Although I had prepared a large part of this article earlier, the report about the meeting on the possibility of a fixed-wing operation in Gozo in The Malta Independent on Sunday of 6 July gave me the opportunity to add some interesting points.
The following provides an overview regarding potential ground infrastructure / aircraft type requirements, and, importantly, fares, illustrated by various practical examples of aircraft/airstrip combinations of other EU countries. Further issues dealt with are minimising environmental impact, possible financial interests against an airstrip, what went wrong with the Helisureste service beyond fares, distribution channel management, competition, as well as some other issues ranging from subsidies to racetracks and airparks. However, potential sites will not be discussed.
Britten-Norman Islander
Sold well over 1,000, this small British-Romanian plane, powered by two 260hp piston engines, operates in most basic environments. Malta-Gozo Air Service also bought it in the late 1960s – but then had not provided the airstrip.
Britten-Norman states a ground roll of 190 metres and 370 metres to clear a 50 ft obstacle for take-off. The landing roll is a mere 140 metres, with 300 metres over the obstacle. One should add something for the summer heat (hot weather means longer take-off rolls), but one will also not have full fuel load. A grass runway suffices.
How about fares with present EU operations?
Franco-Caribbean St Barth Commuter runs the highly frequent 30km flight from the international airport at St Martin to St Barthelemy, a sector directly comparable to the MIA-Gozo run. The plane takes nine passengers with carry-on luggage, or seven with normal luggage; return fare is e120.
In Germany, the 10-kilometre hop from Norddeich to Juist Island, FLN (Frisia Luftverkehr Norddeich) charges e68, while a scenic flight lasting 30 minutes costs e120 per person.
The fares of LFH (Luftverkehr Frisia Harle) are similar: from Harle to Wangerooge, a five-minute flight, tourists pay e60, the Baltrum hop (10 minutes) costs circa e100 return. The Baltrum distance is shorter than MIA-heliport.
How about slightly longer sectors?
Fares in the Scottish islands are highly subsidised to keep tiny very isolated communities linked, so they cannot be compared.
OLT, a larger operator from Bremen, runs Islander flights to/from offshore island Helgoland. The 65-km run from Büsum costs e150 return. The 90-km run from Bremerhaven, distance equivalent to Gozo-Ragusa, costs e160 return.
For the Scilly Isles, Skybus runs Islanders and Twin Otters at high frequency. A return fare from the small Land’s End grass strip, a 50-km distance, costs between £109 and £129 (e160 to e180).
For about 40 years, the Aran Islands in Ireland’s far west, which have three airstrips, basically 500 by 15 metre wide pieces of bumpy paved road in a meadow, are linked from Connemara “regional airport” by Aer Arann Islands. For the 15-minute hop, five kilometres shorter than the Malta-Gozo run, one pays e45 return, with group bookings e40. Half an hour of scenic flight costs e35 per person.
The reasons for the comparatively lower fares could be manifold: Ireland’s favourable fiscal environment and subsidies, or regional carrier Aer Arann cross-subsidizing its roots. While the first is a fact, the latter two cannot be confirmed or denied here. The big Aer Arann operation has only been in existence for a few years. With the good ferry service, would flights be subsidised? Would scenic flights be subsidized?
The Islander requires little infrastructure. A grass/gravel strip or a converted country road (repaving, broadening to 15m, removal of side walls) is sufficient.
But carrying just seven passengers, it occupies a whole slot. Except for Aer Arann Islands, all EU operations today have fares comparable to Helisureste’s.
Synergy Aviation had projected e45-70 Gozo return fare for an Islander service back in 2006 – at 2006 fuel prices.
And alternatives?
Needing quite more runway, the Piper Navajo Chieftain, a twin-piston engine nine-seater out of production since the 1980s, runs, for example, with Flugfelag Vestmannaeyja along with Islanders, linking the Vestmanner Islands to Bakki airstrip on mainland Iceland (16 kms, equal to Luqa-Mellieha): e47 return, while Selfoss (65 kms) costs e92 return.
