The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

‘I Would do the same again’ – Joe Saliba

Malta Independent Monday, 28 April 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 15 years ago

In a wide-ranging interview in today’s edition, Nationalist Party secretary-general Joe Saliba says of the party’s handling of the Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando Mistra Bay allegations that, even knowing what he knows now, he would not have handled the situation any differently.

Just days before the 8 March election, the party had been embroiled in a scandal implicating one of its up and coming, environmentally credentialed MPs, Dr Pullicino Orlando, over an application for an entertainment centre in an environmentally sensitive area.

Mr Saliba comments, “I know much more now than I did at the time, but even now with the benefit of hindsight, I would have done the same thing again – there was nothing else we could do.

“It was a very difficult situation for us,” he recalled. “It was the campaign’s last week, we were winning, we knew the issue could have lost us the election and we had to take certain decisions.”

The decision to send Dr Pullicino Orlando as a journalist to a state television interview to confront opposition leader Alfred Sant over the allegations, he said, “was a decision I had to take.

“It was like a chess game. We made our move and sent Jeffrey to PBS, we were sure Dr Sant would not face Jeffrey – and that is what happened. I think if Dr Sant had sat down and had a discussion with Jeffrey, he probably could have won the debate. That was a mistake on Dr Sant’s part.”

On whether he feels Dr Pullicino Orlando had lied to the party in the run up to the elections, he commented, “After the police commissioner investigates the allegations, the truth will come out and we will see if Jeffrey is guilty or not, up to now we simply do not know.”

On whether there would be internal party disciplinary measures after the police investigation, Mr Saliba said, “I do not think we should do anything at the moment. First we have to wait for the commissioner’s report, then I think there will be actions that will have to be taken in due course.”

* * *

When Nationalist Party secretary-general Joe Saliba in the near future steps down from the party’s stewardship after nine years, having seen the party through a successful European Union referendum and two successful general elections, he does so to make way for new ideas and faces he feels are necessary for the party to continue to evolve and win elections.

“As I said a year before the election,” he recalls, “irrespective of whether we would have won or lost the last election, I will not be staying on as secretary-general.

“The PN needs to change, it needs new faces and new blood. People who have been in the post for so long will not carry out the necessary changes within the party. If I were to stay on for the next five years, by the end of the term I probably would not have carried out the real change the party needs.”

Such change, he says, applies not only to the party’s officials, but also to its grass roots, committees and policies.

“Even though our policies have worked and have been approved by the electorate time after time, if we do not evolve and continue creating new ideas for our country, we will not survive.”

Just as the PN needs change, the opposition could do with similar reshaping, according to Mr Saliba – not only in terms of the pending changing of the guard, but also in the party’s policies.

“I think there have to be reforms within the MLP, otherwise they will not win an election,” he commented. “What seemed obvious in this last campaign was that people wanted a change – not because our party or government was not doing a good job, but because sometimes change is good in itself.

“But when they turned to the Labour Party, they realised that it was time for a change, but not for a change for the worse.

“If the MLP does not really change, not only it will have problems, but the whole country will have problems as one day we will have the Labour Party in government.”

With the PN having achieved a hairline majority at the polls last month, Mr Saliba prefers to see the result not as a question of why the PN did not achieve an absolute majority, but rather as one of why the MLP did not win.

“One should see it the other way around,” he argued, “why was it that after practically 20 years in opposition, the Labour Party did not manage to achieve a majority? That was the only job it had to do, win the election. We had to work closely with the government in several areas, such as seeing that our electoral programme was being implemented.”

The omens were also stacked against the PN when it came to polling time – no party had ever won three consecutive general elections, and no EU government had ever been re-elected after bringing its country into the EU or the eurozone. As such, the PN achieved three firsts along these lines at the 2008 polls.

Going into the election, the party’s internal surveys had placed PN leader Lawrence Gonzi eight points ahead of opposition leader Alfred Sant in terms of who it preferred as the next prime minister.

The same surveys showed that while the electorate appeared satisfied with the economy and the government’s performance, it was, most of all, satisfied with Dr Gonzi’s performance as prime minister.

“Comparing and contrasting Alfred Sant with Lawrence Gonzi,” Mr Saliba recounts, “it was obvious we needed to base our campaign on Lawrence Gonzi, and while we had already said beforehand that we were going to run a presidential campaign, there were other issues that convinced us to do so.”

The leadership contrast was the driving reason behind the decision to go for a presidential campaign. But there was also the fact that there was no central issue at stake as in previous elections.

