The new Unfair Commercial Practices Regulations that came into force in December 2007 set out common criteria as what is considered an unfair trading practice. The aim of this common set of rules is to enhance the European Consumer confidence when buying away from home and to simplify cross-border trade. Common rules and principles reassure both consumers and traders of their rights and make it clear which commercial practices are allowed and which are not.
As a general rule these new regulations ban any unfair commercial practice. Then more specifically ban misleading and aggressive practices that cause or are likely to cause average consumers to take different decisions. Businesses cannot mislead consumers through acts or omissions or subject them to aggressive commercial practices such as high pressure selling techniques. The aim is to get traders to give consumers clear and timely information to enable them to make informed decisions about products.
According to these regulations a commercial practice is misleading if it either contains false information, or it is likely to deceive the average consumer even if the information presented is correct, thus leading the consumer to a transactional decision that he would have otherwise not taken. Through these criteria the consumer is not only protected when deceived but even if not deceived. The possibility of deception alone can be considered misleading.
Misleading omissions are also banned under these regulations because consumers need information to make informed choices. More specifically it is misleading to omit material information that the average consumer needs or to provide material information in an unclear, unintelligible or ambiguous manner. A trader should also identify the commercial intent of the commercial practice.
Aggressive commercial practices are for the first time prohibited under the Consumer Affairs Act. A practice is considered aggressive if it intimidates or exploits consumers in the context of the circumstances, such as harassment, coercion or undue influence. Thus restricting the consumer’s ability to make free or informed decisions. For example, coercion may force consumers to buy a product at a higher price or on disadvantageous terms.
These regulations not only impose a blanket ban on unfair commercial practices in general but also set out a list of practices that are out rightly banned. This list is known as the “Black List” and it consists of 31 practices that are always deemed unfair. This list includes a “dirty dozen” of schemes which are well known to cause consumer detriment. Amongst these we find:
· Bait Advertising, which is advertising that lures the consumer into buying from a company by advertising a product at a very low price without having a reasonable stock available.
· Fake “Free” offers where businesses falsely claim that a product is “free” when in reality consumers have to pay other than unavoidable cost of responding to the commercial practice and collecting or paying for delivery of the item. Direct exhortations to children to buy advertised products or to pester their parents or other adults to buy advertised products for them. This ban does not only apply for television but it extends to all media.
· False claims about curative capacity such as cure from allergies, solution to hair loss or achievement of weight loss.
· Advertorials that fail to make clear that a trader has paid for media promotion.
· Pyramid Schemes where compensation is derived primarily from the introduction of other consumers into the scheme rather than from the sale or consumption of products.
· Prize Winning where the trader creates the false impression that the consumer has won a prize when in reality there is no prize or else the prize is subject to the consumer paying money or incurring a cost.
· Misleading impression of consumers’ rights where a trader presents rights given to consumers in law as a distinctive feature of the trader’s.
· Limited offers where a trader falsely states that a product will only be available for a very limited time to deprive consumers of sufficient opportunity to make an informed choice.
· Language of after-sales service where the consumer is not informed before buying a particular product or service that the after sales service will only be available in a particular language.
· Inertia Selling where the trader demands immediate or deferred payment for the products supplied by the trader but not solicited by the consumer.
· Europe-wide guarantees creating the false impression that after-sales service in relation to a product is available in a Member State other than the one in which the product is sold.
These regulations only protect the economic interest of consumers and not other interests such as health or safety. Even taste and decency are outside the scope of these regulations. In other words, practices which do not directly harm the economic interest of consumers are not regulated. Moreover, these regulations only apply to business to consumer practices and thus commercial practices between businesses, such as boycotts or refusal to supply are not covered.
This article is intended for information purposes only. Any legal claim or action taken in the event of a dispute should be based solely on the legal texts concerned. For further information one can contact the Consumer and Competition Division on Freephone 8007-4400.
Odette Vella is senior information officer, Consumer and Competition Division