In what Armed Forces of Malta Commander Brigadier Carmel Vassallo describes as “quite worrying”, arrivals of migrants landed by the AFM this year have risen by some 36 per cent over last year between 1 January and mid-June.
In what Armed Forces of Malta Commander Brigadier Carmel Vassallo describes as “quite worrying”, arrivals of migrants landed by the AFM this year have risen by some 36 per cent over last year between 1 January and mid-June.
Interviewed in today’s issue, Brigadier Vassallo says that despite its limitations in terms of personnel and human and operational assets at its disposal, the AFM has done “admirably” in the face of the new challenges brought on by the growing migratory phenomenon.
And while patrols by Frontex, the EU’s border control agency, are a positive development, he remarked, “Frontex is not the solution – it cannot be and much more has to be done. It is, however, a start.
“If you had enough assets present in an area, you would at least know how big the problem is. Sometimes we have boats that pass by us. We do not notice them and they end up in Sicily or who knows where. They are like needles in a haystack.”
With Malta’s search and rescue region bordering that of Libya, the departure point for most sea voyages that see migrants ending up in Malta, matters were strained last summer.
But cooperation with Libya is in the offing, hopefully before any similar incidents crop up this summer and Brigadier Vassallo confirms the AFM is currently in discussions with Libya over improving search and rescue cooperation.
He is optimistic, commenting, “We believe there is enough good will, also on the other side, to reach such an agreement. We have had meetings in Tripoli and in Malta and while discussions are still to be completed, I believe we are on the right track.”
* * *
AFM rises to new challenges
One could easily say that the last six years have been among the most challenging for the Armed Forces of Malta since its formation 37 years ago, and it has also been a period in which the AFM has risen to new challenges.
Since 2002 the Forces’ already broad remit has been significantly widened with its search and rescue responsibilities having taken on an entirely new dimension with the rise of the irregular migration phenomenon increased, while at the same time being tasked with Malta’s migrant detention centres.
AFM Commander Brigadier Carmel Vassallo, meeting earlier this month just after the AFM rescued some 160 irregular migrants within 24 hours, concedes the army can sometimes feel “overwhelmed” by the extent of the problem at hand.
Quick to emphasise that one should not equate the AFM with migration, and stressing that the AFM does a whole lot more, Brigadier Vassallo describes the phenomenon as something that has “landed in the lap” of the army’s rescue and border control operations.
The first major influx, he recalls, took place in 2002, when the AFM rescued 1,486 migrants from the sea, after which, in 2003, the number fell to just 503.
Since then however, numbers have grown to an average of some 1,750 migrants per year, who are brought ashore by the AFM and, due to Malta’s automatic detention policy, are also kept in detention by the AFM.
And the tide shows no sign of relenting. Between 1 January and mid-June, Brigadier Vassallo cites, migrant arrivals have increased 36 per cent over last year. “This,” he said, “is quite worrying.”
But despite certain limitations in terms of personnel and human and operational assets at its disposal, Brigadier Vassallo believes the AFM has done “admirably” in the face of such challenges.
“In comparison to others countries that have more means and more personnel at their disposal, we can do almost just what they can, but with much less equipment and far fewer human resources.”
At the time of the meeting the Nautilus II operation coordinated by Frontex, the EU’s border control agency was ongoing in the waters around Malta, with the participation of Malta and a number of other EU states.
But the obligations of the international law of the sea leave the operation arguably toothless in effectively stemming the tide of migrants reaching EU shores, in that patrols can only intervene in international waters if a vessel is in distress or requests assistance.
Arguments over international legal instruments on illegal migration has provoked a heated debate at EU level and is an area where the AFM plays an active part through the participation of two dedicated officers.
While the law accords any vessel the right of innocent passage, one of the problems is that rickety migrant vessels that typically carry no more than 30 people do not have any flag registration as required by the same law.
“Frontex,” Brigadier Vassallo comments, “is not the solution – it cannot be and much more has to be done. It is, however, a start.
