A man was yesterday sentenced to 13 years of jail time after a jury of his peers found him guilty by a seven-to-two vote of attempting to murder a woman by dumping her in car park after she showed signs of suffering from a heroin overdose.
The woman, who cannot be named by court order, survived the incident and testified in court, saying that she and Brooks Lia, 35, from San Gwann consumed heroin together on 2 November 2001.
Lia, 35, pleaded not guilty to the attempted murder of the woman after allegedly leaving her in a car park “at the point of death” after their having taken heroin together on 2 November 2001.
In opening submissions, prosecutor Anthony Barbara told the jury that on the day in question, the woman, 25 at the time, was found unconscious and partly undressed in the car park of ir-Razzett l-Abjad (near Vibes) after an overdose. She was found by an ambulance crew after Alfred Camilleri phoned for assistance after spotting her when returning from a day working his fields.
Lia, on the other hand, contends that he had called for an ambulance crew immediately after leaving the woman in the car park. The defence team, Dr Anglu Farrugia and Dr Roberto Montalto had raised questions as to the competence of the crew that never found the woman. The defence says that their client could not be found guilty of attempted murder according to law as he had called for medical assistance.
The jurors retired to consider their verdict at 10.30am and the female foreman read out the jury’s decision at about 5.30pm. On mention of the word guilt, Lia’s mother broke down and wept, consoled by his partner.
Mr Justice Galea Debono said the accused could have done more than dump the body in a car park used only on special occasions. He also noted that the victim had participated in the incident and had taken overdoses of heroin three times since the case was brought to light. However, he said that the accused could have done a lot more to preserve her life. In fact, in submissions to the court prior to sentencing, prosecutor Anthony Barbara said that a message needed to be sent whereby people need to realise that altruism should preside over egoism – in plain speak meaning that if a life is at stake, then one should do all he or she can to preserve it.
Mr Justice Galea Debono noted that the accused had 19 convictions on his criminal record and that these were committed between 1990 and 2006. He also said that five of these crimes had resulted in effective jail terms and that he had been found guilty of 10 offences since 2001. The accused was also ordered to pay e1,038 in legal fees.
The case is now shut pending a possible appeal. Police superintendent Mario Bonello and inspector Josric Mifsud led the police investigation.