Could you give an overview of the operations and the projects you were involved in during your two-month stay in Lebanon?
All the operations that I was involved in during my time in Lebanon were Civil-Military Cooperation (CIMIC) operations. These operations are an integral part of modern military operations, especially peace support missions, where every effort is made to connect with and win over the civilian population.
While at Sector West Brigade Headquarters, I worked with the Italian Armed Forces, with whom we share very close ties. I was also in regular contact with French, Ghanaian and South Korean forces. Major CIMIC projects in which I was involved included support for the rebuilding and equipping of hospitals and schools in Southern Lebanon as well as improvements to local roads and the infrastructure. The French had a widespread programme that aimed to regenerate the olive industry and local agriculture whereas Italian efforts were consistently geared towards improving health care and sanitation.
The battalions within the brigade also organised their own CIMIC activities and these could range from medical and veterinary assistance, financing of new wells and drainage systems, and the procurement of garbage trucks. Another unusual project was the distribution of fish-finding sonar equipment to boat fishermen in Tyre. With CIMIC, there are no rules on the type of activity or project as long as it is conducive to improving relations between the military forces present in the area of operations and the local population that is hosting them. This cooperation serves to increase the effectiveness of the overarching military mission.
During the latter part of my deployment I worked in the Multinational Force Headquarters in Naqoura where I came into greater contact with the management of UN Quick Impact Projects. These varied from projects to link new generators to partially-destroyed power grids, development of educational, cultural and sporting facilities as well as the rehabilitation of roads rendered unserviceable during the 2006 war.
What was the greatest difficulty you had to overcome over there? Were there any forms of barriers you had to overcome?
One always finds difficulties and training is the key to overcoming those obstacles. CIMIC is no exception. In day-to-day CIMIC work you come into contact with the local population and have to be both convincing and credible while respecting and highlighting to yourself the constraints that may have been placed upon you. CIMIC is not just about being friendly; it also involves serious negotiations that at times can turn difficult - for instance, when you have different religious denominations or local political factions sitting at the same table with little consensus and with no urge to agree to anything. This is the type of difficulty that a CIMIC officer has to handle while keeping in mind all the financial and security constraints which he should never overstep.
It is not easy to do that without generating residual disenchantment – however minor – in some segments of the local population. A particular example is the health care and medical care that military forces provide to the local community. Even if there is a great need for the services and the population greatly appreciate it, there will be local professionals who view the situation as a threat to their sources of income. A commander has to decide where the balance lies and it is CIMIC who guide him in his decision and then face any complaints.
Did you find that the AFM training was sufficient when you started the attachment? Did you feel prepared?
When conducted locally, AFM training is invariably of a high standard. However, as a small force, most specialised training takes place in academies and military schools abroad. This is an added advantage since in this way one is able to tap into the experiences of others. I followed two CIMIC courses in Italy during 2007, one focused at the lower tactical level and a second geared towards planning staffs. Both were of sterling use. Another related course that I attended in early 2004 was a basic UN Civil-Military Coordination Course without which I would have been ill-equipped to know the workings of the particular Civil-Military policies that are employed by the UN. I think the AFM invests heavily in its personnel and when given the opportunity they rise to the occasion.
What was the most important thing that you learnt from this experience?
It is healthy to approach work with a learning mentality and with an eye on increasing your knowledge from your own experience and that of others. On this basis, in two months one picks up many lessons. However, the thing that struck me most in Southern Lebanon was the range of priorities that one can find within small communities. Lebanon epitomises diversity but I did not expect to see such differences on the local level.
Do you have a particular experience that touched you personally there? Is there a particular incident that comes to mind immediately?
Many, but the most touching was the experience of working with the staff and children of a school for children with special needs in Ayta Achhaab. When one sees the dedication and effort of these people and the way they look forward, it really is a consolation and guide for how one should deal with one’s own small problems.
Could you try and describe a day during the attachment?
Although not the most typical day, I would like to describe Christmas Eve 2007 since, for comparative reasons, it is a day that most of us (including myself) can relate to quite quickly.
