The Malta Environment and Planning Authority board yesterday unanimously approved, after three hours of heated debate, the construction of long-awaited and highly criticised Fort Cambridge Development Project in Tigné, Sliema.
This was not surprising to the journalists present who, before the meeting started at 10am, found a Mepa press statement on the table stating that the board approved the project because all the mitigation measures for height and the Environment and Impact Assessment had been fulfilled.
When members of the media started taking photos of the statement, which stated that the project had been approved before the meeting had even started, a Mepa official took the document and hid it.
A journalist asked Mepa chairman Austin Walker if the board members knew about it and if there was any point in the meeting being held.
Mr Walker said that the members did not know about the press release and stated that due to deadlines for the press, another press release had been prepared stating that the project had not been approved. “It is not an issue,” he said.
However, after an angry Sliema councillor Michael Briguglio requested to see the second press release, Mr Walker refused.
Mr Walker said that if an investigation is needed, then he will order one and when asked several times by a journalist if one will be opened, he accused him of interrupting the meeting.
During yesterday’s meeting, the Mepa board approved the 341 residential apartments, which form part of the Fort Cambridge Development Project. Originally, the project was open to discussion, and approval or not by the board, during a meeting held on 5 June.
However, on 5 June, after four hours of heated debate, board member Joe Farrugia, who was appointed on the board by the Prime Minister, had put forward a motion postponing the decision on the construction of the apartments.
The original proposal had been of 16 floors, but after consultation with neighbouring residents, the Mepa Planning Directorate had suggested to the developer to reduce the footprint but increase the height of the project.
The motion which was approved by five votes in favour and three against, postponed the decision to see exactly how the visual impact of the buildings will affect the area and sent back the project to the developers. In fact, Mr Farrugia had suggested that the architects consider drawing up a proposal which respected the original 16-storey height limitation in the development brief.
During yesterday’s meeting, the case officer gave a brief overview of the project. He said the Planning Directorate once again compared the visual impact of the two heights – for 16 and 23 floors.
The case officer explained that to respect the building height of 16 floors, the applicant reviewed the design in such a way to keep a height of 63.12metres with 20 levels of apartments to be included without affecting the building footprint.
However, the case officer pointed out that the visual impact with the proposed 20-storeys is reduced when looking at it from various viewpoints.
The project was recommended for approval by the directorate, against a number of conditions including an amendment to condition 13 stating that the building should not exceed 63.12 metres from the highest point at street level.
Sliema councillor Michael Briguglio denied that there was an agreement with the local council over traffic plans and once again restated that the EIA was incomplete because no social impact assessment was carried out, and as a result, said that this does not classify as sustainable development.
In reply, project architect Alex Torpiano said that the permit was issued against a number of mitigation measures that were followed by the applicant. He pointed out that the social impact report was not requested as a reserved matter, as part of an EPS and is not required in any EU directive.
“We did all that was required of us,” he said.
Board member Martin Seychell, Director of the Environment Planning Directorate, said that the all the studies investigated all possible impacts on the population. “As a result, the aspect of sustainable development was included in the process.”
Lawyer Ian Micallef Stafrace, who represented several objectors, asked each board member to take an independent decision and not follow the crowd because they are guided in a particular direction.
He said that there is development on site that is illegal, causing an angry reaction from architect Torpiano.
Mr Walker said that he did not pressure any board members and stated that if any board members have been pressured to take any particular decision, then they should state so.
Furthermore, if anyone feels that one of the board members cannot vote for this permit, then say so now, said Mr Walker.
The chairman also said that if any illegal development is taking place onsite, then this will be stopped and measures will be taken.
Astrid Vella, from Flimkien Ghall-Ambjent Ahjar (FAA), described the whole consultation as false. “It is a breach of EU law on public consultation and added that she is ready to take legal action,” she said.
What is being approved today goes against the local plans – which have been ratified in parliament, said Ms Vella.
She also requested the board to read out a letter sent to the board yesterday morning by the Superintendent of Cultural Heritage.
Mr Walker said that he received a letter, via email at 10.18am yesterday, calling for no negative visual impact on Valletta. He expressed his surprise at how quickly information was leaked, when the letter arrived yesterday morning. “Probably people in this room knew about this letter before it was even sent.”
Mepa legal advisor Ian Stafrace pointed out that the development brief was issued in January 2006 and the Local Plan was approved in August 2006. It was included and forms part of the local plan.