The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

EP Approves Returns Directive in finality

Malta Independent Thursday, 19 June 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Although it was rumoured the European Parliament had been deeply split over the controversial Returns Directive, MEPs yesterday strongly approved the new law with 369 votes in favour, 197 against and 106 abstentions.

With the EP having been the last hurdle, following the directive’s approval at Council level by justice and home affairs ministers earlier this month, all EU member states, except the UK which holds an opt-out clause, will have 24 months to bring the legislation into effect.

The clause on the provision of legal aid for irregular migrants aiming to fight their return, meanwhile, has been given a 36-month implementation timeframe.

The directive establishes common, EU-wide rules on the detention and expelling of irregular migrants from member states and only covers actual illegal immigrants - not asylum seekers, whose rights are being tackled through a separate piece of legislation.

As such, the directive will leave the procedural safeguards for asylum seekers unaffected.

The new rules form part of EU efforts to fashion a common EU asylum and immigration policy by 2010, and are aimed strictly at the estimated eight million immigrants currently living in the EU illegally.

In Malta’s case, the directive would not necessarily apply to all immigrants entering Malta clandestinely, but rather only those who do not seek asylum or some form of humanitarian protection. Almost all migrants landing in Malta who come from sub-Saharan Africa apply for asylum and as such are excluded from the directive’s remit.

The directive will, however, apply to other third country nationals, such as Eastern Europeans or North Africans, found to be living in Malta illegally.

Commenting on Malta’s earlier stance against the directive, a Justice and Home Affairs Ministry spokesperson explained how Malta’s main objections had always centred around the argument that the issue of detention should be left in the hands of the member states to determine, but, in the spirit of compromise, Malta accepted the periods of detention set in the proposal which could be considered as acceptable.

The directive’s provision of a six-month detention period, which could be extended by an additional 12 months under special circumstances, according to the ministry, will not affect Malta’s own maximum 18-month detention period.

The new rules, which have been some three years in the making, also provide that unaccompanied minors falling into the illegal immigrant category will not be able to be expelled from the country, while also providing for a five-year ban from the EU for all people who have been expelled.

They also ensure that illegal immigrants are given basic rights across the EU, including access to free legal advice should they choose to argue against their deportation, as well as the provision of food and shelter – obligations Malta already meets.

The issue of the provision of free legal advice for those seeking to fight their deportation was one of the directive’s biggest stumbling blocks, with Malta, Greece, Cyprus, Lithuania and the Czech Republic all objecting to the measure in that it would prove excessively costly.

The concern has been countered by the Commission through an offer for financial assistance for states shown to be in particular need through funds being made available through the European Return Fund. Member states which fail to provide legal aid free of charge will be taken to court by the Commission.

  • don't miss