The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Parliament: Selective Committee to discuss ‘democracy’

Malta Independent Thursday, 10 July 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 19 years ago

Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi yesterday proposed the setting up of a selective parliamentary committee composed of three members from each side of the House of Representatives to discuss the various proposals that were brought up recently by the government and the opposition towards what has been termed as “strengthening democracy”.

In a statement given to the media later, Malta Labour Party leader Joseph Muscat said he had taken note of the PM’s proposal but fell short of committing himself on the matter.

Yesterday’s proposal came in the wake of a set of proposals and counter-proposals made by the government and the opposition, after the government had set the ball rolling in April calling upon the opposition to discuss issues concerning parliamentary procedures.

In the last few days, the PM and the Malta Labour Party leader were involved in an exchange of letters with Dr Muscat saying that the MLP was concerned with more important issues than the issue of pairing and the appointment of the Speaker.

Such issues included the enactment of laws concerning transparency in party financing. The PM replied that he did not have any problem in discussing matters which strengthened democracy, and put forward his own proposals that he would like to discuss with the opposition.

Dr Gonzi yesterday said the committee would certainly not be discussing the issue of capping excise tax on fuel as the excise tax on fuel does not vary according to variations in the international price of oil.

In his statement yesterday, Dr Muscat took note of the PM’s intention to set up a select committee, took note of the PM’s proposal to have equal members from both sides of the House forming up the committee and further took note that the government did not want the committee to discuss the capping of the excise tax on fuel.

Dr Muscat said that he will be waiting for the official terms of reference of this committee to be discussed before committing himself. Dr Muscat added that while he would like that such matters are discussed in Parliament, he also wished that the discussions would not be limited to the House of Representatives only, but would include also the civil society. On the lines of the government, the MLP leader concluded that the opposition would do its utmost to strengthen democracy.

The PM’s proposal was made in the introductory part of his speech regarding the Bill proposing the Freedom of Information Act. Dr Gonzi made it clear that the government was keeping up to its electoral promises and said that the Bill aims to promote transparency and accountability.

Dr Gonzi said that in the last 20 years there had already been improvements in enactments containing provisions concerning the right to information. Some form of right to information already exists in the National Archives Act, the Local Councils Act and in the Code of Organisation and Civil Procedure. The setting up of the Ombudsman’s office was also an important step in order to promote good governance.

The PM said that the primary sources of the Bill were the freedom of information enactments of Australia, Canada and New Zealand.

The PM then elaborated on the salient parts of the Bill. Dr Gonzi said that in the first part of the enactment, the law was defining the persons who can benefit from the right to information. An eligible person, Dr Gonzi said, has a right of access to documents held by public authorities. The PM said that an eligible person for the purposes of the Freedom of Information Act is defined as a resident of Malta who has been residing in Malta for a period of at least five years “and who is either a citizen of Malta or another member state of the European Union”. A person who is a citizen of any other state may also have a right of information in Malta if there is a reciprocity agreement between such state and the European Union.

Dr Gonzi said that the public authority is duty bound to assist the applicant if the latter had made a mistake. The public authority is to provide the information to the applicant, in the form which the applicant requests Dr Gonzi noted, within 20 working days. The time limit may be extended by up to 40 working days if there are reasonable grounds.

The enforcement provision is taken verbatim from the United Kingdom’s Freedom of Information Act, the PM said. Article 28 does not confer any right of civil action against a public authority.

The PM concluded by saying that the Bill is giving a new right to the general public and is a statement of good governance.

Opposition spokesperson for the economy and the self-employed Gavin Gulia tackled various technical areas of the subject such as the matter whether judicial review according to the Code of Organisation and Civil Procedure will exist in the light of the enforcement disposition of the Bill.

Nationalist MP Francis Zammit Dimech contributed to the debate by elaborating on the definition of residence set out in the Bill and the “very simplified manner of how one requests information”. Dr Zammit Dimech also addressed the concerns brought forward by Dr Gulia.

The debate continues.

  • don't miss