The Malta Environment and Planning Authority on Thursday evening made a bid to wipe the egg which had shortly before splashed all over its face, but ended being accused by a journalist of slandering him.
And a joint statement by two journalists’ bodies yesterday said that Mepa’s attitude was “unacceptable”.
Mepa, now under the august aegis of the Prime Minister himself, and with a brand new executive chairman at its head, was on Thursday embroiled in a highly embarrassing situation, when a Mepa press statement was discovered saying that the highly controversial Fort Cambridge development had been approved.
It was an innocent enough statement, in its wording.
But the Mepa came unstuck when its statement fell into the hands of journalists who were at the Mepa to attend a public hearing that was called exactly to discuss the Fort Cambridge development. It was highly damaging for the Mepa to be declaring the project approved, when the project was yet to be discussed by its board.
Mepa’s communications officer, Peter Gingell accused MaltaToday journalist James Debono of looking through his papers, with the journalist countering that Mr Gingell was slandering him.
Mr Gingell, trying to explain the embarrassing situation, said he was requested to draft press releases before the board meeting, covering two eventualities: that the permit was approved, or that the permit was denied.
As a result, Mr Gingell said, he started working on a press statement and took papers with him to the boardroom, including the Development Planning Act case officer reports and a draft press release.
Mr Gingell said that while he was busy, “a member of the press without authorisation went through these papers.” The journalist referred to was MaltaToday journalist James Debono.
“This same journalist took the draft press release, which being a draft had inaccuracies, with the application number and dates, and maliciously began showing it to the other journalists and the public present.”
Mr Gingell said that during the public hearing, Mr Debono claimed that he was handed the press release in the press pack. “His intentions were to disrupt the public hearing and create suspicion among those present. This behaviour is totally unethical and dishonest,” said Mr Gingell. He went on to say that the Mepa board members were not informed that two press releases were being drafted and “so were never even remotely influenced by these press releases”.
Mr Debono did not take things lying down. He said that he felt his question to the chairman about whether the meeting should proceed was within his right as a citizen and as a journalist.
He accused Mr Gingell of slandering his reputation without verifying the facts.
“What happened is that the press release ended in the hands of another person present by sheer coincidence and all the journalists present felt that the contents of the press release should be divulged in the public interest. It was a collective and legitimate decision taken by the journalists present at the meeting,” said Mr Debono.
A joint statement yesterday by The Journalists’ Committee and the Institute of Maltese Journalists said the Mepa’s attitude was unacceptable. The journalists at the meeting, they said, carried out their duty admirably in bringing to public attention a draft press release by the Mepa public relations officer, “which had pre-empted Thursday’s decision on the Fort Cambridge project” before an official public decision was taken.
“This incident alone sows doubts on the transparency and integrity of the Mepa board hearing and its new chairman,” the two said.