The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

Gonzi – The unilateralist!

Malta Independent Tuesday, 24 June 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

The man promised consultation. Before and after the elections. Not only with the opposition but also with the constituted bodies including the trade unions. He used the word flimkien (together) throughout his election campaign. But now people are beginning to pause, think and wonder whether he was taking us all for a ride. Or else if by flimkien he only meant roping in his Cabinet or Kitchen Cabinet. To the exclusion of others.

The man in the street is beginning to ask why the sudden change in approach?

What has made him ditch his own promises and go for what looks very much like swift unilateral decision making?

An independent political analyst told me in confidence that he/she very much suspects that Lawrence Gonzi in actual fact might be feeling politically threatened to the point that he is even prepared to risk being perceived as going back on his promises so long as he comes across as decisive and assertive. This could explain Austin Gatt’s typical reversion to his macho role by dismissing the union shipyards report – which I have not seen and into whose merits I will not go into – as being overtaken by events. Primarily government’s decision to privatise Malta Shipyards. Period.

While some suspect that he might be trying to push his agenda through before “something” might happen to block him, on the other hand one cannot discount the possibility that he could be doing his best to come across as strong and invincible in the light of the right waves that the new Labour leader has been making even in circles that are traditionally Nationalist leaning.

One political commentator/ analyst one cannot afford to ignore or by pass is Ranier Fsadni. Simply because he has much more brains than many others in Nationalist circles and often switches the red light on for his party the moment he begins to smell that they could end up being outsmarted.

Last week he cautioned that Joseph Muscat could be projecting himself as Malta’s Zapatero by promoting a social liberalism that incarnates his ambition to coalesce Malta’s progressives and moderates.

But I personally think that what is worrying him – and many others in his party most – is that according to him Joseph Muscat could have embarked on a project to replace the PN-MLP divide with a ‘conservative-liberal’ divide.

As a liberal himself Fsadni literally cringed when Muscat accused Lawrence Gonzi of being a conservative.

The extent of his worries was betrayed by his concern that it is a label that might stick. As well as the deep fear that the MLP might make inroads among some of the demographic groups where the Nationalist Party has in recent elections registered significant strength; youth and the middle-aged professional class.

With Gonzi’s Catholic Action background and the strong support he has from certain sectors, do not be surprised if he reacts impulsively to Labour’s fresh, secular approach by accepting the mantle of defender of conservative traditional values.

When one factors in all these considerations, one might begin to realise why Lawrence Gonzi has handled the Drydocks privatisation issue the way he did. It is true that there are EU deadlines to be met, and that one cannot continue to live in a state of denial, but Gonzi’s language today is totally different from the peace of mind that he committed himself to offering Drydocks workers in his election campaign. One might argue that even those buried in a graveyard enjoy peace of mind, since no one is there to disturb them! For those who think that I am spicing things up for political mileage purposes please refer to the following GonziPN quote on Radio 101 which was reproduced in Il-Mument on 10 February:

“Irrid inserrah mohh il-haddiema kollha tat-tarzna u ta’ l-Enemalta…” (I would like to put the minds at rest of all Malta Shipyards and Enemalta employees).

Dr Gonzi was reported to have steered away from pointing fingers or blaming anybody for the shipyards’ constant negative results, be it workers, management or bad decisions taken in the past. But his sly remark that pointing fingers was a national pastime that never yielded any results was solely intended to shield himself from having fingers pointed at himself and his fellow cabinet members.

Not only have no public statements been made by the time this article appeared in print of the new restructuring impetus that GonziPN undertook since the 8 March election – almost four months ago – to date, but things seem to be coming to the boil at a time when the Drydocks might be facing a Catch-22 situation that might have been mitigated, even if not solved, had it been addressed earlier.

Gonzi’s behaviour during last week’s press conference was a provocation ostensibly intended to “undermine” Joseph Muscat’s offer to help so long as we were kept in the loop all along as equal partners on this issue. It could also have been intended to test Muscat’s mettle as part of the newly devised PN strategy to portray Joseph Muscat as “more of the same”. Something that does not seem to wash with the electorate.

What has happened instead is that even if Joseph Muscat will or might have been consulted since then, the decision on the way forward has already been taken at an executive level. If my informants are correct this took place last week in Cabinet.

Even if hypothetically all the blame for the yard problems rested on the workers’ shoulders, the government was still irresponsible for allowing the time limit agreed with the EU on the restructuring of the yard to almost lapse before starting to revise the situation. After all 31 December 2008 is only six months away! If low productivity was indeed the main sore, what was government as employer waiting for to impose it the same way that they do in the private sector? If on the other hand there was apparent resistance to a performance related pay system why did government not go public if certain elements might have resisted this and instead insisted on guaranteed payments? The taxpayer which means you and I have a right to know!

A prophetic streak might not be part of my political “attributes” but I could sense this coming from days even prior to the opening of parliament. That explains why on day one I tabled a parliamentary question to the Finance, the Economy and Investments Minister about government’s privatisation programme for the whole legislature as well as regarding what contacts had been made on the privatisation of the shipyards both prior and post elections 08. I also asked in passing about something that is doing the rounds among people who do much business with Libya – the possibility of the privatisation of the Libyan Arab Maltese Holding Company.

I tabled this identical question by way of PQs 179, 360, 681 and 884 and have resubmitted it since then. It was due for a reply yesterday evening for the fifth or sixth consecutive time!

No wonder that by the time that I filed this report on Saturday before going abroad, I was still awaiting a reply.

With all that has happened during the last week I can very well understand why!

e-mail: [email protected]

Leo Brincat is MLP spokesman

on foreign affairs and IT

  • don't miss