When on 7 August Mikhail Saakashvili felt confident enough by the closeness of the relationship with the West and took a gamble, ordering the offensive against separatist South Ossetia thinking that Russia would hesitate to respond, little did he know that Russia got what it wanted, the pretence to unleash an aggressive attack on Georgia out of all proportions.
The map drawn up in 1992 after the collapse of the Soviet Union to the current state which the West took to be permanent was only a temporary phenomenon for Russia. After this war the fact is that it is not going to remain as it was.
The events we witnessed in Georgia may be only the start of Moscow’s attempt to regain complete control in the region. Russia’s actions have undermined regional security; threatened the vital oil pipelines through these regions and shown disregard for international law. They have also made claims on ethnic Russians and other minorities that could be used to destabilise other former Soviet republics, including Ukraine. At the same time Moscow’s concerns that the West seems to have taken advantage of its weakness, ignored its interests, maintained NATO in an unnecessarily confrontational way and its encirclement with states sitting American missiles cannot be ignored.
The crisis raises serious issues about Moscow’s intentions with the rights of other states bordering Russia. On 26 August, Russian President Dmitri Medvedev approved a parliamentary resolution to formally recognise the independence of Georgia’s two separatist regions — Abkhazia and South Ossetia, disregarding calls for restraint from various quarters. The move is surely to create tension in the Caucasus and increase the deterioration of Russia’s relations with the West. Legally both regions of Abkhazia and South Ossetia are considered part of Georgia, although Tbilisi lost control over them during two brief wars in the early 1990s. The Georgian government has accused Moscow of attempting to illegally append the two regions. This is possible by granting citizens in the conflict zones Russian passports, paying pensions and providing other financial assistance.
One may say that the Russia-Georgia conflict is transforming the contemporary geopolitical world. We are now faced with an international challenge. This challenge is not only to restore peace and stability in Georgia through the immediate implementation of the ceasefire accord, but to seriously address the more fundamental questions the conflict raises for security in Europe The short-term problem may be how to support Georgia without completely alienating Moscow. The longer-term problem will be whether Europe can maintain a healthy relationship with Moscow without completely putting in jeopardy its own and the West’s democratic values and showing a common unified front.
It seems that Georgia is dividing the EU instead of uniting it. While some countries, including Britain, Poland and the three Baltic States, are pushing for the EU to take a harder line which would involve putting negotiations on an EU-Russia partnership treaty on hold, France, Germany and Italy advocate a more cautious approach.
At the same time Moscow could be trying to drive a wedge between America and Europe while Vladimir Putin, the Prime Minister who is still regarded as the ultimate Russian power, is banking on European distaste for confrontation to ensure that Moscow gets its way.
A top priority will be not only to forge consensus on how the EU should respond to Russia’s actions but also to send a message to the United States that while the isolation of Russia is no solution however the common interest of the West is not being put in question. The EU will also have to pronounce itself that any contraventions by Russia to the ceasefire will not be accepted.
This will require a balanced policy of the EU taking into consideration that Russia must be understood and contained, rather than confronted, but clear enough to Moscow that the regions’ vulnerability to Russia’s pressure must end. Europe must show clearly that it is prepared to affront any situation that could threaten its vital interests and those of the West.
Much is at stake. This is no longer a small war in the Caucasus, a minor ethnic squabble. A situation has developed that could greatly worsen the already tense relations between Russia, Europe and the United States. It looks like there was a break in diplomacy and the EU has to make sure that a new mechanism is created to avoid any future repetitions. Nobody needs a war in Europe at this time.
David Casa is a Nationalist MEP
www.davidcasa.eu
[email protected]