Another year, another Eurovision Song Contest – is it my imagination, or is the fever a little less, well, feverish this time? Maybe our serial losses have dampened our enthusiasm, or perhaps we’ve grown up and stopped being so Swedish about it all.
Bjorn Erichsen, who is not Swedish but Danish and the director of Eurovision television, has accused the BBC and the great British public of failing to consider the annual cheese-fest with the gravitas it deserves. “They take it much more seriously in Sweden,” he said accusingly last week. “They have a genuine love and respect for it there.” Erichsen singled out Terry Wogan as being symptomatic of the naughty British attitude towards the song contest. “Terry Wogan is a problem because he makes it look ridiculous,” he said. “I know he is very popular and maybe that is the reason why a lot of people watch. But one day he will have to retire and the BBC will have to find someone else. It will be interesting to see if that attitude changes.”
No, it won’t – because Wogan doesn’t shape the British attitude towards the Eurovision Song Contest. He reflects it. His successor will be the same, because the British audience is never going to accept a commentator who treats the show with reverence, or who doesn’t pillory it. To the British, and to increasingly many Maltese of whom I am one, the Eurovision Song Contest is a camp, over-the-top event that we love to hate. Over the years, it has become a parody of itself. The winning acts are the ones that realise this, like Lordi, and not the ones that take themselves too seriously, like anyone from Malta.
The Eurovision Song Contest only regained popularity in Britain when Wogan began his caustic commentary. Thanks to him, the show now pulls in around 10 million viewers in Britain alone, and countless other millions who watch the BBC broadcast over cable or satellite. In Malta, those with the Swedish approach to Eurovision watch the TVM broadcast, while the rest stick with Terry Wogan and the BBC. Sometimes, we non-Swedes switch to TVM for the sheer pleasure of hearing all that breathless football-type commentary that is as devoid of humour as a computer instruction manual. The reverse happens, too, and the Swedish types of Europe zap to Wogan to give themselves a frisson of irritation and even outrage. The Danes went nuts seven years ago when he described the Danish presenters as “Doctor Death and the tooth fairy”, which pretty much summed them up.
The controversy made it to the leading article of The Sunday Telegraph last week: “With so many of humanity’s harmless pastimes now delivered to us wrapped in swirling mists of bombast – when football and rugby and even snooker, for heaven’s sake, must be shown, not simply as enjoyable games, but as the elemental conflicts of demigods – Sir Terry Wogan’s obstinately unserious approach to the Eurovision Song Contest goes refreshingly against the grain. Congratulations, to quote Sir Cliff Richard, are certainly due to the BBC for allowing him to go on, year after year, gently ribbing this fiesta of musical inconsequence... The contest is a precious opportunity for the peoples of Europe to come together in a spirit of mutual ridicule, to exchange incomprehensible rude remarks and bombard each other with harmless volleys of La La La and Boom Bang-a-Bang. It would be appalling if it were to be destroyed by a spirit of earnestness or reverence.”
Amen to that. If only some of the more earnest people here, including the Maltasong Board or whatever it’s called, would take that advice on board.
* * *
Now bear with me while I put on my language police cap. We have a new parliament – it would be stretching things to call it fresh – and this has brought with it the usual set-my-teeth-on-edge references to the legislature as a period of time (five years) rather than an actual physical body of people who legislate. I’m not going to delve into the matter of how, in Maltese, “legislatura’” (surely that should be “legizlatura”?) came to mean the five years between the state opening of parliament and its dissolution. That’s what it has come to mean, and I am not about to argue with the rapidly evolving mysteries of the language. The important thing is to remember that “legislatura” and “legislature” no longer means the same thing, even if there was once a better-informed time when they did. This means that “tul din il-legislatura” does not translate as “during this legislature”, because the legislature is made up of people, and not of days, months or years. Now that’s off my chest (take it easy, Jason).
* * *
Alfred Sant, whose constitutional role as leader of the opposition, when he is not leader of the opposition party, is being questioned, stood up in parliament to refresh our memory of why we stampeded to vote him away from the prime minister’s chair three times on the trot.
Somebody really needs to put this man out of his misery, because evidently the will of the electorate is not enough to give him the message. He is clearly somebody who insists on seeing the glass as half full, at least where his own personal interests are concerned. Instead of telling himself that Malta has decided three times in a row that it didn’t want him as prime minister, he tells himself that almost as many people voted for him as for Lawrence Gonzi. This is like trying to jump across a deep chasm, missing the other side by half an inch, and then telling yourself, when you’re lying at the bottom with your back broken in three places, that you almost made it. Ah, but you didn’t make it.
I really don’t know how people took his speech seriously, especially now that there is no risk of him becoming prime minister ever again, unless he plans to challenge the party-leadership contenders unexpectedly, as he did last time. The man is a walking, talking joke, and he should be treated as such. Consider his latest narrative, which is the name he likes to give to his interpretations of reality. A clique of mysterious but powerful people have turned the Nationalist Party into a brand and a tool, and are using this branded tool to control all the major decisions taken in Malta. Sant is afraid that this network is attempting to manipulate the Labour Party, but he knows that the Labour Party is strong enough to resist.
Heaven knows that there are enough conspiracy theorists and sci-fi enthusiasts on the internet, using names like Trojan Warrior and Purple Warlord, debating with each other the various ins and outs of political life in Malta. It comes as no surprise to see evidence once more that the won’t-go-away leader of the opposition is one of them. That Alfred Sant lives in a world of his own making has been obvious for some time. Now, because he sees that some people who sympathise with the Nationalist Party find it easy to relate to some other people who sympathise with that faction of the Labour Party that supports George Abela, he sees this as an attempt by the former to infiltrate and colonise the Labour Party, by using the George Abela faction as a Trojan horse.
Sant didn’t spell it out, but as an expert reader of his mental meanderings (and I should be one by now), I can tell you that this is exactly what he is thinking. It doesn’t occur to him, because he is not one who suffers from self-doubt, that what this says is one thing only: that he and his immediate predecessors have been the main cause of Malta’s internecine political warfare, by behaving like dangerous and threatening enemies instead of like fellow Maltese with different opinions. Alfred Sant, Dom Mintoff and Karmenu Mifsud Bonnici all had (and still have) a serious attitude problem. They are very different people but they have one thing in common: their political behaviour was and is sociopathic. Even those who don’t even know the meaning of the word somehow sense this. It manifested itself in a desire to push their ideas through at all costs, regardless of the damage caused to the people and the country.
Even now, with his ideas rejected at the polls for the third time – the fourth time, if you factor in the referendum on Europe – Sant used his first speech in parliament to defend and justify his plan to cut the electricity surcharge by half and to tell us how wrong we were not to choose him over Gonzi. The most astonishing thing is that he wasn’t barracked from the benches on the other side – and there is strong justification for barracking, too, from the benches on his side, given the irreparable long-term damage he has caused his party.
Alfred Sant, like an unwanted guest, shows no signs of leaving even when every member of the household is yawning, looking at their watch, or making increasingly longer trips to the bathroom, then loudly announcing that they are retiring to bed because they have an early start tomorrow. We go to bed, wake up the next morning, and find him still on our sofa, ready to engage us in another irritating conversation. And there is nothing we can do to turf him out, because when we get back from work 10 hours later, he’s still there, taking a bath and cooking himself some supper.
www.daphnecaruanagalizia.com