Operations with single-engine nine-seaters (more passengers not permitted in the EU, even if aircraft has more seats and only daylight operations) are rare. Finistair links Brest (France) with Ouessant island (50 kms) with a Cessna Grand Caravan turboprop: e63 one-way, ca. e90 return; if one stays some days on the island, it is e126. Fares in the French Caribbean with Air Caraibes are not trashy. For the Berlin-Strausberg to Heringsdorf/Usedom run (150 kms) LTS (Antonov-2) charges e250 return.
These are the dimensions in this segment.
The 19 seaters
Ninteen-seater planes have a capacity more similar to MAC’s Soviet wide-body helicopters. Excluded are Beechcraft 1900, Fairchild Metroliner and British Aerospace Jetstream 31, out of production for the past five to 15 years and unsuitable for extremely short flights. Their pressurized cabins are unnecessary here and ahve higher costs (acquisition/maintenance). Compared to the four following examples, they generally also require longer runways: extra cost and environmental impact. The evaluated aircraft all have two turbines.
The Britten-Norman Trislander, mentioned at the presentation, still hopping around the UK Channel Islands, has been out of production for many years, and only a fourth of production are still operational. Shorts Skyvan and Israeli Arava are becoming rare too. Embraer 110s are still around in larger numbers but have been out of production also since the early 1990s and require too long a runway. One needs aircraft/airstrip combinations providing service over the next decades.
For commercial passenger applications beyond Malta, with Air Malta (Catania, Palermo, Reggio, Tunis, Tripolis, Benghazi, Athens plus Corfu and Cagliari charters), Libyan Airlines (Tripolis), Ryanair (Bari) and Sevenair (Tunis), all feasible airports in the region are already connected and not forgetting Virtu Ferries.
No way will it be cheaper to first fly to Sicily and then to Gozo than via Malta, because the higher cost per air seat mile (casm) of small regional planes eats all real/imagined benefit (fares below). The Malta-Trapani (air base, Ryanair airport) route that local carrier European 2000 (Metroliner) started around 2005 soon disappeared. Would the concept work to/from much smaller destination/catchment area Gozo at much higher fuel prices? And, as it was mentioned, how can a small propeller plane, flying from Cyprus, with a stopover for refuelling, compete against Emirates’ Boeing 777?
DHC / Viking Twin Otter
Almost 850 Twin Otters were sold from the late 1960s to 1989. After 20 years of production standstill, Viking, the Canadian product support firm that also owns tooling and production rights, is re-launching it, taking orders for US$3.5-4 million per unit. A contingent is available through a leasing firm.
In Greece, AirSeaLines, partly owned by Canadian Harbour Air (partners in Harbour Air Malta), operate amphibian floatplane Twin Otters from Corfu to neighbouring islands and Brindisi. A 30-minute scenic flight costs e100 per person. Corfu-Cephalonia, ca. 150 kms, costs e175 return. The Brindisi run, (distance the same as Malta-Catania), costs e230. The Corfu to Paxos (50 kms) return costs e70, no taxes apply.
A scheduled service to a 400m-long paved strip can be found in The Netherlands – the Netherlands Antilles, which is, strictly speaking, non-EU territory (unlike the French Caribbean). For the 50km ride from St Maarten to Saba Island Winair charges e75 return.
Loganair links some isolated Scottish island communities under the British Airways franchise, now starting under the FlyBe label. At Barra (Outer Hebrides) the plane lands and parks on a wet sandy area, partly covered with some centimetres of water at low tide: in fact the “airport” advises passengers to come wearing wellies for (de-)boarding particularly in rainy weather, which illustrates that the DHC-6’s ‘offroad’ capabilities is proving a tourist attraction. The service, subsidized annually with some £300,000, keeps Barra connected to Glasgow (230 kms away). Otherwise, one would first have to take a 25-km trip in a small ferryboat, then drive across two other islands connected by causeways to a third island, to the small airport at Benbecula from where it takes an hour’s flight to reach Glasgow. Clearly, this is not comparable to Gozo, with MIA far better connected than any southern Italian airport, only 5 kms of around-the-clock-all-weather ferry-shuttle and a few more kilometres of road away. In a non-EU case, Air Seychelles is one of the Twin Otter (re-)launch customers. Currently, ‘classic’ Twin Otters run to small islands with tiny grass strips, and on the frequent Mahe-Praslin shuttle (45 kms), a return ticket costs e140.
