‘A mistake to demand that all workers are retained’ – ministry
General Workers Union secretary general Tony Zarb yesterday expressed the union’s concern that that Malta Shipyards will not be used for ship repair facilities under private owners and called on the workers not to rush into the early retirement schemes offered by the government.
During a meeting held outside the dockyard, Mr Zarb also called on all former shipyard workers and those who want to support the workers to attend a meeting to be held tonight in the main square of Paola.
Addressing a crowd of workers outside the yard’s main gate – the union had originally asked the media to attend a press conference at Ghajn Dwieli – the union secretary general appealed to the government not to close the door for discussion on the shipyards’ privatisation.
“The GWU is not against privatisation or against early retirement schemes as long as these are done in the workers’ interests,” said Mr Zarb.
If there is no agreement, no one expected the cooperation of the union and the workers, he added.
Mr Zarb pointed out that the government took the decision to privatise the shipyards on its own.
“The union expects that there are work opportunities for all the employees who want to continue working,” he said.
Mr Zarb reminded the workers of various promises, particularly one made by Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi on 10 February, telling the workers to put their minds at rest.
He also quoted a statement made by Dr Gonzi on 12 February saying that there were no plans for downsizing in the shipyards.
Mr Zarb reminded the workers of a letter they each received from the prime minister on 27 February assuring them that the government will work together with them to find more work.
Referring to the call for Expression of Interest, Mr Zarb listed a number of inconsistencies found in the document. He pointed out that the government said that the present 1,700-plus workforce has to be reduced to 700. However, the document states that the government is expecting the new owner to state how many employees it would need.
The union had requested the government a copy of the report, drawn up by a number of experts, which states that the dockyard can work with 700 employees.
“For reasons only the government knows, this document has not been published yet,” said Mr Zarb.
He went on to say that the documents published by the government is pushing for a small number of workers.
“The documents clearly state that the boiler wharf and the tank cleaning section will not form part of the privatisation process. However, these sectors are essential for ship repairs – a sector which is quoted as booming in the EOI especially due to Malta’s strategic position in the Mediterranean,” said Mr Zarb.
Through its attitude, the government is reducing productivity and productive jobs with the shipyard, he added.
In a counter-statement, the Finance Ministry condemned the General Workers Union for verbally saying that it agreed with the privatisation process while at the same time underhandedly doing all it could to prevent a successful deal from being concluded.
The government also moved to allay fears of change of operation by pledging that the ‘yards are to be privatised for economic purposes tied to ship repair, super yacht repair and other related activities.
The ministry said that if one looked at the Expression of Interest issued by the government, it made itself clear in the fact that it would not be interested in considering any offers that are not related to the maritime sector.
The government also made it clear that it had to abide by the European Commission’s Transfer of Business directive whereby the company that takes ownership of the ‘yards will have to take on all workers still left on the books, with existing conditions. This, the statement said, was the precise reason why the government implemented the voluntary redundancy and early retirement schemes.
The government also reminded that at present, there are only expressions of interest and that a shortlist will be drafted in the near future.
The ministry said it would be a mistake to demand that all workers presently on the books are to be retained by the buyer, especially as it is still not known as to how many people will take up the various schemes which are on offer up to 31 October. He added that it was unrealistic to think that any company would remain interested in buying out the ‘yards if they were obliged to take on 1,700 workers.
The government also said that it wanted to see a successful privatisation of the ‘yards and was not intending to go for a half-baked and unsustainable venture. If too many workers remain on the books, said the ministry, there was a real possibility of failure of the process and said this would, in turn, lead to the ‘yards going bankrupt’.
In an appeal to the union, the ministry said that successful privatisation also hinged on a positive picture being painted about the yards. “Any intimidation of violence will tarnish the image of the yards and will have a negative impact on the impressions of potential buyers,” said the ministry.
The government said it accepted the right to freedom of expression and freedom to act, but reminded workers that there will be consequences if such actions are excessive. “No one wants to buy a company that is rife with problems, as was the case with Sea Malta,” concluded the ministry.