The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

The Marsascala Wind-powered generator

Malta Independent Sunday, 22 June 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 13 years ago

From Mr M. Psaila

Renewable energy is something we hear quite a lot about these days. We hear how much we need it and how much it should be implemented and it has given rise to companies and individuals who started planning on getting as much advantage from this as possible. What is being ignored all the time is the fact that when a nation starts planning renewable energy, it does so on a national level and not an individual level.

Take the case of the wind-powered generator that was installed in the garden of a private villa in Marsascala. The owner of the villa once said, to a reporter, that this had been done to help the government of Malta save some electricity. The fact that the generator was a great eyesore and created such a great quantity of noise that it effectively made some houses in the area uninhabitable was conveniently forgotten. In my case, the wind-powered generator was erected in front of, and at the same height as, my bedroom windows. No wonder I could not sleep for the whole period this unit was operating.

Some strange things occurred with the installation of this wind-powered generator. The first and foremost is the question of how somebody would do their utmost to destroy a nice residential area without giving a thought to the people living there. Another thing is the way some Mepa officials initially treated this case, before the Authority itself took all the steps necessary to resolve our problem and return to us the ability to inhabit our residences.

An application was lodged with Mepa asking for permission to install a wind-powered generator, and none of the other residents in the area were initially worried, since we were all aware that Malta, as a nation, does not yet have a national policy on such things and therefore we could not see how Mepa could give this permit without the necessary guidelines of a national policy. Imagine our surprise when the case officer in question recommended that the permit be approved, citing UK planning norms as his basis.

To top it all, the applicant decided to install the unit before the permit was actually approved, since granting seemed to be assured. The residents quickly formed an association, the prime purpose of which was to fight this monstrosity that has been constructed in our neighbourhood. We filled out petitions and complained to Mepa and the police, both about the visual aspect of the unit and about the noise coming from this machine, which worked continuously, 24 hours a day, seven days a week. How can a neighbour do this to us?

We studied the UK planning norms and discovered that, while the case officer recommended a granting of the permit citing these norms, he only used those parts of the norms that seemed to help the application be permitted. He forgot to check the other things that are constantly at the forefront of any similar application in UK, namely:

1. Consulting with the neighbours was ignored completely in Malta, while in the UK that is where they start.

2. The rotor diameter should be a maximum of 2m as opposed to the 5.5m rotor diameter of the unit installed in Marsascala. In fact, this size is considered a commercial size and is not acceptable in a residential installation in the UK.

3. The height of the installed unit, at 15m, is way above the 10m allowed in any residential area in the UK, even though applications there are mostly for rural areas.

4. Unlike in the UK, the visual aspect of this installation was – as can be seen from the photograph – completely ignored.

5. A wind-powered generator is not allowed to be installed at a height that brings it level with a neighbour’s windows, as is the case in Marsascala.

6. Great importance is attached by UK planning authorities to noise pollution, and no permit will ever be given if even ONE person is bothered by noise. In our case in Marsascala, many people were unable to sleep because of the noise this wind turbine unit created. It bothered practically everyone living in the area, and neither the Mepa case officer nor the applicant cared about this at all. In fact, how can they do it – bother so many people and not care?

7. Other considerations too numerous to list here, for example: disruption to any electrical/electronic household appliances, birds and bats, the amount of energy generated, etc., etc.

We made studies of various documents, including both foreign and local publications. The following quotes are taken from the official Malta Government publication A Draft Renewable Energy Policy for Malta.

Page 6 Chapter 2.1: Quality of Life

“Improvement in the quality of life is an overriding objective of Government’s policies. While appreciating the benefits of RES, Government is also mindful of their impacts and characteristics. In considering and promoting their development, it will seek to ensure that the quality of life of citizens is not compromised or negatively affected by the choices made.”

The report also states that for medium scale wind-powered generators, update on progress towards 2010 target GWH/annum is negligible, therefore since there is no real national need for the applicant to install this monster in our area, only the applicant may stand to gain by this installation, maybe by selling electricity to the national grid while destroying the wellbeing of all the surrounding neighbours and making their residences uninhabitable.

Page 12

“While microwind may provide a small contribution in electricity generated from RES, this is also associated with other constraints originating from its visual impacts on the Maltese townscape, good neighbourhood and planning policies.”

Page 17: Microwind

“Government has also introduced support measures for electricity generation from micro-wind systems in the form of capital grants for micro-wind generation systems for domestic households.

“Microwind however is not expected to contribute significantly to the national indicative targets for RES-E particularly due to the impacts and planning constraints that are likely to originate due to visual impacts on the Maltese townscape.”

Page 19

“In managing the introduction of renewable energy sources, Government will ensure that on balance, the overall quality of life of citizens is not adversely affected or compromised.”

Page 20

“Small scale systems – photovoltaics, solar thermal panels and micro-wind – are acceptable as, subject to proper building rules, they should not be unduly intrusive. They generally utilize land which is otherwise not used or which has relatively small value.”