As mentioned above, Skybus operate from Land’s End to the Scilly Islands: e160-180 for the 50 kms return.
Many Twin Otters operate either in energy/mining support, humanitarian/crises operations, or in the wilderness of Canada, and cannot be compared to the cost pressure seen in commuter markets.
The Twin Otter has a small nature footprint. Production is being resumed. In case of commercial failure the plane can quickly be re-sold. Special voluminous tyres are optional for least load impact landings. The Saba and Paxos examples seemingly suggest a return fare of ca. e60 plus taxes.
Yet, for second-hand planes, one has utilized 20- to 40-year-old examples with according maintenance costs. The cabin standard is maybe not as high as with the three other competitors it is sufficient. “Except for exceptions” fares equal Helisureste’s.
PZL Mielec M28 Skytruck
In the 1990s, the Polish assembly firm of the Antonov 28 that went into production in the mid 1980s, carried out 40,000 improvements (Pratt&Whitney engines, US avionics, propellers, stretched and heightened fuselage), and the commercial version dubbed M28 Skytruck. It is so westernised that it even passes as “made in USA” and is fully certified by both EU and US aviation authorities.
While the Gozo heliport runway measures 180m, the Skytruck’s take-off run at sea level and standard temperature at full weight is 250 metres, and 330 metres over a 50-foot obstacle. Even the Twin Otter needs 100 metres more under equal conditions. High summer temperatures certainly influence this negatively, but at the same time one would operate far from full payload / fuel load (aircraft may operate in temperatures up to +60 deg centigrade). The landing ground roll at full weight is 240 metres with just over 500m over the obstacle. The Skytruck climbs twice as fast as the Twin Otter, is less noise polluting for residents, and has optimised safety reserves. And, in case of sudden engine failure, automatic aerodynamic devices immediately fully stabilise the plane, a feature not found in other competitors.
The advantages of the Skytruck are its short-field performance combined with grass strip capabilities meaning least environmental impact. It has high safety reserves (climb-out/engine failure and so on) and, with equal seating cross-configuration, it has a broader and higher cabin than the Twin Otter. The optional under fuselage luggage pod is necessary. It has proven itself in most hostile territory (including sloping soil runways in mountain terrain). Assembly is in the EU. The producer claims low operating costs. Actually, its predecessor An-28 uses 0.2 tons jet fuel for 40 minutes/180 kms sectors (equal to Gozo-Catania; the MAC helicopter type would use 0.6 tons). Presumably western engines and better propellers did not increase fuel burn. Pilot and mechanic training are included in price.
However, hardly any second-hand planes are available, so one needs roughly US$4-5 million. Yet leasing is also possible, and as the Skytruck has been delivered primarily to military/police/special mission operators, maybe a special offer for an inter-island shuttle EU launch-customer might be made. Re-selling an airliner-configured plane might not be as easy, particularly with old cheap Twin Otter or a newer Let 410, as most small operators don’t have the money, so leases or a buy-back clause is preferable. System-cost wise, while the aircraft might cost more, infrastructure investment is lower than with the Let: everybody knows the value of plots.
A demonstration video is available at www.skytruck.us.
Dornier 228
Produced from the early 1980s to the late 1990s in two versions (-100, 15 seats, and -200, 19 seats), production is now being resumed by Swiss concern RUAG with many Indian parts and final assembly in Germany.
Low-cost giant Air Berlin (through LGW) operates “thin” German domestic routes. For Dortmund to Sylt Island, summer return fares are e248 (saver) to e748 (flex); off peak costs e198-748 per person. This 350 kms sector is not even equal to Malta-Tunis. Düsseldorf-Erfurt, 300kms, (equal to Malta-Palermo/Tripoli) ranges between e118 and 488 return, same as Düsseldorf-Saarbrücken (230 kms, same as Malta-Pantelleria).
