The San Gwann Local Council made a development application to regularise its administrative operations that were being carried out in a villa for the last 11 years without an official planning permit. The villa at No 55 Triq R. Caruana Dingli, San Gwann is in a location designated as a residential area by the North Harbours Local Plan.
The Authority refused this request. Mepa stated that the proposal could not be favourably received due to the fact that the proposed commercial floor space (121 square metres) is significantly larger than the commercial area technically permitted by policies regulating office use in residential areas in the North Harbours Local Plan (75 square metres). It is recognised that Local Plans attempt to channel office development having a floor space in excess of 75 square metres into designated town or commercial centres, irrespective of the nature of operations.
In its recommendation, Mepa’s Directorate referred to Policy NHHO 01 stipulated in the North Harbours Local Plan. This seeks to limit office use to 75 square metres when the site lies within a designated residential area, stating further that the San Gwann Local Council premises featured a net office floor area of 121 square metres, and therefore constituted bad neighbourliness.
In one of its core arguments, Mepa also stated that if the proposed change of use were to be approved, it would create a dangerous precedent for the allocation of further extensive offices in residential areas around Malta and Gozo.
The Directorate also pointed out that the proposed arrangement does not secure a fully accessible environment for all its users and cited paragraph 4.16 of the Development Control Policy and Design Guidance 2005, which requires that public buildings are accessible for all. Accessibility matters are in fact regulated by Structure Plan policy SOC 24, which requires that all public buildings to be fully accessible and designed in a way to secure sufficient accessibility standards. To this end, the architect representing the developer (in this case the Local Council) informed the Appeals Board that he was willing to adhere to such requisites and modify the plans, should the permit be granted.
The rationale underpinning Mepa’s arguments to refuse the permit was strongly repealed by the Planning Appeals Board. The Appeals Board unequivocally determined that, contrary to what was being purported by the Authority, local council offices deliver a community service to residents and therefore do not constitute bad neighbourliness. The Appeals Board also underlined that community operations cannot be placed on the same footing as purely commercial establishments. The Appeals Board also stated that the 75 square metres limitations regulating office use in residential areas are too restrictive and ordered the issue of the permit.
This decision signifies two important aspects.
In the first instance, it is immediately revealed that planning decision bodies are enticed to take a more sensible approach when dealing with requests for the provision of community facilities, rather than to adhere blindly to quantitative guidelines stipulated in Local Plans.
It is therefore acknowledged that offices serving local needs do not contribute to the degradation of our residential areas, and it goes further uncontested that in this day and age, office spaces require considerable areas to operate adequately. Rather than basing a planning decision on whether the proposed office space exceeds 75 square metres or not, planning decision bodies must establish whether the intended operations are of a local nature serving the immediate community or a targeted customer base, or intended to serve the entire nation such as the passport office or Public Registry.
On a separate, yet significant note, it must be noted that the Appeals Board accepted the architect’s request to modify plans (in this case to adhere to sufficient accessibility standards for all requirements), after the appeal was lodged. The Board’s reasoning in this respect, although running counter to the established rationale prohibiting architects to modify drawings after an appeal is lodged, portrays a very pragmatic approach on the part of the Appeals Board. It is now formally acknowledged that negative planning decisions may be overturned at Appeals stage even if the original submitted plans need to be modified in order to adhere to policy requirements, provided the architect says that he is willing to do so.
Mr Musumeci is an architect and founding partner of RMPERITI. His main area of practice is Mepa law.
[email protected]