“We also knew we had to make the environment a central part of our strategy because we knew AD was held as the green party. It was, however, only considered as the environmental party – no one would consider AD as a party for any other type of reforms, in terms of job creation or anything else. We knew that if we were to win the election, we would also need the green vote.

“Our electoral programme had a large amount of environmental proposals, which also came through in our visuals and speeches, but I think the best one was that the prime minister would take the Malta Environment and Planning Authority under his ministry.”

The Labour Party, meanwhile, ran what Mr Saliba perceives as a “bad and negative campaign”, which lumped all ministers and the whole of government as a corrupt administration.

“They had two facets to their campaign,” Mr Saliba observed, “one that we have been in government for too long and another where they argued all ministers, including Lawrence Gonzi, were corrupt. It was, however, impossible for the electorate to believe that everyone was corrupt, including Lawrence Gonzi.”

The corruption platform, Mr Saliba says, had a short-term effect on the campaign, but did not work in the long term.

“In the fourth week of the campaign, we were ahead by 5,000 votes. All surveys were showing the Labour Party’s campaign was not working and that we were going to win.”

But in the fifth and final week of the campaign matters appeared to have begun unravelling for the PN. First there was the alleged Mistra scandal where it surfaced that one of the PN’s leading environmental champions, Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando, had pushed for an entertainment development on land he owned in the environmentally sensitive area.

Then, just a few days before the election, there were the allegations regarding AD leader Harry Vassallo, with the green party accusing the PN of having engineered a last minute smear campaign over Dr Vassallo’s long-standing but unpublicised legal tax woes.

The Harry Vassallo incident, Mr Saliba recalled, did not have a perceivable impact on the PN’s campaign – with the neither green party nor Dr Vassallo himself significantly eating into the PN’s voter base – while the Jeffery Pullicino Orlando can of worms, of course, had an impact.

Of the Harry Vassallo incident, Mr Saliba observed, “It would have been foolish, or suicidal, to have engineered such a thing. We could be stupid sometimes, but not that stupid – and not during the final week of the campaign, where we would be very careful about what actions and stances we take.

“The Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando issue had an impact, no doubt about it, but I believe we managed to handle it quite well.

“I do believe the determining moment related to Jeffrey’s issue was the event that took place at PBS, where Jeffrey went to face Dr Alfred Sant at the debate, and where Dr Alfred Sant refused to sit and be questioned by Jeffrey. That was a mistake on Dr Sant’s part.

“It was like a chess game. We made our move and sent Jeffrey to PBS, we were sure Dr Sant would not face Jeffrey – and that is what happened.

“I think if Dr Sant had sat down and had a discussion with Jeffrey, he probably could have won the debate.”

But, knowing what he knows now, does he believe Dr Pullicino Orlando lied to the party when he declared he did not even know to whom had he rented the land in question?

“I think we knew little about the whole issue at the time, having surfaced as it did practically in the campaign’s last week.

“Strategically, the Labour Party held that for the last week because all they were interested in were votes, and not in the truth coming out.

“In fact, it took Dr Sant three whole days to go to the police commissioner with the allegations, and even then he did so only (just) after the prime minister himself requested the police to investigate the matter.

“It was a very difficult situation for us,” he recalled of the undoubtedly stressful time. “It was the campaign’s last week, we were winning, we knew the issue could have lost us the election and we had to take certain decisions.

“What we did at PBS was one of the decisions that I had to take.”

“I know much more now than I did at the time, but even now with the benefit of hindsight, I would have done the same thing again – there was nothing else we could do.

“People ask us, ‘Why didn’t you remove Jeffrey?’ at the time. The answer is that we couldn’t, the electoral law did not allow that and there was nothing that could have removed his name from the ballot at that stage.

“After the police commissioner investigates the allegations the truth will come out and we will see if Jeffrey is guilty or not; up to now we simply do not know.”

But even if the law had not been broken, there is still the pending issue of whether the party had been lied to, putting the entire election at risk.

On whether there would be internal party disciplinary measures after the police investigation, Mr Saliba commented, “I do not think we should do anything at the moment. First we have to wait for the commissioner’s report, then I think there will be actions that will have to be taken in due course.”

But despite the scandal, Dr Pullicino Orlando won both districts he contested, how could that be explained?

“People understood what the Labour Party was doing and they saw it saw it as a strategic manoeuvre by the MLP. Even if there was truth in it, to leave such an issue for the last five days of the campaign made people realise the MLP was only using the issue for strategic purposes to gain votes.

“People turned around and expressed their support for Jeffrey, and the issue backfired on the Labour Party.”