Manx2 links the Isle of Man with Gloucester and other UK places with Do228s contracted from Germany. The 300-km Gloucester-Jersey return costs e127-309, while Gloucester-Manx, also 300 kms, ranges between e179 and e387.
The Air Malta standard, not special, Ferragosto season Palermo-Malta (300 kms) return ranges between e130 and e150 including taxes/charges.
French Air Caraibes also operates the 228 to the 600-m St Barth strip, with fares comparable to Helisureste’s. In the 1980s, a Do 228-100 linked Hamburg with the tiny 400m Helgoland airstrip (today 480 metres), a 150-km trip.
The 228 operates on gravel strips. It offers a high cabin standard and appears more fuel-efficient than others.
Twin Otter and Skytruck remain better runway performers, though on single-engine climb-out Skytruck and Dornier lead. Fares with a low-cost celebrity speak a clear language as regards ability to compete against Air Malta.
Let 410 UVP-E20/ Let 420
Roughly, 1,200 examples of this Czech-assembled plane have been sold since the 1970s. The current models are the standard Let 410 UVP-E20 and the L420 for hot&high operations. The L410 was also mentioned at the recent presentation.
The landing distance over the standard obstacle is 425m in standard conditions and 450 in warmer temperatures for both, while for take-off the L410 UVP-E20 needs 570 metre over the obstacle plus another 100 in warm weather; with the L420 this stands at 510 to 550m. This cannot compete with Skytruck and Twin Otter but one will not operate at full fuel load (less weight = shorter runway) so dimensions would remain limited.
How about fares?
Manx2 (www.manx2.com) has Let 410s (contracted) for flights from Isle of Man to places in Britain and Ulster. The Blackpool-Isle of Man return (110 kms per sector, equal to Gozo-eventual Comiso airport) costs between e62 (tourist fare, less busy hours) and e280 (totally flexible). The carrier needs a mix.
Aeronorte runs from Vila Real in northern Portugal to Lisbon, a subsidized public service obligatory route, therefore no fare comparisons can be made. But Vila Real’s 800-m runway proving far more than necessary for the 300 kms run illustrates that less can be sufficient for a Malta shuttle.
Bulgarian Heli Air (the Gozo MAC helicopter contractor!) flies an L410 to/from Elba for the Elbafly brand. The Elba-Pisa (100 kms) and Florence (140 kms) runs cost e129 return, the 340 km run to Milan e299, plus taxes.
In the French Caribbean, Take Air also operates Let 410s to small neighbouring island States. The run from Fort de France to Dominica (90 kms per sector) starts from e75 return, St Lucia from e65 (also 90 kms) and the intra-France run to Guadeloupe (190 km) costs from e145 return. These “from” fares are not tempting offers but readily available also at short notice for all passengers on any date. One has a very high cabin standard (see www.takeairlines.com) on French registered planes with French labour. In the same environment similar operators of competing aircraft, partly of way lower standard (even single-engine), charge significantly more. Generally, the type (also older models) is proving very popular with Caribbean operators needing a cost-effective plane for short flights.
In Estonia, Avies (www.avies.ee) links two islands, primarily with Lets. The 120-km run from Tallinn to Kärdla on Hiiumaa Island costs 530 Estonian krones return; residents have a 100 krones reduction. Exchange rate being 15.64 EEK to one euro, the return fare costs e39. The 200km fare to Kuressaare/Saaremaa Island is a bit higher.
Even if there should be a subsidy in Estonia, the Malta-Gozo hop measures just a fourth of thedistance: one could be very pleased if the fare just remained so (third of Helisureste’s) or even a bit higher; see also TakeAir’s distance-fare relations.
