Although the new telephone and Internet eavesdropping system commissioned by the Malta Communications Authority on behalf of the Malta Security Service began operating in October 2006, it has been up and running in the absence of a set of technical obligations that undertakings related to the system need to adhere to.
The lack of technical obligations, a situation that had persisted for at least close to a year and a half, leaves a concerning void in the regulation and operation of the State’s practice of tapping the Maltese public’s phone calls and monitoring their Internet communications.
In its recent 2007 annual report, the Authority stated with reference to the so-called Unified Lawful Interception (ULI) system, “A manual listing the technical obligations that undertakings need to adhere to, was drafted and circulated among interested parties for their feedback. It is anticipated that the manual will be published by the end of the first quarter of 2008.”
Considering the extreme sensitivity of the eavesdropping practice, the fact that the any technical obligation, no matter how minute, has remained undefined for any period of time, and that the process of drawing up such technical obligations has taken as long as it has, is indeed disconcerting.
Additionally, the Authority notes in its projections for the system’s costs for 2007-2008, that its capacity as well as the technologies covered could very well need to be increased this year.
As the Authority pointed out in the costings document, “There exists the possibility that additional equipment needed for the interception of new services and technologies together with increased capacities will be required during 2008.”
In 2006, the Authority on the MSS’ behalf commissioned new software-based eavesdropping technology, a so-called Unified Lawful Interception system, which incorporates both telephony and Internet, from New York-based Verint Systems, whose parent company, Comverse Technology, has been criticised for its links to the Israeli government.
The new system provided for a departure from the previous modus operandi, which had previously required Malta’s authorised telephony operators and service providers to supply the Malta Security Service with eavesdropping equipment.
Now, through the Verint ULI system, Malta’s operators no longer supply the equipment but instead foot the bill for the running of the Verint system – to the estimated tune of e426,275 for the period between November 2007 and October 2008. The amount is shared proportionately between Malta’s operators and service providers based on their total gross revenue from relevant services.
The contribution includes the costs incurred for the design, supply, installation, implementation, use and maintenance of the ULI system, as well as the costs of undertakings to link it with the MSS’ equipment.
The cost for the use of the Verint system alone for the current year is projected at e372,099.