“If you had enough assets present in an area, you would at least know how big the problem is. Sometimes we have boats that pass by us. We do not notice them and they end up in Sicily or who knows where. They are like needles in a haystack.”
What also makes a difference is where the operations are conducted, Brigadier Vassallo observed. At the time, the Nautilus II mission was underway 80 miles from Libya and 90 miles from Malta - and just outside Malta’s search and rescue region
At that stage, Brigadier Vassallo explained, when patrols encounter a migrant boat they can ask passengers what they are doing, whether they need assistance and ensure all persons on board are given lifejackets. Patrols then monitor the vessel’s progress from a distance.
Brigadier Vassallo recounts one such encounter in which the AFM supplied lifejackets to migrants at sea and followed the vessel from a distance. The vessel later capsised in the dark and thanks to the lifejackets supplied the occupants could be rescued.
“That was an instance of our way of doing things in accordance with international law. If you are in difficulty I am obliged to help you but if you refuse such help...they say you can take a horse to the water but you cannot make it drink, and we have had many instances in which these people refuse any sort of help.
“Our obligation within our search and rescue region is to be in a position to coordinate such missions, and I can assure you we do that to the highest standards,” Brigadier Vassallo commented.
Cooperation with Libya, whose search and rescue region borders that of Malta, was something of a sticking point last summer – an issue that drew no small amount of criticism from European politicians and media.
Brigadier Vassallo confirmed the AFM is currently in discussions with Libya over improving search and rescue cooperation.
He is optimistic, commenting, “We believe there is enough good will, also on the other side, to reach such an agreement. We have had meetings in Tripoli and in Malta and while discussions are still to be completed, I believe we are on the right track.”
Brigadier Vassallo is clearly perturbed over last summer’s criticisms, observing, “The conflict was not as such between Malta and Libya but rather that certain countries were expecting Malta to take responsibility for everything that happens in the Libyan search and rescue region.
“That was most unfair, we still say that. How can Malta, the smallest EU state, take responsibility for a third country’s search and rescue region?”
On top of the AFM’s multiplied search and rescue responsibilities, the running of migrant detention centres has also, quite literally, landed in its lap, with two barracks having been transformed into detention centres for some 1,200 irregular migrants.
“Now we are turning these barracks into either camps or accommodation blocks for immigrants. But if you have a block built 40 or 50 years ago to accommodate 120 persons, and you now have 300, 400, 500 people living in the same block all year round, it is bound to cause problems.”
Conditions within detention centred have been harshly criticised in the past on a number of fronts and from a variety of quarters and Brigadier Vassallo insisted that prevailing conditions are by no means the result of the army having abandoned the centres’ upkeep.
“We are spending more money on their maintenance but it is not enough,” he explains. “But the buildings are bound to end up this way given their heavy usage.
“I can assure you that refurbishment is a continuous process and that each detention centre is completely refurbished from one end to the other at least every three years, if not less.
“It is also frustrating for them to be in detention and to be in such big numbers, but what else can we do? On a per capita basis, Malta’s 1,750 per year means close to 400,000 for Italy or the UK – something they would never imagine would happen, but it is happening in Malta.”
Hopefully the planned introduction of two new detention centres will help to ease the burden.
Such new responsibilities have been added onto the AFM’s already wide remit, which encompasses a single joint command covering sea, air and land. And although it does not engage in war, the AFM has multifaceted responsibilities not normally assigned to an army, navy or air force such as fulfilling the functions of a coast guard, customs and maritime law enforcement.
In the course of its operational duties, the AFM holds the same authority as the police or customs – it can arrest before contacting the appropriate authorities and is also responsible for the collection of evidence, for example during maritime law enforcement or vehicle check points.
While the AFM suffered a staff cut in January following the implementation of obligatory retirement at age 55, abolishing the previous practice of granting extensions to soldiers choosing to work up to 61 years, Brigadier Vassallo is confident the AFM’s numbers, hovering in the region of 2,000, will remain intact.
Some three years ago he successfully convinced the government of the need for a yearly recruitment drive, while last September a new recruitment scheme began offering different options for recruits of different educational levels.