Turning to other matters, Mr Saliba does not see a problem with the fact that the PN consistently wins general elections but just as consistently loses local council elections.

“I do not think there are any problems there,” he commented. “We are part of the democratic world and that is what happens in all democracies.

“The party in government loses the local government elections for various reasons. First of all, people understand the difference between voting on a local level and voting on a national level. The local level has more to do with local issues, while a vote in a general election could change your life. People are well aware of this distinction.”

“The situation also helps the party in government. It keeps it on its toes and very careful. Reading local election results helps the party in government to project and correct certain things within the five-year box. We have done that, otherwise we would not have won the general election.”

On the other hand, Mr Saliba described the party’s defeat at the European Parliamentarian elections as his biggest disappointment, after it had fought tooth and nail to secure Malta’s EU membership.

Mr Saliba sees three major reforms pending before the next legislature – electoral, party financing and local council reform.

After having pushed the matter forward last year, he is confident that a party financing law will emerge from the next legislature.

But, he argued, steps toward the long awaited law must be taken carefully.

“That is the next step in our democracy. It is out of the question that the state finances parties’ commercial entities. The state should only be financing campaigning and research activities, and those areas only.

“I agree with the idea of a party financing law because there is this myth, and I stress it is a myth, that parties are financed predominantly by contractors and wealthy people.

“The truth is the main amount of our finances comes from our supporters, the marathons and our activities.”

He added, “There should be no problem with the parties being more transparent in the way they make ends meet, and I think the people will be surprised. People should also understand that everyone who works with the party is more a voluntary worker rather than a salaried employee – when they see my wage or those of officials and employees, they will be surprised again.”

In terms of electoral reform, Mr Saliba believes the threshold issue needs to be addressed but, again, very carefully.

“I do not believe there should the possibility that a party with one seat would be able to hold the entire Parliament to ransom. That is not correct, that is not democracy.

“There is also the possibility, which almost happened in the last election, that you could have three parties in Parliament but none with a 50 per cent majority.

“Such a scenario would mean there could be a party that had the smaller number of votes governing on its own. This is a dangerous situation, if AD had won a seat we would now have the Labour Party in government.

“As such, the threshold issue needs to be analysed more carefully. I believe, as I have already stated, that there should be a 7.5 per cent threshold and there would be three candidates elected, so at least if Parliament were held to ransom, it would be done with some form of real support.”

Other issues he sees as needing to be addressed within the electoral scope are electronic voting, or at least the electronic reading of the votes, and the potential of overseas Maltese voting by post. He also holds the view that all Maltese, irrespective how long they have resided abroad, should be eligible to vote, particularly those who live in Europe.

Local council reform, meanwhile, should revisit both the council financing, where Mr Saliba believes certain “injustices” need to be corrected, and the frequency of elections.

The current format of yearly “mini campaigns”, he says, should be revised to a format in which local council elections are held either every three years, or every five in tandem with Malta’s European Parliamentary elections.

While coy about endorsing one prospective successor or another, Mr Saliba sees the person as “not just filling my shoes, but also enacting change within the party.

“It would be presumptuous and out of place for me to say who should or should not be the next secretary general, because what I say could have an effect on the outcome.

“I will not say who I think would be the best of those mentioned, although there will also be others who, up to now, have said nothing but will probably contest the post.

“One must also remember that it is not only the party officials that make the real difference to the party, but rather the support from the party’s volunteers from all walks of life. As such, making this party great and electable has nothing to do with the secretary general.

“People see Lawrence Gonzi or myself on television, but there are a lot of people whose faces are not seen but who have given a lot and continue to give a lot.

“I myself will continue to give my best to my party, but will not remain on as secretary general.”

As for Mr Saliba’s own future, on which there has been no small amount of speculation, he says he has “almost decided” where he will be headed, but he is not yet ready to go public with his plans.

A variety of options are in the offing – from returning to university to entering the private or public sector.

“To tell you the truth, I have not decided yet,” he comments. “What I do not agree with is the speculation that I will now be promoted by the government and be given some form of ‘thank you’.

“I do not need a thank you. I have spent nine years as the party’s secretary general – winning two elections and a referendum, building a new headquarters, dealing with the party’s commercial companies – I gave to the party and I also gave to my country.

“Whether my future lies with the private or public sector, first and foremost I need to work. Despite what people think about politicians, after they leave politics most have to work.

“I think I still have a great deal to give, but what I do not need is a thanks from anyone. What I do, I do proudly.”

  • don't miss