The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

The Sun Targets Judge Giovanni Bonello

Malta Independent Sunday, 10 August 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

The Sun, Britain’s leading tabloid, has aimed its guns at the nine judges sitting in the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg who issued an interim order this week blocking the extradition of Muslim cleric Abu Hamza al-Masri from the United Kingdom to the United States.

British courts had ruled earlier that Hamza al-Masri would be extradited to the US to face charges for attempting to set up a terrorist training camp in Oregon in 1999.

The Sun let loose a tirade against the judges, and even went as far as to single out Maltese Judge Bonello – describing Malta as an “obscure country”, the judges hearing the case as “euro clowns” and even questioned the judges’ credentials to hear the case since their countries are “unlikely to be targets in the war on terror”.

The Sun’s Thursday issue dedicates both a story and a section of its editorial to venting its anger over the ECHR’s decision, which, incidentally, is not final and is merely a stopgap solution until the judges are better able to consider the case.

The tabloid’s Thursday editorial, titled “Judge Dregs”, begins with the observation that “You won’t have ever heard of 72-year-old Giovanni Bonnell (sic) from Malta. Or Ledi Bianku, 37, from Albania. But yesterday these two – plus seven other judges on the European Court of Human Rights – STOPPED the extradition of hate preacher Abu Hamza to the US.”

Describing the ruling as an “intervention” and an “outrage”, the editorial adds, “Bonnell (sic), Bianku and their chums all come from obscure countries that have never faced Islamic terrorism.”

In an article carried on the same day, titles, “Euro clowns let Hamza off hook– in a typical Sun pun Hamza al-Masri’s two partially amputated arms which have been fitted with hooks – also drives home the paper’s very questionable point that, “The nine European judges all come from countries which are unlikely to be targets in the war on terror.”

The newspaper’s website also put up a slideshow of photographs of the nine judges.

The Egyptian-born cleric is already serving a seven-year jail term in Britain for inciting followers to murder non-Muslims and racial hatred. He has been fighting extradition to the US – where he is wanted on 11 other counts including funding terrorism, organising the terrorist training camp in Oregon between 1998 and 2000 and conspiracy to take 12 Westerners hostage in Yemen in 1998 – since the request was filed in May 2004.

If convicted, Hamza al-Masri could face 100 years in jail. His lawyers, however, argue that certain aspects of the American justice system contravene the European Convention of Human Rights and that he would face inhuman and degrading treatment if sent to the US.

The other eight judges are David Björgvinsson from Iceland, Paivi Hirvelä from Finland, Nebojsa Vucinic from Montenegro, Mihai Poalelungi from Moldavia, Jan Šikuta from Slovakia, Ljiljana Mijovic from Bosnia Herzegovina, Ledi Bianku from Albania and Pole Lech Garlicki.

  • don't miss