The Let has the highest cabin standard. Grass strips are no problem. Made in the EU, it is available both new and second hand with not many hours at very competitive prices, operators available for contract work. It seems lowest-cost as regards maintenance. Fuel burn is 0.2 tons jet fuel for 40 minutes/180 kms. Gozo-Catania operations might be acceptably priced. Let’s website is www.let.cz.
Unfortunately, required runway length is noticeably longer than with Twin Otter and Skytruck, particularly with the L410, less with the L420, though still within limits.
Bigger planes
Forty-50-seater turboprops need six to eight hours daily revenue flying to be profitable. Such pressurized planes are not built for hops ‘boosting’ flight-cycle related maintenance costs making them ready for the breaker in a jiffy. With an average 15 daily flight pairs (like the MAC helicopter run; frequency is crucial, otherwise land/sea/land is faster), and just one 40-seater, no back-up, one annually has to try and fill 220,000 return seats, which is clearly unrealistic.
But still. The Greek island of Paros, with the same climatic parameters like Gozo (important for calculating required runway length), has a runway measuring 700 by 25 metres. Paros is linked by Olympic using a 40-seat Bombardier Dash 8-100. Milos has an 800m strip. Leros, just off the Turkish coast, has a runway of 1000 metres with the same service, just like Siros, Astipalea, Kassos, and others. Dash 8-100s also link Norwegian coastal communities’ 800m strips, and in North America and Australia also operating to well-prepared gravel strips.
How about fares?
The 50 kms Kos-Leros hop costs e100 return. The Athens-Paros (150 kms) return stands at e125. The 300 kms Athens-Leros return costs e20. Whether the flights are profitable, or an infrastructure measure by government and State carrier, is better not discussed.
These Aegean islands are more isolated from the centre and with a far longer time plus for air transport over the ferry than with Gozo.
Aer Arann’s ATR42 flights from Dublin to northwest countryside places Sligo (1000m runway, 180 kms flying from Dublin) and Carrickfin (Donegal, 230 kms, much more by road) are low-fare but highly subsidized. Their main operations with quite larger, very efficient ATR72s, or those of other carriers with Bombardier Q400s (70-80 seats), cannot be compared due to way lower unit costs and clearly too big for Gozo (both as regards capacity and runway length).
Subsidies
Highland Airways runs Anglesey-Cardiff with a 19-seat BAe Jetstream 31, twice daily on weekdays. While the average one-way fare is ca. £40, the Welsh authorities pay a subsidy of over £80 (ca. e100 EUR) per actually flown passenger, one-way, (annual spending is £800,000 to the carrier and £400,000 for the terminal, so over e1.5m in total). This 220kms run is not even equal to Gozo-Palermo.
If so much money would have to be provided for 10 weekly 19-seater flights bringing a handful of tourists from Sicily, there might be better use for the Gozitan people and also local business and tourism.
One can only be surprised by the EU’s fuss over the Gozo Channel Line, which provides millions of passenger trips per year. Besides the service to the community, it saves ruining both landscape and public coffers with a road project, while at the same time tolerating such things like in Wales, where necessity can in no way be compared to that for isolated small Scottish or Aegean islands.
Of airfields and racetracks
The racetrack facility near the Nadur-Victoria road occupies at least the area required for an airstrip similar in size to the Paros, maybe even the Leros, one. The more or less straight piece of road parallel to the racetrack, from the slight bend in the east to the crossing, measures 700m, the length of the Paros strip, just for dimensions. One wonders how a 1000m circuit, as long and broad as a runway for 40-seaters, was regarded as being of incomparably higher socio-economic importance than a 500 or 700m grass/gravel strip for an island community.
Financial interests in no airstrip
Quite a few make their living from the land/sea/land transport of tourists: taxis, minibuses and coach operators. Even though it only has a tiny share, all revenue counts for the ferry.
Those who own fields in approach zones will see their land depreciate in value, as it will have to remain agricultural/ODZ for operational reasons. Even though a simple ODZ landowner cannot build one still can sell the hope for development to a smart new owner with a project in mind. Homes under approach paths could lose in value and farmers might be affected.
