The way the Labour Party and its various adjuncts are going on, you’d think that the last general election was a draw and that the Nationalist Party is governing only with the express permission of the Labour Party, and on sufferance. Malta’s little section of cyberspace is brimful of comments by those who seem to believe that the government cannot appoint anyone to a key position without a by-your-leave from the Labour Party. And who in the Labour Party would make that decision, in any case, given that it remains rudderless until early June?
But that’s not the point. The point is that in general elections, as with almost everything else in life, a miss is as good as a mile. It makes no sense for the Labour Party to argue that it almost won, because a near win is nothing more than a complete and absolute loss. Whether Labour lost by 1,500 votes or 15 votes makes no difference at all. It lost. That’s it.
The Nationalist Party is not required, morally or otherwise, to share the seat of government or to appoint representatives of the opposition to key positions that are within its gift.
The ‘we almost won’ mentality is being hyped up by the pro-Labour media. The general tone is “iss hej, it’s not fair; we almost won but they’re not letting us take part in running the show”. Does this make sense? Of course it doesn’t. What the Labour Party is talking about here is a virtual coalition of sorts, based on the fact that it obtained a mere 1,500 votes fewer than the Nationalist Party. But our democratic system and our Constitution do not allow – thank heavens – for anything quite so ridiculous. You either win or you lose. There’s no halfway house called sharing the spoils of victory. Using the arguments of the Labour Party, in any football match where the score is 2-1, the teams would splice the trophy between them (because we almost won).
I can’t understand why they’re doing this, unless it is for the express psychological purpose of helping themselves feel better and raising morale among their supporters. I’ve never been hot on manipulating the minds of the inadequately educated and the ill-informed, so I really don’t approve. Instead of telling people that Labour has a right to key positions on the grounds that it almost won, the party should explain to people that almost winning means sweet nothing, and that the party lost with a capital L and must concentrate on not losing again, rather than on bickering to slot its men into key government positions when they are not in government.
The latest target of this x’gharukaza-imbasta-they-say-they’re-a-government-for-all campaign is Gordon Pisani, the government’s brand-new head of communications. Pisani was the Nationalist Party’s information secretary for almost a decade, and successfully worked through the last two general elections and EU referendum. He has a proven track record in political communications and he knows virtually everything there is to know about government policy. Oh, and another thing: he’s loyal to the government. The Labour Party speaks as though it believes that is a negative rather than a positive. Perhaps it imagines that the government’s head of communications should be somebody who didn’t vote for the government, who supports the opposition party, and who has little or no experience of political communication? I suppose the answer to that question would be yes, given that it thought Jason Micallef to be a superb person to fill the role of secretary-general, Alfred Sant an excellent political leader, and now, Joseph Muscat a wonderful candidate for the post of prime minister. When it comes to choosing the right man (or woman) for the job, the last people anyone should consult is the Malta Labour Party, which has a long history of getting it fabulously wrong.
Now here we have Joseph Muscat, last seen – at least as far as I am concerned – staring at the television camera like a rabbit mesmerised by headlights on one of those discussion programmes that the leadership contenders are using to hawk their wares. He met the council members of the Federation of Industry a couple of days ago and told them something of such astounding banality that I am left in no doubt that I shan’t be deprived of yet another Labour leader for target practice. Because the Labour Party got “almost as many votes as the Nationalist Party”, he told Martin Galea and Tancred Tabone, it expects the government to treat it as an equal partner.
What? Has the man slipped and hit his head? Since when does any government treat the opposition party as an equal partner? The government is the government and the opposition is the opposition. If the opposition is an equal partner with the government, then it is no longer the opposition but part of the government. I really can’t believe that this silly chap is the great white hope of the Labour Party. We sigh with relief when he makes the occasional bit of sense, on the grounds that oh, look, here’s a Labour (potential) leader and he’s talking sense, which is roughly along the lines of oh, look, there’s a dog and it’s walking on its hind legs. But then he says something like this and we’re reminded of the very poor quality control there on the Labour production line. They sure know how to churn them out with bells on.
Yes, the government should consult the opposition and seek consensus with it in the national interest. But at the end of the day, it’s the government that takes the decisions, and the government which shoulders the responsibility and is held accountable for the consequences of those decisions.
The Labour Party and Joseph Muscat should swallow the fact that a great hash was made of things this time round (again) and that it’s paying the price for having made such a bad choice of leader and such a terrible choice of secretary-general. As my grandmother used to say, you make your bed, and you lie in it. It’s no use whining and complaining – or suggesting that the government rolls over and lets you lie on one side of the mattress.