The Malta Independent 16 November 2026, Monday
View E-Paper

Gynaecologist Files appeal

Malta Independent Friday, 30 May 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 13 years ago

Gynaecologist Astrid Camilleri filed an appeal requesting the court to revoke the judgment handed down by the court whereby she was ordered to pay e96,000 in damages to a patient.

In the appeal, which was filed in the First Hall of the Civil Court, Dr Camilleri said that the judgement was handed down on 29 April was unjust and not proven with any medical evidence.

The court case, which was presided over by Mr Justice Giannino Caruana Demajo, was filed by Tessie Ellul and her husband Joseph against Dr Camilleri.

The court heard how Mrs Ellul had a hysterectomy in 1994. In 1998 Mrs Ellul felt some pain and went to Dr Camilleri, who had assisted in the hysterectomy. Mrs Ellul and her husband had wanted the operation to take place at St Luke’s but there was a queue of some months’ duration so the operation was performed at St Philip’s Hospital.

After a rather normal convalescence, Mrs Ellul was sent home after six days. But 17 days after the operation, she was admitted to St Luke’s suffering from severe pain in her stomach. The doctors at St Luke’s at first thought she had some intestinal obstruction, then that she had appendicitis. At last a foreign senior registrar identified peritonitis and operated.

He found evidence of a perforated colon in Mrs Ellul. Consultant Surgeon Anthony Zammit performed yet another operation on 14 November but Mrs Ellul was left in a debilitated state estimated by the court at 60 per cent.

Court experts said that the operation done by Dr Camilleri was flawed in that Dr Camilleri had made a horizontal incision but when complications arose, instead of making a vertical incision to better see what was the matter, or calling in expert opinion, she had stitched up Mrs Ellul.

In her appeal, Dr Camilleri said that the evidence clearly shows that no perforation took place during the operation carried out at St Philip’s hospital.

Furthermore, she said, the court did not take into consideration the evidence of surgeon Anthony Zammit who had clearly stated that there was no perforation in Mrs Ellul’s intestine.

In the appeal, Dr Camilleri claimed that Mr Zammit, who was the consultant at St Luke’s Hospital explained that it was only the initial impression of Dr Spiegowski that the inflammation in the plaintiff’s intestine was due to a perforation in her intestine, but this impression was subsequently contradicted upon examination of the plaintiff’s intestine under the microscope where no perforation site could be identified.

The appeal also pointed out that there was no mention of a perforation in the operation report and added that it is the nurses’ duty to write down if damage had been caused to the plaintiff’s intestine as alleged.

Finally, Dr Camilleri said that she exercised all due diligence required by law during the operation and, as a result, could not be held responsible for any damages.

  • don't miss