The table on page 29 of this publication also states that microwind is placed generally on roofs (because they are small, unlike the unit applied for) in low value site, while medium scale wind generators are generally in rural settings. In this particular case the applicant wishes to sanction a semi-industrial wind generator in the garden of her private villa right in the middle of a high value and high quality residential area, which may allow the applicant to sell electricity to Enemalta but which makes life unbearable for all the other residents in the area. This table further points out that microwind will have negative visual impacts and light flicker and potential nuisance to neighbouring buildings while the medium scale (which would be slightly smaller than the one in the applicant’s garden) will have visual impact, light flickers and shadow effects, ecological impact, noise and vibration and conflicts with other uses, including tourism and recreation, etc.

In the case of the application for the wind-powered generator installed in Marsascala, none of the above points seems to have taken seriously by the case officer and not even the majority of Mepa’s own guidelines seem to have been followed in recommending the granting of this permit, as can be seen below.

In a report drawn up by the UK Department for Communities and Local Government dated April 2007, entitled Domestic Installation of Microgener-ation Equipment Final report from a Review of the related Permitted Development Regulation, a number of interesting and relevant points emerged, including the following:

When a unit is going to be installed they state that “a 10-metre hub turbine has the potential to be very imposing, therefore separation distance from the boundary of other properties (and roads) must be great enough to minimise the impact and make the installation more acceptable in planning terms”. In this case they are referring mostly to rural areas. (They would not even consider a 15-metre mast as was applied for and installed by the applicant, even in rural areas).

Likewise the technical advice suggests that a 2-metre diameter blade (translating to an approximate swept area of 3.14 square metres) is sufficient for domestic generation and helps to limit the potential visual and nuisance issues. The Entec project team DOES NOT accept the (BWEA cited) need and associated risks in a domestic setting to increase that blade size for stand-alone solutions to 3.5-metre rotor diameter.

The applicant’s rotor diameter is 5.5 metres, way too big and therefore unacceptable for a domestic installation in the UK. However, the case officer who said he used the UK planning standards for his recommendation did not blink at this rotor size, as he also did not blink at the 15m height of the mast, as opposed to the 10 metre limit imposed by UK planning on any domestic application. So did he use the UK planning standards when he recommended the granting of this permit, or did he not? He said he did!.

In the case officer’s report, the representations begin with: “The proposed development will create Noisy Wind Turbines and shall Obstruct Sea Views.” Since the case officer knew this in advance, and was following the British Planning Policy Guidance Notes on renewable Energy, in which the neighbours are automatically consulted, I ask why he did not consult me since I am one of those who has to suffer the noise and whose sea views are obstructed. Not only that, but the installation towered over all the adjacent buildings and could be seen from a long way away.

Notes re Mepa Policy BEN 1&2 also makes some statements, the foremost of which prompts the question of who decided the replies. For example, who decided that such a monstrous development is compatible with the urban design and characteristics of the area? What about the visual intrusion, noise, vibration, unusual operating times and bad neighbourliness of Ben 1?

And what about Ben 2, which states that a development will not be permitted if it is incompatible with the good urban design, natural heri-tage, and environmental characteristics of existing or planned adjacent uses, and is unlikely to maintain the good visual integrity of the area in which it is located?

And why was no mention made of Policy RCO 4, which states that Mepa will not permit the development of any structure or activity which, in the view of the Authority, would adversely affect the scenic value because it would:

1. Break a presently undisturbed skyline.

2. Visually dominate or disrupt its surroundings because of its mass or location.

3. Obstruct a pleasant and particularly a panoramic view.

4. Adversely affect any element of the visual composition.

5. Adversely affect existing trees or shrubs.

6. Introduce alien forms, materials, textures, or colours

When Mepa itself realised the validity of the above arguments, it did a very good job of overturning the grant permit recommendation of the case officer, although I still cannot understand why one of the DCC board members took the time and trouble to try to justify to the other board members why the generator, once installed, had to work so as not to be damaged by the wind. In fact he likened it to the wind pumps farmers used in their fields.

I do not know what was on his mind at the time, considering that he was supposedly there to safeguard our environment and that he conveniently forgot that the unit was installed before the relative permit had been issued and that it was the subject of an enforcement notice.

Another salient point to consider is the fact that the case officer mentioned a maximum permissible noise level in his recommendation, but the manufacturer of the unit itself admitted to a slightly higher noise level while, when the unit was tested by the UK authorities, it was found to create a much higher level of noise.

I enclose a photograph of this extremely noisy wind-powered generator so that people can see and decide if they want these things springing up in their neighbour’s gardens, as everybody will have the right to install such units if this one is allowed, since the owner of the villa in question is still insisting that the permit should be issued, while forgetting that, apart from electricity, this unit also generates noise and great problems for the people trying to live a normal life in the area.

This letter is aimed at explaining to the public the danger we presently have, where a home owner is trying to get a permit for a large semi-commercial wind turbine in a heavily residential area, thus opening up the possibility of allowing all those who may wish to install such units in their gardens to do so. This will surely make us unique in the EU, where such things are not possible and residents’ rights are suitably safeguarded.

Such people are hiding behind the phrase “renewable energy”, as evidenced by the adverts that appear from time to time to sell similar units to home owners.

Mario Psaila

MARSASCALA

  • don't miss