The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Only Five community service orders issued before 2002

Malta Independent Wednesday, 25 June 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Even though community service orders are cost-effective and help reduce the possibility of a relapse by the offender, only five were issued between 1985 and 2002, said Dr Sandra Scicluna from the Institute of Forensic Studies.

Dr Scicluna was speaking during a talk organised by Probation Services within the Department of Correctional Services a few days ago at the Chamber of Advocates in the law courts. It was attended by a number of social workers, lawyers and probation officers.

Dr Scicluna said that between 1985 and 2002 there were only five cases of probation orders, including community service which were issued before the 2002 Probation Act.

She pointed out that it is not an easy punishment. “If one is given the maximum number of hours – 240 hours of unpaid work – this is a very taxing sentence as it amounts to six and a half weeks of full time work which the offender is not getting paid for.”

However, Dr Scicluna said that community service orders are of great benefit to society as well as the offender.

“It is one of the few punishments that the public approves of. Furthermore, it is cheap and cost-effective,” she said.

A day in prison costs around e57 while a community service order costs much less as it only involves the wages of the community service officer taking charge of the order.

Another advantage of the community service order is that it helps improve the working skills of the offender and is not carried out at a loss if the offender is already employed. “The community service is carried out during the offender’s free time but has to be completed within a period of three to 12 months. It can also be combined with a probation order,” said Dr Scicluna.

Although the offender is followed by a community service officer to make sure that the work is carried out, and carried out well, if the work is not done, then the offender will receive a warning. If the warning goes unheeded, then the offender can be taken to court again, fined e233 or, as a final resort, the court can revoke the order and the offender will be dealt with as though it was never issued in the first place.

Dr Scicluna explained that the community service orders can be used as a form of punishment for offenders who are found guilty of an offence punishable by seven years in prison and in certain exceptional cases, up to 10 years. It can also be used for criminals whose action is not punishable by a fine – a very wide range of offences.

However, drug and alcohol abusers, people who reveal a pattern of extreme violence, sex offenders, people with serious mental illnesses or those who are unwilling to change at all are not the ideal candidates for this type of punishment.

Dr Scicluna said that so far, the community service orders involved maintenance tasks, gardening, helping disabled people, refurbishing and restoration works, and working on a computer filing system.

In a short address, Home Affairs and Justice Ministry permanent secretary Charles Deguara said that more awareness is needed as it is unique to society. However, more stakeholders, such as local councils and NGOs need to be involved in helping this service to be successful.

In another presentation, Dr Paul Knepper from the University of Sheffield, gave a brief overview of how the community service orders were implemented in England and Wales.

He explained that it was seen as a “value-added” punishment as both society and the offender benefited while it also lead to lower re-conviction rates.

However, said Dr Knepper, it has not been successful as an alternative to long-term imprisonment.

He said that it is a popular measure but added that there are some practical difficulties in implementing it.

  • don't miss