The outline permit for the controversial and highly discussed open-air disco at Mistra was unanimously revoked yesterday by the Malta Environment and Planning Authority board under Article 39A of the Development Planning Act as no appropriate assessment was carried out on the Natura 2000 site.
The permit had been approved by the Development Control Commission in November 2007 – the same DCC board that collectively resigned after they approved an application for a supermarket in Safi against the recommendations of the Planning Directorate.
At the beginning of the meeting, which lasted just over 30 minutes, the new Mepa chairman Austin Walker informed the board members that Mepa had received a letter from the applicant’s lawyer.
The letter stated that the applicant was no longer interested in the permit for an open-air disco, and therefore would not be present during the hearing. In fact, the boardroom was unusually empty with only members of the media in the room.
The letter also stated that the contract between the applicant and the owner of the land no longer held.
The saga of the Mistra open-air disco started during the week preceding the general election last March, with former Opposition Leader Alfred Sant accusing Nationalist MP Jeffrey Pullicino Orlando of being involved in the application for the open-air disco. The police were asked to investigate and two weeks ago they issued a statement saying that they will take action against three people in connection with the Mistra disco case – with no mention of Dr Pullicino Orlando.
In the statement, the police said its economic crimes unit has started cases against Philip Azzopardi, 57, of Naxxar and Anthony Mifsud, 50, of Birzebbuga over alleged private interests in an adjudication process.
A second case was opened against George Micallef, 48, of St Julian’s over alleged false declarations and violation of the Planning Development Act.
Mr Azzopardi and Mr Mifsud were members of the Malta Environment Planning Authority’s Planning Development Commission. Mr Micallef was a consultant with the Malta Tourism Authority.
In yesterday’s sitting, board member Martin Seychell, who is also Environment Protection Director, explained that the site falls in a Special Area of Conservation and forms part of a Natura 2000 site.
According to the Habitats Directive, before any development takes place on a protected area, an appropriate assessment needs to be carried out to find out whether the application will have a significant effect on the site.
Mr Seychell said the directorate believed there is a probability that the application will have a significant negative effect on the protected area – not only during construction phase but also after when the project is ready.
He pointed out that an appropriate assessment was required before any permit was approved – something that was not done.
If there will be a negative impact, the Habitats Directive states that the permit can be granted only if there is an overriding public interest for security and health reasons.
However, said Mr Seychell, if this is the case, then compensation measures must be introduced and the EC must be informed. “Appropriate assessment is a cardinal step,” he said.
Furthermore, he said, the EIA directive should also have been applied to this application.
“The directorate believes that an EIA was required for this process – again it was not done,” said Mr Seychell.
He said the file was not referred to the Environment Directorate and, as a result, screening did not take place.
The decision would have had a direct effect bearing the Development Control Commission, which did not refer the file to the Environment Directorate.
“The directorate believes that this constitutes an error on the face of the record that constitutes a breach of the law and, as a result, Article 39A can be applied,” he said.
Mepa’s legal advisor Ian Stafrace explained that the legal office endorsed the directorate’s decision
“Appropriate assessment was needed on a Natura 2000 site and it was not done – here was the mistake. It was not a case of fraudulent information but an error on the face of the record,” he said.
Mr Walker said that he could not explain why the DCC board took the decision to approve the application.
Board member Godwin Cassar pointed out that the project case officer had recommended the DCC board to refuse the application. However, he had also recommended that if the DCC approves the application, an appropriate assessment and EIA have to be carried out.
In view of all this, the Mepa board revoked the permit that had been granted.
In a statement, AD spokesman for Sustainable Development and Local
Government Carmel Cacopardo welcomed the decision and invited Mepa to consider other permits which merit the same treatment.
Mr Cacopardo called for the board to review the application for a supermarket in the limits of Safi, which had also been approved by the DCC notwithstanding a negative recommendation by the Planning Directorate and also in view of it being outside the development zone.
Similarly, the Malta Labour Party expressed its satisfaction over Mepa’s decision and pointed out that had Dr Sant not brought up the case in March, one of Malta’s most beautiful valleys would have been destroyed.