The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

An Evening with friends

Malta Independent Sunday, 13 April 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Recitals at Sala Isouard have a tendency to feel a little bit odd. The hall itself is an L-shaped space that was created by joining several rooms of the palazzo adjacent to the Teatru Manoel. The performers, who are placed at the intersection of the right-angled hall, have to communicate across a compartmentalised space both in front of them and to the side. Thankfully, this was not a problem for the three performers who gave a recital on Thursday 27 March as part of the Friends of the Manoel Series. These were tenor Joseph Aquilina, baritone Ali Rieger and pianist Ramona Zammit Formosa.

If there was one thing I could have criticised straight away, it was the programme on offer, which was mostly a selection of operatic arias. This suffered from being too varied, and at times felt more like an operatic highlights disc than a recital. In today’s world information is easily accessible, not least in music, and one does not need to attend a recital to hear a favourite aria or song. Therefore, it is very difficult to attract the younger generation to classical music with such a programme. This was indeed a pity since the selection included some lesser-known repertoire of great interest. Nevertheless, the delivery of this programme was done with enthusiasm and charm, which kept the audience involved all the way through.

Joseph Aquilina is a powerful tenor, too powerful perhaps for such a small space. His opening rendition of Verdi’s ‘La mia letizia infondere’ from I Lombardi set the pace for the evening. It was a very solid and dramatic interpretation full of verve. Aquilina’s voice worked best with Verdi, with a clean and powerful voice and excellent diction. However, when it came to Massenet’s ‘Pourquoi me reveiller’ and Bizet’s ‘Au fond du temple saint’, one tended to miss the warm lyricism that is so crucial to French opera. The same was true for ‘E lucevan le stelle’ from Puccini’s Tosca, which suffered from being too fast.

Ali Rieger’s voice was a completely different sound world, and I enjoyed the contrast created. Rieger is still a very young baritone, and it was immediately apparent that his voice is still opening up to its full potential. He has a soft vocal texture which worked best in the lighter repertoire. His interpretation of Mozart and Donizetti was suitably light and delicate. Rieger also managed to include some very small and effective gestures to some of the arias and this made the performance particularly enjoyable, especially in Mozart’s ‘Non più andrai’ from Le Nozze di Figaro. Rieger’s voice was less effective in the heavier repertoire such as Wagner, and his diction needed to be clearer at times.

Because of the heavily contrasting voice textures, the duets did not work out as well as they should have. The tenor had a tendency to overpower the baritone, not because of the former singing any louder than the latter, but because he had a more powerful timbre. This also got in the way of the ensemble work, since all three performers were concentrating on the balance at the cost of communication. Ramona Zammit Formosa did a wonderful job with the accompaniment, and provided a very solid musical support.

Alexander Vella Gregory

  • don't miss