Furthermore, one could get the heliport facility declared derelict (after all it was vandalised in September 2007, which was somehow missed by the English language press but covered by Kullhadd) and put up for sale. A construction tycoon could make plenty of money by erecting blocks of flats and garages on top of the runway, zero extra land footprint (though there will be visual impact), selling desired ‘unobstructed country views’ with plots around kept ODZ. Whether Gozo needs more flats is surely very debatable, and the heliport was built with dedication, hope and public money.
Environmental compromises
An environmental compromise could be to either lengthen the existent strip, or convert a current road into a tarmac runway by slightly broadening and resurfacing, thus using less new land than a totally new construction, or a grass/gravel strip.
One however cannot make people believe that it needs an airstrip for wild plants to grow. The goal must be minimising undeniable impact. A grass facility cannot be returned to its natural state but at least can be turned to agricultural use.
FTI (formerly Frosch), a leading tour operator that always puts more stress on Gozo than others, states in its marketing material that Gozo is far greener and quieter than Malta, explicitly mentioning the lack of an airport as a plus. A bush plane however might be less of a nuisance than heavy trucks, jackhammers, bulldozers, stone saws, and banging machines around the place.
The benefit of a direct transfer without having to climb around with luggage is undeniable, particularly for the elderly or those travelling with children. Tour operators will however not pay extortionate prices. Helisureste’s fares (e115 at max) showed according results.
Why Helisureste failed – not only fares-wise
Everybody in the business knows that tour operator contracts for hotels, flights etc. for the next summer schedule are made the summer before. Tour operator summer catalogues, printed or online, are issued in the preceding autumn.
MAC was scheduled to cease in 2003 but got an extension from parent company Air Malta, which announced, on 27 October 2003 in a press release, that the last flight would take place on 31 October 2004.
Then, instead of starting to get things fixed by spring 2004, those interested in the link apparently went on wait-and-see mode. On the last flight day all was still unclear. Helisureste did not take over a route, it had to re-start it. The agreement/announcement was so late that the opportunity of inclusion in the summer 2005 season contracts was gone, though fares spoke for themselves.
One however sometimes also wondered. In the media one read of Helisureste’s “idea” of Libya flights – competing against Air Malta and Libyan Arab?
Helisureste, “hailed” as the highly experienced firm, which it indubitably is technically, however did not have the highly experienced Air Malta marketing machine like MAC. Air Malta would have been crazy allocating its apparently reduced outstation staff (‘overstaffing’) to go around for a firm charging more than double and getting fat benefits in Malta, while their own helicopter service had been cross-financed only internally and paying full costs. The subsidies provided to the Helisureste operation quoted at the presentation made things very clear. Particularly when one recalls that those “hailing” the Helisureste service as better than MAC (which only offered higher frequency, higher reliability, more capacity, less cramped cabins, fares at a fraction, no subsidies) argued at the same time that even Air Malta’s already then very reasonable euro fares were too high.
Forcing Air Malta now into a heli-wetlease agreement would be financially irresponsible.
By the way, just remember MAC being labelled “shameful”, “the shame of the country” and so on. Time has indeed proved otherwise.
Distribution channels
Maybe Air Malta might market moderately priced Malta-Gozo flights. The small carrier would provide special fares exclusively for Air Malta passengers (with an exclusive check-through baggage agreement too); in return Air Malta outstations, an elementary factor of Malta’s tourism marketing network, could propose the service to tour operators and pre-arrange cont(r)acts and add website advertising. Air Malta would get all Gozo passengers and the small operator gets the marketing he would otherwise never have.
But Air Malta faces rocketing fuel costs, while during the last legislature got some highly subsidized parallel flights thrown against them (e.g. London), with according cost pressure, having to burn money with trash-tickets to hold market share. While fuel prices cannot be influenced, the recently announced Hamburg-Bremen to Bari swap is a welcome re-orientation.
