be a candidate in a general election, and any Maltese citizen above the age of 18 can vote.

If any Labour Party member can stand for election to the leadership, then it follows that any Labour Party member should be able to vote, and not just the delegates. With its strange and silly ruling that only delegates may vote, Labour’s electoral commission has reduced the party leadership election to an odd animal that is neither here nor there.

Given that the people involved will be choosing the man or woman who will make the party or break it further, and who might end up making or breaking Malta, this is a serious business and the rules, which have failed the party so miserably in the past – most evidently in 2003 – just have to be changed to reflect normal practice.

* * *

Dr Joseph Muscat DBA looked incongruous being interviewed by Reno Bugeja on TVM’s Dissett the night before last. He came across as a jumped-up kid (at 34 he should be deeper and more mature) with pretensions and more ambition than talent, sitting for a job interview with the human resources manager of a financial services company, and failing. You could see the interviewer thinking, “I hope the next interviewee is better, because I’m about to despair.”

But of course, the next candidate, Michael Falzon, was even worse, for different reasons. Without the MGM cartouche around his neck and the excitement of yodelling to a crowd of tens of thousands, he seems to have morphed into an exponent of one of these “we live in Christ” movements, all quiet voices and restrained thinking and measured tones and do unto others as you wish to be done by.

Oh, come off it. We admired him in the counting-hall when skin-deep Jason ditched him to keep the boss company and then got a police escort to drive them home to bed, but there are limits. My memory isn’t that short and I can still remember Michael Falzon raging and shouting in the election campaign and never allowing the slightest glimmer of a smile to reach his lips. Jason smiled all the time, even where not appropriate, and the others never smiled at all. What a bunch.

I got so bored with Falzon’s prating that I wandered off for a glass of wine, came back, did some work at my computer with the television on low volume in the background, and ended up turning it off completely. Magnetic, I must say – really enthralling.

I watched Muscat all the way through, on the other hand, because he makes for compelling viewing in the same way as one of those widget figures in the Southpark cartoons. They grate and squeak, but still you have to watch. Three minutes into the show, I felt I was watching Alfred Sant in 1996. He used to smile then, and just as artificially. Muscat’s verbal and non-verbal tics and communication are modelled entirely on Sant. He mirrors him. That’s part of what I mean about his being a follower, not a leader. A real leader would have a forma mentis and mode of expression all his own. It was almost creepy.

The difference is that Muscat’s personality is better-adjusted, which means that he knows, at least in theory, the proper way to respond to certain questions. So when Reno Bugeja asked about the referendum result, Muscat didn’t say, like his boss did, that this is water under the bridge and for the historians to judge. He said, “If it’s a question of whether partnership won or lost, then given what happened in the general election that followed, membership won.”

Yet this is still double-speak and I don’t know why people are getting over-excited about it and why The Times ran a story headlined Muscat admits Yes vote won in referendum. Muscat did no such thing. Like his boss and every other party spokesperson before him, he factored in the general election result. A referendum result is a stand-alone. You do not wait to see the result of a general election that comes afterwards to interpret a referendum, nor do you allow five whole years and another general election defeat to go by before you can rip the words from your lips – and still you can’t do so without saying “given the general election result”.

You see, that’s another trick Muscat has learned from his boss: how to appear to be telling people what they want to hear, without actually doing so, like promising to remove VAT without continuing the sentence and saying “but I’ll replace it with something else”. With this kind of person, you have to be on your guard and with your wits about you all the time, and that’s why I’ve been saying that I don’t trust him. Like his boss, he’s not straightforward, but strikes me as somebody for whom it’s all grist to the mill as long as it gets him what he wants.

In that piece in The Times, he was described as “a high-ranking MLP official”. I’m sorry to have to be a nit-picker here, but since when is an ordinary MEP a high-ranking party official? Or is high-ranking being confused with “important to the king”, in the same way that the king’s mistress or widna used to be considered important in 16th century courts?

Even Muscat’s comments on divorce were an echo of Sant’s comments on the same subject: “We’ll start a discussion…free vote… yada… yada… yada…”. Yes, and pigs, chickens, peacocks and lions will fly – I don’t think. Well, peacocks do fly but Jason’s staying put.

The same process was at work when Muscat was asked to comment about Jason’s pooh-poohing of George Abela on Xarabank. “I don’t agree with that,” Muscat said, bang on cue and flashing that relentless smirk that is beginning to come across as some kind of symptom of a nervous disorder. Ah, but here’s the question that needs to be asked: does he not agree with Jason’s opinion, or does he not agree with Jason expressing that opinion in public in a way that damages the Labour Party (and Jason, but who cares about that, eh?). And then, bang on cue again, he more or less clears up this mystery for me by saying, “The process not only has to be transparent but should also be seen to be as transparent as possible.”

Coming from the candidate who has made his name as Sant’s poodle, and who is being widely touted as the anointed one, that’s a bit rich.

Roll on, 5 June, because this is beginning to seem like the dance of the seven veils.

www.daphnecaruana

galizia.com

  • don't miss