There is a vacuum in the provision of residential services for children and adolescents who need to be looked after. The authorities continuously face difficulties when trying to accommodate children in institutions. The lacuna in the lack of available facilities especially for boys, creates further difficulties for society.
The Fejda Programme and the Jeanne Antide Home have facilities for girls under the age of 18 experiencing emotional and behavioural problems, but still, this is not considered to be enough.
Before being appointed Commissioner for Children, Carmen Zammit had occupied the post of Homes Director, which involved running the two residential set-ups for female adolescents with personal problems and the two residential set-ups for minor asylum seekers (Dar is-Sliem and Dar il-Liedna), besides other institutions for adults.
The lack of facilities for such a vulnerable group of adolescents poses problems because a group of people with different difficulties and different grades of challenging behaviours live together. Ms Zammit explained that adolescents and youths who have no other place to live, reside with others who have committed certain crimes and could therefore be a negative influencing to each another. “If a girl feels like running away, in such a set-up it is easy for her to find someone else to help in the adventure,” explained Ms Zammit.
The problem is even greater when it comes to boys since “there are no residential facilities for boys with difficult behaviour,” Ms Zammit said. She explained that boys who have committed certain crimes are sent to the corrective facility while others receive day services by psychologists and social workers at the Outreach service centre under the direction of Appogg.
“Malta has yet no strategic national policy for the looked-after children, those who cannot reside with family members and who should be provided for by the state. It is time for scientific research, which allows us to plan resources in the best interest of children, to be carried out,” said the Commissioner for Children.
The state has to provide services that allow all children to develop and grow up in their best interest for them to be able to function well in society. At present, the data available on a national basis is not sufficient and although similar studies have been carried out recently in Europe, probably this has never taken place in Malta.
The issue of lack of resources was clearly identified in the Manifesto for Children, which was recently published by the Commissioner for Children’s Office. Such a collection of proposals highlights that “due to lack of resources, some children are still being sent to the Young People’s Unit or to the adult wards at Mount Carmel Hospital, or sent back home for residential care”. Children are sent to Mount Carmel when there is a need for them to be isolated from others, especially when the child is very violent, and cannot be left with others to safeguard the interests of all until the child calms down and may be placed in other facilities.
The Corradino Correctional Facility (CCF) caters for minors but inmates over the age of 18 are also admitted there. The Commissioner for Children suggested that such a section should include a residential setup catering for children under the age of 18 in conflict with the law for it to better suit their needs.
Ms Zammit said that professionally-trained and adequately paid foster carers who are assessed and followed up by the authorities could supplement and start replacing institutional-type residential care. Although the provision of residential care may not be fully phased out, the Commissioner for Children explained that it should be limited to cases that would not benefit from fostering. Such is the case in other European countries with specialised fostering diminishing the need of building residential set-ups.
Gozitan children having behavioural difficulties and who cannot reside with their families will also benefit from the provision of foster carers. Such cases in Gozo are relatively low in comparison to Malta but after the closure of the Lourdes Home, the only alternative accommodation is the Gozo General Hospital.
“I think we do need an appropriate alternative unit with professionally trained staff, not only social workers and psychologists but also doctors and psychiatrists since the problems of children with difficulties are more acute than social ones. You need a staff that can help them and safeguard their safety before they actually surpass such a stage and are able to go to a different institution or foster family”.
The need of more social workers and psychologists also came out during the interview. Ms Zammit explained that the Manifesto for Children identifies the sectors in which such a need is mostly apparent, namely families in poverty and those suffering from social exclusion, the health services’ especially in the Child Development and Assessment Unit (CDAU), the Child Guidance Unit, and the education sector.
“This is surely not a joke and a lot of funding and resources are needed in such a regard,” Ms Zammit stated.
Besides lack of resources, the Commissioner for Children said that guidance counsellors in schools often lack the sufficient knowledge towards possible career and employment opportunities, especially for those who slip out of the education system.
