The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

What Went wrong, Mr President?

Malta Independent Monday, 19 May 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 20 years ago

What led to the Labour Party’s third election defeat in a row is an obvious question to ask the president of a party that was convinced it would finally regain power after 10 years in opposition.

Is his diplomatic reply, Stefan Zrinzo Azzopardi did not point at a single factor, neither did he try to blame anyone or anything, He simply concentrated on the soul searching process the party is currently undertaking. After two months, Dr Zrinzo Azzopardi said, people have reflected both on a collective and personal basis.

A commission has been set up for the purpose and is studying the party’s performance in order to identify why it lost.

While the party worked a great deal in renewing its policies through the Pjan ghal Bidu Gdid, which Dr Zrinzo Azzopardi described as a well-studied plan, he conceded that the party did not manage to communicate its thoughts well enough.

He feels that the party can do more in order to convey its message to the people; however, he said, sometimes it did not depend solely on the party to send out the message. The president said the party must work on the way its message is communicated. It is not enough to meet a lot of people during the campaign.

Given the slim margin between the parties, said the party president, an analysis based on a single factor would be a superficial one. He said that a mix of factors led to the rare scenario in Maltese politics of not having a party enjoying an absolute majority of votes.

While the MLP reflects and takes action on the electoral result, he said, a broader discussion on whether the electorate is happy with the way politics is carried out, should also be sustained.

Dr Zrinzo Azzopardi did not limit himself to organising the party for the election but also made several house visits throughout Malta and Gozo. He felt that such visits from party officials who are not running for parliament were a positive thing which he intended to keep up with renewed vigour.

He did admit that there was always room for improvement; after all, he said, the 8 March election was the first one for him as a party official. He had unsuccessfully contested the previous two elections after becoming actively engaged in the party in the mid 1990s.

What about the report commissioned by the party to analyse its defeat? The question rebounded against a wall of “the party structures still have to take a decision on the matter”.

This election was one devoid of issues, a factor which might have hindered the MLP in its bid for the government. Yet the party president was quick in pointing out that his party had put the issue of a need for change as its leitmotif. The issue of change, he pointed out, was not as clear-cut as the EU issue, but led to different sub-issues.

The message was taken in by a lot of people, but not enough for the MLP to win the election and the result shows that the Maltese want a change in the style of politics. Thus the MLP must criticise itself also in view of the current political scenario with a slim majority.

But could it be that the electorate deemed that PM Lawrence Gonzi could bring about the change himself?

The people chose the PN at the end of the day; however, there is a lot on which to reflect, he said, especially in the light of an absence of a resounding electoral win.

Asked whether the MLP should champion a particular issue which might be dear to the electorate’s heart, Dr Zrinzo Azzopardi said the party must always uphold its principles and see that social justice is upheld also in the current scenario.

With regard to certain sectors in society which have not been targeted by the MLP, he said although some of them have historically been nearer to the Nationalist Party, the MLP must nonetheless send out a stronger signal to reach them. Dr Zrinzo Azzopardi took the IT sector as an example; the sector has evolved tremendously in the past years. This does not mean that the MLP cannot contribute towards its strengthening for the good of the Maltese.

The MLP president said one also has to send a strong message that it is the party that really believes in giving people the opportunity to advance, especially those is the low and middle class.

University students, he said, must also feel that the MLP, who has always supported in providing education to one and all, is also the party which gives opportunities to all students. In politics, certain people might feel that their needs were not targeted and things are also moved by perception.

What does he make of George Abela’s apology to university students for the party’s behaviour during the campaign? An open and healthy debate within the party that is going through a period of decision-making, he says, adding that as party president he cannot enter into the merit of each contestant’s message.

In view of a consumerist and globalised society, the party did not need to change its principles, which have always put social justice at the forefront, said Dr Zrinzo Azzopardi. He holds that old-fashioned concepts might not be relevant in today’s world but principles create the distinction between parties. On the other hand, he points out; one does not refute principles by renewing them.

A five-faced contest could mean that at least five people were not happy with the way the party was led in the past, one might argue; not for Dr Zrinzo Azzopardi, who holds that the decision to stand for a post shows that the person is convinced he or she can contribute in that position. A varied contest, bearing also in mind other people running for different posts, only helps dialogue within the party.

Such a varied spectrum, he said, will not necessarily alienate members in the future as decisions are also taken by the general conference, of which the leader is also a member.

He said that the conference must first decide who would be the best leader and deputy leaders and then reflect on how to strengthen itself and present itself as an alternative political choice.

But wasn’t the general conference responsible for vetting decisions that led to Labour losing the last three elections? Dr Zrinzo Azzopardi held that everyone holding a post bears responsibility and the higher the post, the higher the responsibility.

After all, he said, the party is not trying to blame individuals but is reflecting on how to do the good things it did better and how to responsibly address the factors that held the MLP back.

The party structures are in place after all; their renewal is part of the ongoing discussion within the party. “We need to find the vehicle with which to reach a destination and how are we going to drive it.”

He said he was ready to contribute towards the renewing of party structures wholeheartedly; a process which he said had started some years back and had to be put on hold due to the renewal of policies in view of oncoming election.

Recently, an extraordinary general conference was called to decide whether party members should be given the right to elect the new party leader. In the end , delegates voted against the motion, which means that only the delegates themselves will be electing the new party leadership.

He pointed out that to his knowledge it was the first time a conference was convened by petition to change the party statute. He said a lot of people were involved in organising it and Marlene Pullicino, who proposed the motion, was constantly kept informed on the organisational aspect.

The decision, he said, was taken by the delegates and the public has the right to scrutinise it. After all there was a discussion and there are always those in favour and against. “The important thing is that a decision was taken after all those involved were given a level playing field on which to propose their ideas”.

Dr Zrinzo Azzopardi said that the conference decided how the leadership should be chosen; a process he described as only a part of the great work lying ahead of the party.

Another petition was doing the rounds of the Labour members asking the party administration to resign. The president said the administration will be under scrutiny in January when its term expires. It could not resign prior to the leadership race as it has the onus organising it. Dr Zrinzo Azzopardi said this should not be taken as a sign that the administration is desperately clinging to its power; but rather being responsible and seeing the election through.

He confirmed that he would be seeking a re-election to his post after feeling that he has served the party well and could be able to do so in the future.

Opposition Leader Alfred Sant in parliament last Monday revealed how Maltese people living abroad were brought in to vote and how the local electorate is the one who however has to put up with various government taxes. Could this spur the MLP to consider adopting a stance of no representation without taxation?

The MLP president said the constitution sets the basis on who should be given the right to vote and the party in past years had taken measures according to the law to analyse the electoral register. People today need to travel more than before and therefore the rights of those people should be safeguarded. However, the authorities must ensure that the country’s supreme law must be adhered to.

“There was a considerable number of people who were excluded from the electoral register in view of their permanence away from the island, but who were reintroduced at the behest of the PN who took legal action,” he stated, adding that the MLP did do so albeit on a much smaller scale.

He pointed out that more people were allowed to vote in view of constitutional amendments that extended the right to people who had a minimum suspended one-year jail sentence.

Rights should be exercised according to the law, Dr Zrinzo Azzopardi said, while keeping in its interpretation by the courts and the current socio-economical situation.

  • don't miss