As modernisation gains momentum, more and more of our traditionally built towns and villages are losing their unique character. “Old” buildings are being torn down and replaced by offices, showrooms, shopping centres and apartment complexes. Approval to demolish a number of Sliema houses situated in Milner and Howard Street, (contrary to Mepa’s Heritage Advisory Committee’s recommendation) is a case in point. These were projects which were initially rejected by Mepa as these houses were within the urban conservation area (UCA). However, when the local plans were revised, such houses were excluded from the UCA designation and consequently became available for redevelopment.
According to recent statistics there are as many as 23,000 empty properties, yet new ground continues to be exploited and more flats erected. It is deplorable to think that our towns and villages with their unique identities are in imminent danger of being razed to the ground and replaced by alien “architectural” monstrosities which many consider as grossly unsustainable. The government should seek to enact effective legislation as soon as possible to ensure that this will not continue, by turning down property speculation once and for all and ensure that at least a good proportion of these vacant buildings is re-used.
A planning policy on the use and applicability of the “Floor Area Ratio”, issued in May, dealt with high-rise development of more than 11 floors envisaged in nine specific sites in Marsa, Pembroke, Sliema, Tigné, Malta International Airport, Gzira, Qawra and Ricasoli and not least SmartCity. The entire urban belt including Swieqi, St Julian’s, San Gwann, Msida, Sliema, Birkirkara, Qormi, Paola, Fgura and Zabbar has been identified for medium-rise developments, which will rise from between 6 to 10 floors in areas where current height limitations does not exceed five floors.
Technologically we are therefore gradually moving towards adopting high-rise buildings, high-income luxury condominiums commonly featuring in virtually every mid to large size city across the continent. Apart from the spectacular views they offer, tall buildings make too much sense from an economic point of view particularly in this day and age when land is too scarce and too expensive. Blind imitation of foreign architectural styles is however by no means modernisation.
High-rises vary in size, height, construction, occupancy type and design features. On the one hand high-rises offer advantages such as saving on land space, economise on infrastructure and services costs; however they also present several challenges to overcome. It is difficult to make them efficient in alternative energy use such as tapping solar energy due to the poor ratio between roof size and the rest of the building while it creates undesirable shade to nearby low lying buildings that use solar equipment.
To some, including planners, architects and politicians, high buildings are considered inappropriate. Some cities, such as Toronto, have at one time or other enacted temporary height restriction by-laws, fearing the quality of life will be affected by tall buildings. Other cities, such as Paris, have for aesthetic reasons passed restrictive laws limiting building height on a permanent basis to preserve the character of their historic downtown cores.
Yet the trend worldwide is fast moving towards going larger and higher. Much thought has to be put into
the outer appearance of high-rise
residential/office towers to project an image of supremacy and style as part of the marketing strategy. Just as much, needs to be put into the way such buildings interact with existing streetscapes, neighbouring buildings, and transportation systems around them. Whether we should go for high-rise buildings or not may not be the fundamental issue to consider these days as where to build them, especially when it comes to residential high-rise structures within Urban Conservation areas.
High-rise buildings may have considerable success locally if properly planned according to the perceived country’s needs. While there could be sufficient grounds to consider raising building heights in some localities, this should be done within a holistic planning envelope to ensure least socio-environmental impact within the involved localities.
Roderick Galdes is the Opposition Spokesman on Planning