After the morning Operations Centre briefing and a quick breakfast I was back in the small makeshift offices where for almost 18 hours a day one would toil with the paperwork in between conducting site visits within the many municipalities. For CIMIC, the Christmas activities organised for the minority Christian community implied having also to work extra hours with the Muslim organisations in order to keep an appropriate balance. In the late afternoon the whole CIMIC branch was busy compiling information about the brigade’s CIMIC activities for onward communication in written reports and verbal briefings. Once the evening presentations were over, the CIMIC team sneaked off to a working Christmas Eve dinner before heading back to the container-office to continue the left-over budgetary issues. After running off to listen to Midnight Mass delivered by the Italian Military Chaplain and then trying some soothing hot chocolate (which I was told is an old Italian tradition); it was then a case of interrupting work for some sleep before starting work at a leisurely 0830 hrs on Christmas Day. Since peacekeeping operations are run 24/7 one tends to forget what day it is.
Were there any preconceptions you had before you started the attachment that changed during the two months you were there? If yes, what were they?
As an army officer you are trained to avoid preconceptions as they tend to blur your reasoning and that can be costly. Of course part of the planning process also involves making assumptions where information is unknown. With these pretexts to go by and having covered Middle East issues extensively, there were no huge surprises. Even so, there are always challenges thrown at one's perceptions.
Could you explain the importance of this particular attachment to both the AFM and your career?
For the AFM this operational experience, which was facilitated by the Italian Military Mission in Malta, is a direct way of gauging our preparedness for such tasks. It was also a way of contributing towards international peace and stability. It should always be remembered that uniformed personnel of neutral states are greatly appreciated in UN peace support operations as they represent a moral base that is difficult to contradict and which consequently makes them truly welcome worldwide.
On a personal level, I prefer to talk about the importance of the operational experience for my service in the AFM where the experience is serving me well in my current assignment in the EU Military Staff in Brussels.
How important are these attachments and collaborations with the Italian Military to the AFM?
These attachments are very important for the AFM as they provide the members with the opportunity to obtain actual operational experience in a foreign country. The Armed Forces of Malta has a long-standing relationship with the Italian Military, and it is through this long standing relationship that this deployment was made possible. I would here like to thank all those involved in making this operational attachment possible, especially the Italian Military Mission in Malta. I believe the AFM have all the credentials to work successfully alongside the Italian Armed Forces in the conduct of such missions. We share a common Mediterranean culture, we have cultivated strong military ties and we regularly train with the Italian military. It is a very logical direction to follow.
You have already taken up the post in the EU Military Staff. Can you explain how important this 2-month attachment in UNIFIL was and how it helped you?
The EU Military Staff is a military-strategic planning staff composed of military personnel that are seconded from the Member States. The organisation has what are termed national quota posts and Malta has one post in an important division. I am employed in the Crisis Response Planning and Current Operations Branch within the Operations Directorate with particular responsibility for CIMIC. I also participate in the collective work of the branch which is quite wide-ranging and therefore interesting. The experience in Lebanon is helpful for a number of reasons.
Firstly, UNIFIL is a UN-mandated and UN-led operation run directly by the Department of Peacekeeping Operations (DPKO). Although most multinational operations today have a UN mandate, the execution on the ground is frequently delegated to regional organisations such as NATO, the European Union or the African Union. This in turn means that there are differences in the way operations are in fact run. Seeing at first hand how the UN runs its operations is an important asset for anyone working in my present post.
Secondly, when it comes to CIMIC itself, UNIFIL is somewhat unique as elements of NATO doctrine are merged with UN policies on the same subject. This is a practical arrangement stemming out of the paradoxic fact that the lead nations of UNIFIL follow NATO doctrine whereas DPKO promotes its own distinct version of Civil-Military Coordination (CMCoord) and also runs similar (but not identical) activities to CIMIC through Civil Affairs. For those working in CIMIC at the tactical level, this is a challenging atmosphere requiring flexibility of approach while for anyone involved in developing strategic CIMIC policies, the same experience is invaluable.
Finally, would you do it again?
Yes, of course, but I would much rather see someone else gain from a similar experience.