The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Irregular Migration in Parliament

Malta Independent Thursday, 12 June 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 19 years ago

I read with some anxiety your report on the debate on the Refugees Bill amendments in the House of Representatives (TMID, 10 June) because our MPs seem to be living with Alice in Wonderland.

First, both Minister Dolores Cristina and opposition spokesman George Vella were reported as saying that Malta has international legal obligations. Neither of them seems to have dwelled on Malta’s international rights and interests. Is Malta the only country in the world that has duties but no rights? Do we not have the right to prevent our country from being the subject of “an invasion”, as Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi was quoted as describing the present influx by The Malta Independent on Sunday (8 June)?

Second, the debate seems to have been disconnected from reality. No MP asked the key question of the cost for the Maltese taxpayer of this endless flow of irregular migrants. Minister Cristina was also quoted as saying that “Malta’s repatriation process needed to be improved.” What is the government doing about it? How many irregular migrants have been repatriated since the beginning of 2008? What plans does the government have to step up the repatriation process once the EU’s return directive comes into force?

In addition, Dr Vella wants to have it both ways. He said that he has always been against the principle of detention but “questioned the repercussions on national security if undocumented and unidentified irregular migrants were allowed to roam free in Malta.”

Of course, ideally we would all want to do away with detention centres, but ideally we would all prefer to stop irregular migrants from coming to Malta and to send them back to their own country, or to some other country of their choice in the case of those who are here against their own will. What we need is concrete proposals, not bland oratory.

LOUISE VELLA

Mosta

  • don't miss