Potential operators are all small private enterprises. They cannot risk existential consequences. There should be some guarantee or at least risk-sharing from private/public stakeholders wanting the service, or even a to-be-founded Ltd Co. (e.g. jointly owned by State, private stakeholders, with Air Malta providing marketing, maybe franchise) that would provide the plane (bought or leased), do the marketing, carry the profit/loss risk, and just have it operated/managed by a licensed contractor paid a fixed price. Without Air Malta’s marketing machine and tour operator deals it is very risky. The right timing/organisation is essential. There must be a check-through, and short transit time – no use if total travelling time is longer than overland.
The airpark
Alluding to airparks, as has happened, could prove counterproductive because people might start suspecting that a public transport flight would only be an excuse to build an airstrip, and if the service then fails, one has a hobby airstrip to build villas around and possibly a golf course attached. Hobby pilots should definitely use an airstrip too, but presumably most agree that a runway should only be built provided it is a genuine long-term public service viability prospect, and the area limited to operational necessity. Not much of Gozo’s nature is left and this should be appreciated. Sure, there are some 200 fly-in-communities in the USA, but Gozo is not America. Prospective EU airpark projects are all located in cheap abundant land area (Spanish countryside, ex-Warsaw Pact territory etc.). Dimensions of one of the very few materialising (www.murcia-fly-in.com), where even most plots are unsold, illustrate: clearly not an option for densely built-up Gozo.
A shuttle airfield needs only a tiny fraction of an airpark’s area. If genuinely wanting the air link, it is better to avoid propagating the unacceptable, otherwise one ruins acceptance for even a low impact system.
Plain sailing
Today’s ferries cannot be compared to the vessels of the 1960s (Malta-Gozo Air Service idea) or the 1990s (helicopter heyday) regarding bad weather capabilities. Gozo Channel Line does a great job for Gozo’s tourism.
A look at other EU countries shows what fixed-wing fares are like.
A private MIA-Cirkewwa minivan transfer for up to 10 people costs e90, a chauffeur-driven car return for four people e60, note, per vehicle and return, see www.maltatransfers.com or www.low-cost-transfers.com.
The Gozo Channel Line airport link costs e10 return per person, add another 8-10 euros for the ferry return: so e20 per person from MIA to Mgarr/Gozo return, and if one has to get onward transport here, so would one at an airstrip. But to reduce the undeniable hassle, maybe a smooth drive-thru service with priority boarding and something about the luggage should be done: give up the luggage at MIA, pick it up at Mgarr or Victoria immediately on arrival.
With the new ferries, how many sailings were cancelled due to inclement weather, and would flights have been possible? How much time/hassle could be saved in a well organised surface transfer?
Conclusion
If deciding for fixed-wing shuttle, then one single 19-seater, type depending on priorities, is the choice. An elderly Islander could be a stand-by-plane / low demand filler until demand justifies a second 19-seater. A low-cost, eco-sensitive infrastructure is preferable.
If the helistrip is not extended, a grass runway (lower development costs, less nature impact, more easily removable), or an asphalt runway that could partly include a country road (new surfacing and broadening, but still less new land used) should suffice. A 500m runway, just equalling a broader stretch of road, measures half the length of the racetrack. Commercial viability ignored, in Greece 700-800m runways suffice even for 40-seaters. The core is a frequent domestic shuttle.
If one has no low-cost contractor (with Let, maybe Skytruck), Air Malta marketing, tour operator contracts, well-coordinated timing of plan implementation, low airstrip development costs (Skytruck), and if not sure whether one can compete against surface transport, one might put a big question mark to it – as generally, due to costs-per-air-seat-mile, flights beyond Malta, except perhaps the Let/Skytruck to/from Catania during idle hours instead of keeping the plane parked.
While low-impact possibilities have been outlined here, with all enthusiasm and good intentions, cost is the core. Determining the long-term commercial viability in an environment of rising fuel prices, domestic competition of low-cost surface transport just needing slight optimisation, and flights beyond facing Air Malta, Virtu Ferries and Ryanair, is essential. If positive, correct distribution channel management and timing are crucial for success and avoiding an airstrip becoming a white elephant as regards public transport flights.