While Prime Minister Lawrence Gonzi says he wants a smaller role for the government in the economy, the economic expansion he lays claim to is coming mainly from the government’s own expenditure. And Finance Minister Tonio Fenech, who prefers making comparisons over 12-month periods, also boasted of the 3.2 per cent expansion compared to the same period last year.
Gavin Gulia, Labour Party spokesman for the economy and the self-employed, pointed out that the government was not saying however, that expansion had weakened since September, 2007, when the rate was four per cent, compared to today’s 3.2 per cent, and it was not saying either which sectors of the economy were expanding.
On the expenditure side between April and June, the expansion was due mainly to inventories – production which lay unsold and lay stacked on the shelves. This contributed to six per cent of the 3.2 per cent economic expansion.
As had happened in the first three months, the government’s expenditure had soared, contributing directly to expansion statistics. In fact 56 per cent of the expansion was not due to the private sector but to government expenditure, in spite of Dr Gonzi’s wish for a smaller government role in the economy.
Dr Gulia said that in the meantime investment had decline in the second quarter, as had exports which increasingly were declining at a more rapid rate, to 11.4 per cent in the second quarter of 2008.
The rate of economic decline in the second quarter occurred in all sectors, except financial services and in wholesale and retail. The sectors which showed drastic falls in value added were construction, which from 17.3 per cent expansion declined to 1.4 per cent, agriculture and fisheries from 10 per cent to just over three per cent, and transport and communications, which from an expansion of just over 14 per cent in the first quarter had gone down to five per cent.
The sector which fared worse was manufacturing, Dr Gulia said. An expansion of one per cent in value added in the first quarter had become a decline of 1.4 per cent in the second, with reductions in wages and profits.
Tourism too had shown a decline in value added expansion, from almost 11 per cent to eight per cent, because of the drop in wages expansion.
The economic expansion was spurred mostly by a rise in public sector earnings, higher profits in online gaming, “other business services”, and a large increase in the profits of the wholesale and retail sector. The latter sector needed analysis to see how it had registered a record rise of 22 per cent in profits.
In a counter-statement, Finance Minister Tonio Fenech said Dr Gulia’s claim was wrong.
Official figures by the National Statistics Office show that Malta’s economic expansion was also the result of a rise of four per cent in agriculture, a rise of 16.1 per cent in construction, of 14.4 per cent in the wholesale and retail sector, of 8.0 per cent in hotels and restaurants, of five per cent in transport and communications, of 6.9 per cent in financial services, and a rise of 8.3 per cent in the property sector.
Mr Fenech said that what interested the citizen most, apart from the figures leading to this expansion, was the result of that expansion, which was the creation of employment. That is why it was satisfactory to the minister to note that during this period more jobs were created, with some 3,000 full-time jobs created over the last year, 2,000 of them being taken up by women.
This led to a cut in unemployment to 5,958, which was much lower than the average for 2007 – 6,686 unemployed; or for 2006 – 7,326 unemployed.
Considering the challenges the country faced, both from the financial crises and the competition of the globalised world, it was positive that, contrary to what was happening in Europe, the Maltese economy continued expanding satisfactorily and continued creating more jobs and better-quality work.