The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Malta Rapped by EU for negotiating visa exemption with US on its own

Malta Independent Sunday, 20 April 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Just days after it signed a Memorandum of Understanding for admission to the US visa waiver programme, Malta has had its knuckles rapped by the EU for undertaking such a negotiation on its own instead of at EU level.

A meeting of the EU Ministers of the Interior, held in Luxembourg on Friday, authorised the Commission to open negotiations with Washington with the aim, in the words of Commissioner Jacques Barrot, of “ensuring that all EU member States are admitted into the visa waiver programme”.

In August 2007, the US adopted new legislation that hardened, due to the war against terrorism, its visa policies. The US administration announced new conditions for those countries that wanted exemptions and then started bilateral negotiations with those countries still with visa requirements.

To date, the US has signed Memoranda of Understanding with seven EU member States: Malta, The Czech Republic, the three Baltic States, Hungary and Slovakia. Discussions are still ongoing with a further eight countries, almost all from Western Europe.

According to Thomas Ferenczi, writing in yesterday’s Le Monde, the EU intends to set up a common front to oppose Washington’s demands. Although the EU accepts that each member State negotiates bilaterally with the US on subjects that are relevant to national competence, it also demands that negotiations are held at European level on those subjects that form part of the communitarian competence.

According to Commissioner Barrot the question regards two US demands: exchange of information and the installation of an electronic system for the authorisation of travels.

The Europeans are awaiting clarifications from Washington on these two points, since the US demands are held to be rather vague.

“We do not know what they want,” said Jonathan Faull, director general of the Commissioner. An EU delegation will go to Washington towards the end of this month to open a dialogue.

The exchange of information, requested by the US without more clarifications in the Memoranda of Understanding signed with the seven countries including Malta, is not considered acceptable by Brussels unless on a case by case basis and with full reciprocity. “There will not be any generalized access,” Mr Faull said.

At the same time, the communication of data justified by the war against terror and against organised crime may be envisaged if Washington were to provide guarantees regarding their utilisation. “The data cannot be transmitted without a certain number of conditions,” explained French minister Michele Alliot-Marie. And in any case these conditions must be negotiated with the Commission. Member States are not free to communicate the content of the basis of European data to third countries, a diplomat emphasised.

A second reason for the present conflict between Brussels and Washington is the US plan to oblige all those who want to travel to the US to ask for an electronic authorisation through the Internet, which they can only get if they furnish personal data. Certain Europeans see this as a visa in disguise.

The Americans defend themselves on this issue. They argue that this method facilitates matters, rather than constrains them. The Commission is thus requesting the American side to explain its intentions and to enable the European side to determine whether the electronic authorisation amounts to a visa request or not.

The Commission, the Luxembourg meeting concluded, invites member States to reflect upon the eventual installation of such a system at the EU frontiers.

  • don't miss