One is aimed at those with an Ordinary educational attainment level with passes in Maltese, English and Mathematics, who only need pass a physical, a medical and an interview. Others, meanwhile, sit for additional written exams, which lengthens the process by about five months.
But once in, not all make it through the 14 weeks of training, which includes a 15-day living in period – a duration Brigadier Vassallo would like to see lengthened were it not for the costs involved.
Only about one in three in fact make it, he added, citing how in the last recruitment of 325, 120 made the final cut.
And joining the army is becoming more attractive following this year’s salary review, bringing military wages closer to those of the Police Force. Soldiers are also eligible for pensions after 25 years of service, meaning that young recruits could retire at under 45 and go on to other pastures and still receive their full pensions.
“I started my working career in the army and obviously I am biased toward the army and am proud to say that. What gives me a little more courage is that these days we are getting more recruits who previously had jobs, and quit them to join the army. This shows they were not just looking for a job but that they specifically wanted to join the army.
A great deal had been said about Malta’s reactivation of its Partnership for Peace membership and while the hype has died down the wheels are still in motion.
Brigadier Vassallo welcomed the opportunity presented by the reactivation, commenting, “We are an island and if we seclude ourselves without knowing what is happening around us, we will never develop further.
“PfP further expands our possibilities to train with other forces, to attend courses being attended by soldiers from other countries. Obviously the more opportunities we have to train the better for us and the more professional the forces will eventually be.”
Frequent meetings are ongoing to determine Malta’s individual partnership programme, where there are some 1,500 different activities from which Malta will see what it can offer and what would in turn be good for the AFM.
Among what Malta can offer the PfP, Brigadier Vassallo hopes to be able to make use of services provided by the University of Malta or affiliated colleges such as the Mediterranean Academy for Diplomatic Studies or the International maritime Law Institute, while in the same fashion participating in similar courses offered by other countries.
He stressed there is no clause within the PfP for collective defence or security, while any such action would otherwise be ruled out by Malta’s Constitution.
But that is not to say the AFM is not active overseas. It sends two officers a year to the former Yugoslavia to take part in inspection teams in accordance with the Vienna Document and to Georgia as part of the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) programme.
As from last year, Brigadier Vassallo explained, the AFM has begun participating in two “small but very significant” Frontex-funded operations – the Poseidon mission in Greece connected to illegal migration lasting 14 days and involving three teams of 12.
Another Frontex-sponsored mission saw the AFM’s offshore patrol vessel stationed off the south coast of Spain for 23 days, where the AFM’s Maritime Squadron played an active role and carried out interceptions.
“These are all very beneficial to the Armed Forces, and they are also preparing us so that one day we will participate in a proper peace support operation, even it is humanitarian assistance and rescue.
“We will not go for peace enforcement, that is too high for us – first we crawl, walk, then run. We will start by crawling.”
Any such participation would be carried out by the C Special Duties Company and any personnel assigned to any such peacekeeping duties only do so strictly on a volunteer basis.
And while the company trains year round and receives additional in countries such as Italy, Germany and the US, equipment is also important, and it is slowly but surely being equipped toward being in a position to take part in a peace keeping operation.
Such operations cost both money and manpower, Brigadier Vassallo points out, with four platoons needed for a one-year peacekeeping operation.
In November 2000, Malta had pledged an infantry platoon for humanitarian assistance and rescue operations that the government might decide to participate in, which would be sanctioned by either the OSCE or the United Nations. The platoon would be inserted into a larger unit belonging to a friendly country and Brigadier Vassallo cites that discussions are underway with the Italian military to such an end.
In 2005, the offer was upgraded to additionally include an observation team of 12 to 14 men sent under the auspices of the UN of the OSCE. Such teams can be seen the world over such as the Golan Heights or the Cypriot demarcation line but are generally costly.
Brigadier Vassallo estimates such an operation could cost a few hundred thousand euros, although the costs of UN deployments are usually picked up by the organisation itself.
If the goal is realised, it will represent the AFM’s next major challenge but one it would undoubtedly rise to as it has in the past.