“It is also our duty to create systems for children with specific educational needs to develop their capabilities.” The Manifesto for Children states that “a more practical syllabus which better responds to the individual needs of each child would be more conducive to a holistic education”.
Ms Zammit said that there were tentative attempts for the creation of small groups of children within a school for them to be better monitored. She explained that there are children who for various reasons, such as a low IQ level, are not capable of integrating with the mainstream children. The Commissioner for Children intends to discuss the issue with the Director General of Education since the capabilities and talents of all children should be developed. Ms Zammit said that the education officials have expressed a wish to discuss such issues in detail in view of a more proper framework.
TMID asked whether child participation takes place in discussions on national policies since the participation of children is one of the four P’s to which the Commissioner of Children is committed as part of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. Ms Zammit said that four of the 12 council members with whom she discusses the activities to be organised at the Office of the Commissioner for Children, are youths.
The council organises the Rights 4 U programme, which discusses children’s rights by means of interesting activities as part of the Children’s Rights Convention.
Asked whether she ever receives emails from children, the Commissioner replied in the negative but expressed her concern about this since there is no proper set up for children to communicate easily.
The Commissioner for Children’s website is still in its initial stages with plans being made for an interactive website to be launched during the next scholastic year. The website is targeted at five different child age brackets with games and relevant information under the relevant age brackets.
“We are also thinking about the best possible ways to reach children in the margins of society – those who are frequently absent from school, those who have problems at home”. Ms Zammit said that being emarginated from society may not always mean that one does not have a computer at home and so the Office of the Commissioner is trying to reach such children through various non-governmental organisations.
The Commissioner mentioned the importance of child participation in local councils and she is currently conducting talks with the Education Ministry on this. Perhaps the launch of such a website will eventually lead to more child participation and a better voice for children, which Ms Zammit described as, “still very lacking”.
Children’s rights often make it to the news when the habitually lengthy Family Court procedures come up. It is clearly known that court delays have negative emotional and psychological effects on children and the Office of the Commissioner said that a fast-track system of cases is to be established for cases involving children.
Moreover, there are only two part-time child advocates in the present system which surely does not safeguard the interests of all.
“A lawyer representing the child should be automatically appointed, payable by the parents or by the State where the parents qualify for legal aid. Children’s interests should always be given a priority which is not always the case due to lack of resources and because parents are often so concerned in safeguarding their own interests,” Ms Zammit stated.
The Commissioner for Children explained that not all parents should be put in the same boat since there are those who discuss the children’s needs but in certain situations, children are at the cross fire even though the parents do not always realise this. On a similar wavelength, the Family Court set up is not very child-friendly and Ms Zammit encourages work towards the constant improvement of such premises.
Public debates are taking place on all the sections noted in the Manifesto for Children. A surely topical subject is the paedophile register and Ms Zammit expressed her concern that there is no way to check whether a person selected to work with children was involved in any such cases. Since children are involved in so many sectors ranging from education to sports and many others, the office of the Commissioner believes that if such a register is not established soon enough, a full criminal record should be requested before people working with children are employed.
“In such a regard, it is the children’s interests which are a priority,” Ms Zammit said while explaining her intention to identify the best manner of setting up and keeping such a register. The Commissioner believes that such a register should not be kept by a particular agency but be more widely available since often enough parents choose to send their children to private lessons, sometimes even at the teachers’ homes.
Asked about other issues she envisions and which need to be implemented in the near future, Ms Zammit outlined the need for an amendment in the law to regulate body-piercing. Although there is a law regulating tattooing on youths under the age of 18, the law is very open in regards to body-piercing. The Health Department does monitor such a business but proper regulations on legal grounds will be in the benefit of all.
With the continuous implementation of the UN Convention on Children’s Rights in our country, the Office of the Commissioner for Children continues to grow, thus needing added resources and more space to carry out its duties.