The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Spring Hunting: ECJ assesses main case against Malta as ‘well founded’

Malta Independent Saturday, 26 April 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

The European Court of Justice, according to its judgement on a request from the European Commission to ban the 2008 and 2009 spring hunting season, has found that the main case brought against Malta appears to be “well founded”, but that the arguments relied upon by Malta to defend itself could not be disregarded.

The court on Thursday also fell short of the Commission’s request to ban the spring season both this year as well in 2009, and only ordered the government to refrain from opening the 2008 season. The Court has regarded the request to ban the 2009 season as not urgent enough to warrant an interim measure, at least for the time being.

“It cannot be ruled out from the outset that the main action (by the EC against Malta) is well founded even though, on the other hand, the arguments relied upon by the Republic of Malta in defending itself cannot be disregarded,” the court stated in its Order to Malta to not open this year’s spring season.

The court reached the conclusion after assessing the number of birds taken in both autumn and spring reported by the government, finding that even though the take in autumn was reported to be lower than that of spring, the Wild Birds Directive’s objective was not to “guarantee hunting communities a minimum number of birds to be taken per hunter”.

It also noted that the Maltese government had not clearly explained, either in its written or oral arguments, why the numbers of birds taken in autumn were considered insufficient. The court also noted that the directive’s objective was not to “guarantee hunting communities a minimum number of birds to be taken per hunter”, observing that a banning of spring hunting this year ‘would not run up against either acquired rights of hunters or even a legitimate expectation on their part of engaging, in the spring of 2008, in an activity which falls more within leisure pursuits than within any other type of occupation”.

The government yesterday confirmed it would be abiding by a European Court of Justice (ECJ) interim measure ensuring the spring hunting season is not opened for business this year.

The government, which is fighting its case for the season’s retention and defending its opening since the 2004 season before the court, had already stated it would fall in line with whatever verdict the court delivers on the interim measure requested by the European Commission as well as an eventual verdict in the main case against Malta.

Thursday’s court ruling against the arguments presented by Malta, which has argued against the institution of the interim measure, represents the third time the Commission has successfully requested an interim measure against a member state in which it considers “that irrevocable and significant damage will occur to the environment, if no steps are taken”.

The other two cases had involved spring hunting in the Liguria region of Italy and another concerning a road building project in the Rospuda Valley in Poland.

Reacting yesterday to Thursday’s court decision, Environment Commissioner Stavros Dimas commented, “The decision of the Court emphasises the importance of protecting the common natural heritage of the EU in preventing the hunting of birds during this period.

“The order applies to the spring period in 2008 but we consider that it sets a clear precedent in relation to spring hunting in subsequent years also in other member states.”

The Commission yesterday stated a derogation to retain spring hunting had been a “subject of pre-accession negotiations with Malta” and that at the time it had confirmed a derogation would be possible “where the strict conditions set out in the Wild Birds Directive were met”.

Such strict conditions stipulate that spring hunting would be permissible only if there was no viable alternative to the season. The EC contends the autumn season is one such suitable alternative, while Malta has argued otherwise.

In its request for the interim measure, the Commission had argued that Malta had adopted measures to apply the derogation between and including 2004 and 2007, which the Commission considers unfounded, and stressed there was no indication that such a measure would not be adopted this year as well. In applying the derogation, the Commission argues, the Maltese authorities “have failed to show that there is no satisfactory solution other than spring hunting of the species concerned” (turtledove and quail).

The government has meanwhile argued that the hunting of the two permissible species is possible in autumn, but that sufficient amounts of quarry were not available in the season. Supporting its line of argument, the government demonstrated that in 2006 only 11 per cent of the year’s turtledoves and 24.6 per cent of the year’s quail were taken in autumn. It also argued that in 2005, out of 12,059 licensed hunters – hunting practices amounted to 1.3 quail per hunter in spring and 0.42 per hunter in autumn, while turtledove hunting amounted to 2.6 turtledoves per hunter in spring and 0.41 per hunter in autumn.

The Order of the President of the Court published on Thursday found, “the Court has held that the fact that hunting conditions during the autumn and winter are less favourable than at other times of the year is irrelevant” in terms of the protective framework established by the Directive.

Welcoming the court’s decision yesterday, BirdLife Malta observed how the Order “implies that the Court sees urgent need to prevent irreversible damage to these migratory bird species, while a final ruling on this case is pending and not expected before 2009”.

The organisation also remarked on a section of the court finding, stressing the importance of protecting the EU’s common heritage and stated that “the interest of hunters does not appear to have a value superior thereto”.

The EC’s case against Malta began in January 2008, based on a complaint from BirdLife, for having allowed the hunting and trapping of turtledove and quail for the four years between and including 2004 and 2007.

BirdLife Malta president Joseph Mangion commented, “We are pleased to see that the court has acknowledged the importance of protecting the common natural heritage of the European Union and its member states as overriding the individual interests of the Maltese hunters, who have the opportunity nonetheless to hunt these same birds in autumn.

“Malta has a special responsibility as it is the southernmost central Mediterranean country through which migratory birds first pass on their way to their European breeding grounds, and we should be setting an example rather than seeking exceptions.”

* * *

Late last night, the Federation for Hunting and Conservation (FKNK) issued a statement in which it said that it has taken note of the decision given by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) in relation to the Interim Measures proceedings requested by the European Commission regarding Spring Hunting.

In the statement, FKNK said that it was once again expressing its clear and unequivocal condemnation at the action taken by the European Commission which, in spite of the fact that it had never at any stage of Malta’s Accession process ever objected to the declared intention to apply the derogation of the Birds Directive for Spring Hunting, still proceeded with such a recourse to the European Court of Justice even to the extent of requesting urgent interim measures, it said.

FKNK said that it has also emerged very clearly that BirdLife (Malta) acting in connivance with BirdLife International has worked behind the scenes to spearhead this action against Malta.

The FKNK said that it cannot but conclude that the decision given is the end result of the action taken by BirdLife (Malta). In the statement, FKNK said that the fact that BirdLife (Malta) was the first to break the news of the decision to the general public and seems to have had information even ahead of the Government itself, is indeed quite significant.

In the statement, FKNK formally called upon the Government to step up its firm contestation of all the procedures instituted by the European Commission in stark contradiction to the position taken by the European Commission prior to Malta’s Accession to the EU, in particular with the presentation of the reply to the main court case which is due to be presented in the coming days and in its subsequent active defence of the court case.

The FKNK said that the Government is once again also requested to formally bring to the European Commission’s attention the fact that the actions taken against Malta in this instance are both unfair and unjustified and that they go against the understanding which the Government has publicly and formally advised that it had reached with the European Commission up to the eve of the EU referendum.

“This is not only a fight for the right of hunters and trappers to the Spring Hunting period. This is also a fight for Malta to ensure that whatever was agreed with the European Commission prior to Accession is safeguarded, protected and defended”, FKNK said.

The FKNK reiterated that it will continue to fight with all legal means at its disposal for the rights of all Maltese hunters and trappers to practise the sport which they have been practising since time immemorial.

The FKNK said that on behalf of all its members, and the entire hunting community, it expects the Government to act accordingly.

  • don't miss