The Malta Independent 18 November 2026, Wednesday
View E-Paper

Law Report: Discretion And proving fraudulent behaviour

Malta Independent Wednesday, 9 July 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

Charles Mattocks

v

Dr Anthony Gruppetta as chairman of the Board of Selection and the Director General (Agriculture)

Court of Appeal

Chief Justice Vincent De Gaetano

Judges

Albert J. Magri

Tonio Mallia

27 June, 2008

This case concerned a civil service employment dispute. The plaintiff held the position of Senior Agricultural Officer in the Department of Agriculture.

The Plaintiff had applied for the post of Principal Agricultural Officer in response to a call for applications. It had been held, by virtue of an agreement signed in July 1995 that “Vacancies in the grade of Principal Agricultural Officer will be filled by selection from among Senior Agricultural Officers”.

The Plaintiff claimed that things were immediately clearly irregular in that rather than simply stating that “...applications from serving public officers in the grade of Senior Agricultural Officer for the posts of Principal Agricultural Officer in the Department of Agriculture...”, in the call for applications, certain other employees in other fields were given the opportunity to apply for this disputed position. These fields included employees from (a) the Urban and Rural Landscaping Unit, (b) the Pitkali Markets, (c) the Plant Quarantine Section, (d) the Programmes and Initiatives Unit.”

Dr Anthony Gruppetta was chosen as chairman of the board of selection set up by the Public Service Commission, to examine the applicants according to criteria such as related professional knowledge, relevant experience, leadership abilities, qualifications and personal qualities.

The plaintiff was the only candidate who had followed a nine-month course (i.e. an entire academic year) at Writtle Agricultural College in the United Kingdom. He claimed that this renowned specialised course should have placed him at the top of all candidates. The plaintiff was in fact chosen to follow this same course due to his competence.

However, as things turned out, the Board of Selection put the plaintiff in the seventh place with 61 points. Therefore, while the other six employees that achieved a higher score were promoted to Principal Agricultural Officer, the plaintiff was denied of this same promotion that he claimed to have merited.

The plaintiff had filed a complaint with the Prime Minister who referred the case to the Public Service Commission. The Chairman of the Board of Selection was requested to provide an explanation as to why the Plaintiff was deprived of this promotion. He claimed that the other candidates had attended a variety of courses and provided certificates to prove this. He also claimed that the plaintiff had only provided the Board with a certificate of attendance in relation to the course he followed in the UK.

The plaintiff claimed that apart from the fact that none of the other chosen candidates had followed a course as prestigious as the one followed by himself in the UK, he had also followed a series of other courses and had over 40 years experience in the agricultural sector which included many years in the private sector.

The Public Service Commission held that contrary to that established by Dr Anthony Gruppetta, the certificate provided by the plaintiff was not merely a certificate of attendance.

The Court was requested to declare that the plaintiff had better qualifications than the other candidates and that during the selection process there were irregularities and to order that the plaintiff’s name be included in the list of candidates to be promoted with retroactive effect i.e. that the plaintiff be remunerated in arrears.

The Defendants raised many procedural pleas. One plea was that this Court did not enjoy jurisdiction to decide this case. Furthermore, they claimed that the Plaintiff’s claims and allegation to the effect that the selection was made with specific persons in mind to the exclusion of the plaintiff, were completely unfounded.

In February 2006, the First Hall Civil Court delivered a judgement in favour of the defendants on the basis of Article 115 of the Constitution refusing to exercise its jurisdiction on the basis that the plaintiff could not prove prima facie fraud. The article states:

“The question whether –

(a) the Public Service Commission has validly performed any function vested in it by or under this Constitution;

(b) any member of the Public Service Commission or any public officer or other authority has validly performed any function delegated to such member, public officer or authority in pursuance of the provisions of subarticle (1) of article 110 of this Constitution; or

(c) any member of the Public Service Commission or any public officer or other authority has validly performed any other function in relation to the work of the Commission or in relation to any such function as is referred to in the preceding paragraph, shall not be enquired into in any court.

The plaintiff argued that the Selection Board did not fall under Article 109 of the Constitution which lists those members who should benefit from this immunity in Article 115.

The Court of Appeal claimed that the Selection Board ultimately enjoyed an element of discretion. Reference was made to the case Borg v. Gvernatur tal-Bank Centrali ta’ Malta (2007) wherein a House of Lords decision was quoted to have held that: “The very concept of administrative discretion involves a right to choose more than one possible course of action upon which there is room for reasonable people to hold differing opinions as to which is to be preferred.”

The fact that Dr Gruppetta erroneously in the eyes of the Commission, described the certificate as a “certificate of attendance only”, was not enough. The fact that less importance was given to his qualifications was not an indication of fraud. Moreover, the fact that the Plaintiff did not agree with the manner in which he was evaluated too did not render the selection process irregular and fraudulent. The Board had the discretion to make a selection which revealed no signs of fraud on the part of any official.

For the above reasons, the appeal was rejected and the judgement of the First Hall, Civil Court was confirmed.

  • don't miss