The Malta Independent 17 November 2026, Tuesday
View E-Paper

Privatisation Respects EU rules – government

Malta Independent Thursday, 21 August 2008, 00:00 Last update: about 14 years ago

The government yesterday replied to points made by Alternattiva Demokratika which wrote about the shipyard privatisation to EU Commissioner Vladimir Spidla, who is responsible for employment, social affairs and equal opportunities.

The finance ministry said the privatisation process undertaken by the government would fully respect the obligations of the transfer of business directive (Council Directive 2001/23EC) on the approximation of laws of the member states relating to the safeguarding of employees’ rights in the event of transfers of undertakings, businesses or parts of undertakings or businesses.

It said that bidders who will be awarded the shipyards, would have to take over the workforce should the transfer of business take place.

The statement then went on “to clarify some misconceptions” which AD seemed to have and on which it had based its letter to Commissioner Spidla.

“Neither Minister Fenech nor the government has at any point in time or in any press statement”, stated that the government had commissioned a report to justify the number of workers who would have to be made redundant prior to privatisation.

“This exercise in itself is not even possible since only the expressions of interests will shed light on what type of activity the private sector deems more viable and interested to operate and thus the number of employees that would be considered required to operate a venture viably, thus not requiring state subsidies that will be prohibited post 31 December 2008,” the statement said.

It added that before issuing the expression of interest document this was discussed with DG Competition officials.

As to how the government has arrived at the 700 employees level, the statement said, the minister had given a detailed explanation to the press on a number of occasions, and “what has been repeatedly stated was”:

1. Internal management reports made by the shipyards management, presented even to the opposition last year and tabled in parliament, clearly stated that the shipyards were still significantly over-manned and that employment levels needed to be further reduced if there were to be any hope that the shipyards would become viable.

2. Also, assessments made by other shipyards that had expressed an interest in somehow participating in the shipyards late last year, had withdrew their interest particularly because of what they deemed too high employment levels, they had then indicated that in their opinion the shipyards would not be viable with employment levels that were in the levels of more then 450 full-time employees.

3. After reviewing employment levels of other similar shipyards in the region; including Palermo (around 530), Hellenic (Greece) (around 220), and Lisnave (Portugal) (around 350), the government concluded that, although somewhat optimistic with numbers around 700, in the light of the transfer of business directive,

privatisation prospects would not be jeopardised.

The government said that failure of the privatisation process would not only mean that the workers would have no new business to go into, but would exclude the possibility for the government to offer voluntary early retirement and resignation schemes.

The government said the process that has been undertaken is not only intended to respect the social obligations emanating from EU Directive 2001/23/EC relating to the transfer of business, but rather to ensure that a successful privatisation that will allow the transfer of the remaining workers on the books of Malta Shipyards Limited to the new undertaking/s.

The government hoped that AD would appreciate that this directive applied only if a successful privatisation took place, and therefore “urges AD not to take any further unilateral initiatives that may have the intent of gaining the sympathy of the workers directly involved, but end up only jeopardising their own interest, as only a successful privatisation can ensure that the best interest of the workers opting not to take the voluntary schemes can be safeguarded”.

  • don't miss